5 ms·
I must be new here, this is first time I've seen a post [dead]. Does this count as "the community defending itself"? This article was the top link when I first
by DougBTX 18y ago
I must be new here, this is first time I've seen a post [dead]. Does this count as "the community defending itself"? This article was the top link when I first saw it, I found it a good read. Not even any distracting ads.
Anyone have a link to the list of [dead] articles?
- gaius 18y agoI believe there is a "showdead" feature. Seriously, tho', Chomsky? Would an Ann Coulter diatribe last as long?
- gojomo 18y agoI love the idea that Chomsky fills the Coulter niche for a certain audience.
- jibiki 18y ago> the Coulter niche for a certain audience Michael Moore is the closest I could come up with. What makes Coulter unique is that she actively tries to offend liberals. I can't really think of anyone famous for trying to offend conservatives (although lots of people have become "almost famous" that way.)
- gojomo 18y agoThey're not alike in their tones or most famous aspects -- but their appeal to their ardent fans is similar. "Here's truth that the [corporate|liberal] media contrives to obscure." Each offers a mostly self-consistent (but in other ways bizarro) world to make their audiences feel among the enlightened minority. I happen to think both sometimes make useful and thought-provoking points, though followup conversations about them are prone to derailment into all sorts of superficial reactions and over-rehearsed ideological set-pieces.
- berntb 18y agoI agree with "both sometimes make useful and thought-provoking points". The problem is that these people create true believers. The world could really use sane alternate viewpoints -- and we mainly get lots of conspiracy theorists unable to change viewpoints.
- MaysonL 18y agoI would be interested in a citation for this observation as far as Coulter goes.
- berntb 18y agoI am European, so the only thing I know about Coulter is that she is some form of right wing crazy; a less formally polite Chomsky... :-) That is also more than I care to know; the US extreme left/right looks equally insane. I just wish neither was popular here. But I guess you get the good with the bad. I agreed with a quote as a way of saying that they generate hypotheses that probably aren't correct, but potentially fruitful to work from.
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- madair 18y agoMe too. It really shook me to the core when it suddenly turned up dead since I found it such an interesting read, and I couldn't understand what seemed to be arbitrary deletion. I guess I gotta read more about HN works and why such things can go from #1 to dead in moments.