5 ms·
Is it OK to forgive the dozens of incompetent car drivers who kill people on a daily basis? And if not, how would you feel if each fatal accident was given such
by danso 13y ago
Is it OK to forgive the dozens of incompetent car drivers who kill people on a daily basis? And if not, how would you feel if each fatal accident was given such national news treatment (if there were enough bandwidth to do so, which, theoretically, there is)
My comment is not about the culpability of the pilots, but the long recognized psychological phenomenon of overestimating risk probabilities due to increased "hearing of" incidents, rare or not, the cause being irrelevant.
- ekianjo 13y agoBecause each driver is not responsible for 300 lives in their cars. That's why there is so much attention to plane crashes. It doesn't kill one person at a time. Besides, it's incredible such an accident happen when the weather is perfect, there is no wind, it's not at night, the plane is working just fine, and it's just a couple of pilots who don't know what they are doing because they don't know how to land a plan manually since they are used to pressing buttons the whole time and relyong on autopilot. That's what the news is about. Just like the AF447 crash between Rio and Paris: Pilots incompetence at its best.
- TallGuyShort 13y agoDid you read this article? And if so, do you have any more well thought out arguments against that author's point? His whole point is that this type of landing is not uncommon and there is little reason at this point that it had anything to do with the pilot's experience. It's still possible, yes, but you're making statements that indicate you understand neither the article nor the comments to which your are responding. People are explaining why there is a media frenzy around the accident, not why it's okay. Trolling, at its best.
- ekianjo 13y agoYes, I have read the article, and this final statement is ignorance at its best: "Whatever happened on final approach into SFO, I highly doubt that it was anything related to the culture of Korean air safety in 2013. Plane crashes are increasingly rare the world over. But they will continue to happen from time to time, and no airline or country is 100 percent immune. " There were clear indications from the communication with the air tower that the pilots did not communicate any emergency situation until 1.5 seconds before the crash, and that the co-pilot was apparently silent in the cockpit. Check the Los Angeles times article about that. It's clearly linked to cultural aspects, all over again.
- potatolicious 13y agoI do not make this accusation lightly - but this strikes me as a particularly racist thing to say. Your argument boils down to "because the co-pilot was silent during the crash this points to deficiencies in Korean culture". Which is a wild leap no matter which way you cut it. But I mean, congrats I guess. You were looking for a conclusion and unsurprisingly you found it.
- ekianjo 13y agoWhere did i imply racism? Culture has not only to do with nationality, its also part of education, training, and skills when interacting with others. This kind of accidents can happen in all cockpits where there is no open critique and communication.
- ddunkin 13y agoThat's exactly what we had in the 80s, a deficient culture in the cockpit, a bunch of hot shot pilots who 'didn't want to be told what to do' and would ignore co-pilot advice. I'm not surprised another country has these same hurdles to overcome.
- silencio 13y agoBut Korean Air at least, and Korean pilots have already faced that hurdle (if they aren't already the poster children for culture issues among pilots), and if it comes down to a cultural issue again I'll be more than a little surprised. Can't find the link I originally saw that went into this in more detail, but the basic subject is covered here: http://blogs.wsj.com/middleseat/2008/12/04/malcolm-gladwell-on-culture-cockpit-communication-and-plane-crashes/ http://blogs.wsj.com/middleseat/2008/12/04/malcolm-gladwell-... More on the business side here: http://www.nytimes.com/2002/03/26/business/new-standards-mean-korean-air-is-coming-off-many-shun-lists.html http://www.nytimes.com/2002/03/26/business/new-standards-mea...
- cpncrunch 13y agoPrepare to be surprised: http://www.pprune.org/rumours-news/518568-asiana-flight-crash-san-francisco-63.html#post7931852 http://www.pprune.org/rumours-news/518568-asiana-flight-cras...
- fname 13y agoBecause each driver is not responsible for 300 lives in their cars. That's why there is so much attention to plane crashes. It doesn't kill one person at a time. Right.. and this crash only killed 2 people. Perhaps one if the reports of the girl being hit by a rescue vehicle are believed; so what's your point? The real story is just how better aircraft safety has come over the years. This same accident years ago could very well have killed everyone aboard. Just like the AF447 crash between Rio and Paris: Pilots incompetence at its best. ...and a week after this accident everyone was blaming the weird weather that happens at the equator for the crash. The point is that everyone is speculating, even you, that this this accident is the pilot's fault, but more often than not it's found to be a combination of mechanical failure and the pilot not being able to respond to it quickly enough -- which just so happens to be the official cause of AF447 crashing in 2009.
- ekianjo 13y agoIt's obvious they have been very lucky on the landing. It could have turned out in an explosion and kill half of the passengers. It doesn't excuse anything.
- deathcakes 13y agoIt certainly doesn't excuse your profound and distressing ignorance and belligerence. The facts are that you are not a pilot, were not there, have not received an official statement from the parties involved and are merely voicing an opinion based on what little information the mainstream press has been able to glean in the time since the accident. Air disaster investigations typically take a while. Most reach conclusions that are extremely non obvious, nor intuitive. I recommend, for the sake of my own sanity and the rest of the people you inflict your opinion on, that you read the following books: http://www.amazon.co.uk/Air-Disaster-Vol-Macarthur-Job/dp/1875671110 http://www.amazon.co.uk/Air-Disaster-Vol-Macarthur-Job/dp/18... http://www.amazon.co.uk/books/dp/1875671196 http://www.amazon.co.uk/books/dp/1875671196 There is a third volume available as well if you can stick it out, but perhaps you may gain some much needed perspective.
- marvin 13y agoDoctors make mistakes. Programemrs make mistakes. Pilots make mistakes. In fact, if you can actually get an airline pilot in a relaxed situation where he's certain you won't rat him out, you'll hear lots of stories about stupid mistakes. The fact that this inevitable human error almost never results in fatalities is a testament to the level of redundancy in air traffic procedures. As a case in point, I talked to a pilot in one of Europe's major low-price carriers. They had an incident where both pilots literally fell asleep in the cockpit and were intercepted by German jets. Apart from the jet fighter escorts, the passengers never knew anything was off.
- pbreit 13y ago"plane is working just fine" This you know how?
- ekianjo 13y agoSee https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6013520 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6013520 It certainly does not look like plane failure.
- pbreit 13y agoPilots suggest plane slowed despite presence of auto-throttle: http://www.cnn.com/2013/07/10/us/asiana-airlines-crash/ http://www.cnn.com/2013/07/10/us/asiana-airlines-crash/ My point is, it is premature to rule out aircraft problems.