4 ms·
Yes, it is in fact, possible they are just wrong. It took at least two supreme court decisions to sort out the court of claims and the bankruptcy court :) Cou
by DannyBee 13y ago
Yes, it is in fact, possible they are just wrong. It took at least two supreme court decisions to sort out the court of claims and the bankruptcy court :)
Court of claims is a article 3 court, per Glidden Co. v. Zdanok.
Congress can certainly create new article 3 courts, since it has the power to create 'inferior courts'. It's just not clear what happened here. The statute does not make clear, and even if it claimed one or the other article, at least Ex Parte Bakelite would imply it doesn't matter.
The only circuits to consider it have found FISC an article 3 court, based on the idea that congress assigned article 3 judges to it, and the 9th circuit holding that the judges are still article 3 judges while sitting on FISC (this is different than say, an Administrative law judge, who is an article 1 judge, even if working for an article 3 federal court).
The cases you want to read are Glidden, Ex parte Bakelite Corp, and Northern Pipeline Co. v. Marathon Pipe Line Co.
Ex parte Bakelite says:
"he argument is fallacious. It mistakenly assumes that whether a court is of one class or the other depends on the intention of Congress, whereas the true test lies in the power under which the court was created and in the jurisdiction conferred."
It's also from 1929.
I'm a bit too busy to go shepardize it to see what else pops up other than the major decisions i listed.
This is not my area of law, obviously. Everything I know here is from random con law study.
- tptacek 13y agoThrilled to have more reading material. Thanks!
- cpleppert 13y ago>>It's just not clear what happened here Do you mean that the statue or intention of congress was unclear or that it doesn't matter whether it is an article III court or not? There is a tremendous amount of evidence that congress intended the FISC to be an article III court. Objections were raised specifically on the basis that it would extend the judiciary into policy making or not be a constitutional valid subject for an article III court. Several courts since the 1980s have considered the claim that it is not an article III court and have rejected the argument every time it has been raised. (see United States V. Megahey or the second circuit appeal) I think it is an important question for a couple reasons: 1) the minimization procedures that the court must approve are an extension of the warrant power that the court is granted to satisfy the fourth amendment. 2) the warrant power itself is generally understood to require a judge where a warrant is required in the first place(see keith 1972). Of course, there are cases where it is possible that an independent officer(not a judge) can satisfy this requirement but it is difficult to see how judicial oversight can be excluded in this case. 3) congress intended (by the committee reports) that judicial oversight was the only valid means by which the executive could be checked. Simply requiring documents wasn't enough for congress. EDIT: reply to below I understand the requirement that the constitution sets out for judges to apply to them specifically and not to any individual court. Thus temporary courts or tribunals(composed of judges that were appointed to other courts) can act as a proper article III court. In terms of the subject matter of article III courts the constitution says that: "The judicial Power shall extend to all Cases, in Law and Equity, arising under this Constitution, the Laws of the United States, and Treaties made, or which shall be made, under their Authority;" I don't think it requires that every court necessarily can consider all cases that the judicial power is entitled to hear; it only acts as to set out what the maximum subject matter that a federal court can consider. There are other courts like the FISC/FISCR that also have limited subject matter jurisdiction under statute such as the United States Court of International Trade that only hears customs cases yet it also an article III court.
- tptacek 13y agoHelp me understand how Congress can create an inferior federal court that isn't subject to the rules of Article III? Doesn't an Article III court require appointment by the President, confirmation by the Senate, lifetime tenure, and power over all cases arising under the Constitution? Thanks for Megahey! Reading now.
- DannyBee 13y agoMaybe i'm missing it (i just skimmed it), but where did Megahey's appeal consider whether it was an article III court? I'm looking at 743 F.2d 59
- tptacek 13y agoTo your later reply: it sure seems like you're right about the notion of specialized Article III courts. And the fact that FISC judges are part-timers drawn from the federal bench somewhat mitigates the tenure concern. But how do you get around the non-Presidential appointment, and the lack of Senate confirmation? FISC can't possibly set a president that a party with a veto-proof majority can create speciality courts to isolate specific controversies appointed by random people without Senate confirmation, can it?
- dragonwriter 13y agoThere is no Constitutional requirement that inferior court judges be Presidentially appointed or confirmed by the Senate; of judges, that is only Constitutionally mandated for those of the Supreme Court, beyond that "the Congress may by law vest the appointment of such inferior officers, as they think proper, in the President alone, in the courts of law, or in the heads of departments." (Art. II, Sec. 2) > FISC can't possibly set a president that a party with a veto-proof majority can create speciality courts to isolate specific controversies appointed by random people without Senate confirmation, can it? I think you mean "precedent" rather than "president"; in any case, the authority to do that (assuming "random people" means the President, executive department heads, or the courts) is expressly in the Constitution and doesn't need the precedent of the FISC.
- 13y ago