2 ms·
I can mostly grok the scope of the error and the theory behind it...what's more interesting to me is to hear, preferably from the Cryptocat developers, what led
by danso 13y ago
I can mostly grok the scope of the error and the theory behind it...what's more interesting to me is to hear, preferably from the Cryptocat developers, what led to this error? An accidental regression? A deliberate decision? Cryptocat and what it aims to do is respectable, but I think what concerns people outside of the project is the prospect of unknown unknowns in the rest of the code: are the recent bug revelations indicative of endemic blind spots?
- sirsar 13y agoOff-by-one errors are very common (and they have a long history). My best guess is "an honest mistake." As for the "endemic blind spots," any crypto software needs professional reviews and a good deal of time before it can be used in critical situations.
- tptacek 13y agoYes. A pro friend of mine is fond of saying: budget 10x to design, 1x to implementation, and 10x to verification.