4 ms·
There's no way the Supreme Court would arrive to the same conclusion and definition of "relevant". This is why this stuff needs to be open to the public.
by mtgx 13y ago
There's no way the Supreme Court would arrive to the same conclusion and definition of "relevant". This is why this stuff needs to be open to the public.
- rhizome 13y agoThat's exactly why it isn't.
- tptacek 13y agoI have absolutely no idea what this comment is supposed to mean. If SCOTUS ruled that any part of FISA was unconstitutional, that ruling would be enforceable. Contrary to the popular misunderstanding of FISA as a shadow court system, FISA enjoys literally zero immunity to judicial review. It's not even a real court.
- jdp23 13y agoExcept, of course, that since it's not an adversarial proceeding there isn't anybody to appeal the rulings.
- tptacek 13y agoSo? Most decisions the USG makes aren't adversarial, and yet SCOTUS routinely intervenes in them. Again: the best way to think about FISA is to remember that it's not a real court. It's an internal review board staffed by federal judges who can issue warrants. This point is, I think, frequently misinterpreted. It's not a defense of FISA. FISA is a terrible system and a dereliction of the duties of Congress. But it's not an intractable legal obstacle. The reason that it's difficult to engage FISA in the Supreme Court isn't that FISA is shadowy, but rather that the Constitution doesn't have much to say about foreign intelligence, and there aren't a lot of opportunities for citizens to get their hooks into FISA/NSA in order to get standing in court. That would, of course, change rapidly if the FISA process started being used to make criminal cases in the US.
- apalmer 13y agoI would like clarification on the repeated statement that FISA is not a court but instead a review board. I am not sure if you are speaking from your educated interpretation, or something that is agreed upon as understood legal 'known'.
- tptacek 13y agoI'm not a lawyer; I just play one on message boards. Also, while I think my invocation of "review boards" is closer to the truth than the notion that the FISC is a real court, you should know that the sentiment is disputed and though I don't believe it's hyperbolic, some people do. Courts of law established by the federal government must comply with Article III of the US Constitution (state courts, which is where the overwhelming majority of all controversies in the US are heard, don't need to be structured along the lines of Article III, because the US Constitution defines the federal government and not the state governments). An Article III court is staffed with a federal judge appointed by the President (as specified in Article II) with a lifetime tenure. Article III courts "extend to all cases, in law and equity, arising under this Constitution". FISC court judges are appointed from the federal bench (they're judges appointed by a President for a lifetime term on a federal court). But they have a limited tenure on FISC --- seven years. And unlike Article III appointments, FISC judges are appointed by the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court. And, most importantly, FISC judges do not have power that extends to all cases in law and equity under the Constitution. In fact, the only thing they're empowered to do is authorizing FISA certifications. Things that the FISC does not appear to be able to do: hear criminal cases, sentence defendants, overturn laws, or establish precedents binding on any other court. There are other federal courts that aren't Article III courts --- bankruptcy is one of them. Bankruptcy court judges have 14 year terms. Even though they function as part of the district court system, the Judiciary is clear that they aren't Article III judges. It's worth noting that Bankruptcy's bizarro status in the court system has also created stare decisis problems with the rest of the court system. There's little reason to believe that FISA courts, which are even further removed from Article III than Bankruptcy, would be more judicially potent. One dispute about the Constitutional status of FISC judges arises from case law in the 1990s, wherein a defendant claimed that the FISC was a violation of separation of powers. The appellate decision ruled that FISC judges weren't violating Article III by serving on the FISC, but I dispute that the language in the decision dictates that those judges are in fact Article III judges; I think it says merely that a federal judge doesn't violate Article III by sitting on a body that is effectively an agent of Congress. If they are Article III courts, the FISC is unconstitutional (in a technical way, not a substantive way). I'm a layperson summarizing independent research here, so I'd very much appreciate an expert's opinion on this analysis.
- apalmer 13y agoThats a cool thing to say, reality is SCOTUS could arrive at any conclusion. I would like to think this is a 'nobrainer' with very limited range of interpretation, but its really not apparently.
- malandrew 13y agoI think the more worrying thing is the timing of the discussion. We're now in a position where the government is asking for forgiven instead of permission and that tends to result in the victim (us) being more permissive. If they had publicly asked us (the people) to define "relevant" years ago when this question was originally on the table, then we would have struck a very different balance.