6 ms·
> But consider for a moment the year 1985, one of the darkest ever for commercial air travel. By the end of that year, 27 crashes had resulted in the deaths of
by danso 13y ago
> But consider for a moment the year 1985, one of the darkest ever for commercial air travel. By the end of that year, 27 crashes had resulted in the deaths of almost 2,400 people. These included the Air India bombing over the North Atlantic, with 329 casualties, and, two months later, the crash of Japan Airlines Flight 123 outside Tokyo, with 520 dead. (These, the second- and fifth-deadliest incidents in aviation history, happened 49 days apart.) Also in 1985 were the Arrow Air disaster in Newfoundland that killed more than 240 U.S. servicemen, the infamous British Airtours 737 fire, and the crash of a Delta Air Lines L-1011 in Dallas that killed 137.
Wow, the number of fatalities that year is incomprehensible by today's standards. Yes, this accident has made big news because so few accidents have happened in this decade...but I'd say that today's news cycle has served to amplify just about everything, no matter what their statistical, relative, or absolute significance.
- ekianjo 13y agoSo it's ok to forgive Pilots' incompetence just because statistics say it doesn't happen a lot?
- danso 13y agoIs it OK to forgive the dozens of incompetent car drivers who kill people on a daily basis? And if not, how would you feel if each fatal accident was given such national news treatment (if there were enough bandwidth to do so, which, theoretically, there is) My comment is not about the culpability of the pilots, but the long recognized psychological phenomenon of overestimating risk probabilities due to increased "hearing of" incidents, rare or not, the cause being irrelevant.
- ekianjo 13y agoBecause each driver is not responsible for 300 lives in their cars. That's why there is so much attention to plane crashes. It doesn't kill one person at a time. Besides, it's incredible such an accident happen when the weather is perfect, there is no wind, it's not at night, the plane is working just fine, and it's just a couple of pilots who don't know what they are doing because they don't know how to land a plan manually since they are used to pressing buttons the whole time and relyong on autopilot. That's what the news is about. Just like the AF447 crash between Rio and Paris: Pilots incompetence at its best.
- TallGuyShort 13y agoDid you read this article? And if so, do you have any more well thought out arguments against that author's point? His whole point is that this type of landing is not uncommon and there is little reason at this point that it had anything to do with the pilot's experience. It's still possible, yes, but you're making statements that indicate you understand neither the article nor the comments to which your are responding. People are explaining why there is a media frenzy around the accident, not why it's okay. Trolling, at its best.
- ekianjo 13y agoYes, I have read the article, and this final statement is ignorance at its best: "Whatever happened on final approach into SFO, I highly doubt that it was anything related to the culture of Korean air safety in 2013. Plane crashes are increasingly rare the world over. But they will continue to happen from time to time, and no airline or country is 100 percent immune. " There were clear indications from the communication with the air tower that the pilots did not communicate any emergency situation until 1.5 seconds before the crash, and that the co-pilot was apparently silent in the cockpit. Check the Los Angeles times article about that. It's clearly linked to cultural aspects, all over again.
- potatolicious 13y agoI do not make this accusation lightly - but this strikes me as a particularly racist thing to say. Your argument boils down to "because the co-pilot was silent during the crash this points to deficiencies in Korean culture". Which is a wild leap no matter which way you cut it. But I mean, congrats I guess. You were looking for a conclusion and unsurprisingly you found it.
- ekianjo 13y agoWhere did i imply racism? Culture has not only to do with nationality, its also part of education, training, and skills when interacting with others. This kind of accidents can happen in all cockpits where there is no open critique and communication.
- rquantz 13y agoThis is about how we deal with the news, not how an airline should discipline pilots who screw up.
- TallGuyShort 13y agoI don't believe that is even close to what he was saying.
- potatolicious 13y agoThis is orthogonal to the original argument, but yes, we should forgive pilot error, because mistakes are not necessarily a demonstration of incompetence. Life, and all subcomponents of life, is one giant ball of probabilities. Training, preparation, and planning all go towards decreasing the probability of undesirable events, but they do not rule them out entirely. This includes plane crashes, car crashes, or even scraping your knee. Professional football players don't play perfectly every game. Olympic athletes still make mistakes despite years of daily training. And you still have major bugs in your codebase - would you describe yourself as incompetent? Mistakes happen. Accidents happen. So long as we can confidently determine that it is accidental rather than systemic (i.e., incompetence), we learn from it and keep going. But nevermind all that. Let's hang a sign around their necks, parade them in the streets, let people throw things at them, and then execute them publicly.
- goodcanadian 13y agoPerhaps more to the point, no single error should ever destroy an aircraft. As the parent points out, people make mistakes. This is not news, and good systems (including aircraft) are designed to allow for that. So, even if pilot error was a contributing factor, I find it very hard to believe that nothing else went wrong. There were at least two people in the cockpit as well as controllers on the ground. No one was worried until a few seconds before the crash.
- sokoloff 13y agoAgree that a single, simple error has little chance to down a modern transport aircraft. It's almost always a chain of errors, each necessary but only jointly sufficient. I realize that not all the facts are in, and the NTSB full process will take quite some time, but I believe that once all the facts are in, you will find this to be a stunning display of lack of basic airmanship skills. Why would no one on the ground warn the flight? The altitude transmitted to ATC radar is in hundred foot increments and the high and fast on initial won't trigger an alert, once they pull the power off and try to capture the appropriate vertical profile, ATC radar has no information that anything is wrong, then when they start blowing through the vertical profile, there's not enough resolution to trigger a low altitude alert. More fundamentally perhaps, it's not ATC's job to fly the plane. ATC keeps planes separated; pilots fly them. On a clear-and-a-million day, and an 11,000 foot runway, the crew couldn't manage a visual approach. There was more than one error, but I think the NTSB findings on probable cause will overhwelminginly find the failures to be in the forward portion of the aircraft, immediately behind the yokes. (It is hard to fathom.)
- todayiscrown 13y agoFor everybody talking about pilot error, please note that none of us have full info. Just as another datapoint read this http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2357585/Crash-landing-San-Francisco-mirrors-Boeing-777-crash-London-Heathrow-years-ago.html http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2357585/Crash-landin... Same type of plane( yes different type of engines) , same type of issues while landing. I am not suggesting that sfo crash was due to engine failure. I am just suggesting that we all should wait for the investigation to conclude.
- snom380 13y agoWhile we don't yet know the details, have enough information to say that 1) the approach was unstabilized, 2) the engines provided thrust when they initiated a go-around (too late), 3) no emergency was declared before the accident happened unlike the BA accident. The only thing in common with these two accidents is that they are the same model of airplane and that both landed short of the runway. We don't know whether it was pilot error, but it looks very unlikely to be the same problem, especially since Boeing reviewed all 777 aircraft after that accident. A third option of course is that the root cause was not found in the earlier investigation and that there is a different problem affecting the type, but so far pilot error seems to be the most likely cause.
- nawitus 13y agoIt's not the same problem, as the engines responsed to thrust. The pilots applied thrust 8 seconds before impact, and the engines revved up to about 50% in that time.
- snom380 13y agoThat's exactly what I'm saying :)
- fnordfnordfnord 13y agoDo we know if that is a reasonable rate of acceleration for a 777 engine?
- josephlord 13y ago> Yes, this accident has made big news because so few accidents have happened in this decade... And there is video footage of it happening. Never underestimate the how much excitement there is in news rooms where there is actually video of the news that isn't just people talking. Yes the news cycle amplifies everything but when they have video the volume goes to 11 (or beyond)!
- newbie12 13y agoSo true. There was another plane crash that killed ten people in Alaska over the weekend...even though it was more deadly it hasn't gotten the same coverage, in some measure because there's no video of the accident.
- bedhead 13y agoI think the issue is that major airline crashes are so relatable since many people fly on a major carrier every so often. "It could've been me" plays. On the other hand, very, very few people take air taxis in Alaska.
- nawitus 13y agoThere are still quite a lot of bigger accidents, but since they happen in Africa and Asia, they're not that big news in the West. For example, 2012: * April 20 – Bhoja Air Flight 213, a Boeing 737, crashes near Chaklala airbase, Rawalpindi, Punjab, Pakistan reportedly due to bad weather, killing all of the 127 passengers and crew on board. * May 9 – In the Mount Salak Sukhoi Superjet 100 crash, a Sukhoi Superjet 100 crashes into Mount Salak, Indonesia on an exhibition flight, killing all 45 passengers and crew on board. * June 3 – Dana Air Flight 992, a McDonnell Douglas MD-83 carrying 146 passengers and 7 crew members crashes in a suburb of Lagos, Nigeria on approach to Murtala Muhammed International Airport, killing all on board and an estimated 6 more people on the ground. Of course, air safety has been greatly improved, but it's not like these larger accidents are unheard of.