3 ms·
It's easy for self-styled intellectuals to focus on the most complicated forces in a topic, so it makes sense that they would miss the forest for the trees by f
by rhizome 13y ago
It's easy for self-styled intellectuals to focus on the most complicated forces in a topic, so it makes sense that they would miss the forest for the trees by focusing on the law in this case. It allows a tangled web of objects to be connected in order to allow pre-existing preferences to be restyled into a dry logic, like postmodern theory or a positive Michael Buble review.
The word "relevant" is used in so many different ways because it's an adjective. You don't say "look at how many different meanings there are for the word, 'green': green cars, green makeup, green grass." The word, "relevant" is the same way, except that it takes two nouns or noun phrases, necessarily, because the only meaning of the word is to describe that they are connected, that they are germane to each other.
"[R]elevance is germane to college admissions" is a meaningless phrase because "relevant" and "germane" are somewhat synonyms. "Relevance is relevant to evidentiary rules." OK.
The context here is an argument of what the terms of relationship are and whether and what those have been changed to. The Terry test speaks to what the surveillance is relevant to. It's not a change in the meaning of Terry, it's a change in the relationship of the surveillance to a particular standard. It could be Terry, it could be something else, but at the end of the day, in the equation "X is relevant to Y," Y is the thing that's changing (or missing, if you follow emptywheel).
- tptacek 13y agoI think I get what you're saying; you don't care what the law says, because you believe surveillance on the NSA's scale is wrong. I'm not sure who you think you're arguing with. You indulge the nitty-gritty detail of the topic I'm discussing anyways, in order to dismiss what I said. But your dismissal doesn't make any sense; you appear incapable of comprehending that there's a second order of relevance at play in cases determining what "relevant" means to different circumstances. Is the color of someone's hair relevant to predicting their performance on a job? Objection! Requires court to recursively evaluate concept of relevance! Overruled. I don't know who you're referring to when you point to "self-styled intellectuals", but if it's a participant on this thread, I'd note that nobody here has taken to calling you names.
- rhizome 13y agoYou're arguing for sophistry in service of authority, in bad faith I might add. You know what my motivations are just like you do for "lay journalists," but at least I engaged the argument in detail and with respect to your terms. And that's a pretty funny implication: "I only called other people names." I guess I should apologize if my first paragraph broke your brain, it was the last part I wrote and I almost didn't include it.
- mpyne 13y agoThe same 'sophistry' that might serve authority here may be the sophistry that goes against authority elsewhere in the legal framework, so I'd be careful about drawing additional inferences from what tptacek has written. He's describing how the law actually is, whether you agree with it or not. A notable example is "treason", which has a very precise definition that is not friendly to authority. Have you read legal code, by any chance? Often modern laws include at the beginning of each section a wordy definition of what each term actually means, despite each of those terms having perfectly good and reasonable meanings in the common vernacular. It is later in accordance with those terms that the court interprets the law (assuming, of course, that the law is not deemed unconstitutional). Given that plethora of examples of this in the law (and case law) I don't see how pointing out that legal principles are being misapplied is somehow subservient to authority. The journalists have tried to explain things in the context of legal principles and not reason, so they should be evaluated on legal principles. Otherwise we risk people trying to rely on that flawed logic in the courts in good faith, with nothing to show for it, when they should have been taking action that had a shot at success.
- rhizome 13y agoHuh? Sorry, while I should probably just bow out, I have no idea what the substance here is. It reads as metacommentary to me.
- mpyne 13y agoTo rephrase, the article seems written from the idea that the journalists have found some innovative change in how the law was applied by the FISC. But it's not really innovative since the journalists didn't understand the reason why 'relevant' in this context would not be the same 'relevant' from the Supreme Court case they were discussing. They are trying to play law and messed it up, must like the first time I used Python I messed it up because I didn't realize that it's pointers, pointers everywehre. So PRISM and all the rest may very well be bullshit, but it will be because it's actually bullshit and not because (in this case) some reporters have spotted some glaring bright-line change instituted by a panel of 12 judges. The risk with these types of arguments is that the technically skilled opponent points out the flaw in your reasoning and derails the whole thing, even though your overall point may have actually been valid. In this case, the government can go 'No conspiracy here, the reporters didn't understand that the definition of relevance for these cases comes from <whatever case law>, so all hunky-dory now, eh. Oh look, Egypt!'