4 ms·
To use a programming analogy, talking about what "relevant" means in the law is like talking about what "num_files" means in programming. That's a highly permi
by rhizome 13y ago
To use a programming analogy, talking about what "relevant" means in the law is like talking about what "num_files" means in programming.
That's a highly permissive interpretation, though one that does allow for the gutting and redefinition of the word. I'm not sure I'd go so far as to say legal terms are as fundamentally meaningless as variables, mere containers for whatever the practitioner desires, though.
Can "relevant" be defined as null?
- rayiner 13y agoLegal terms are not as arbitrary as variable names, but they are highly context-sensitive, which is the principle I was trying to illustrate. A well-written program will not use "num_files" to refer to a count of things that aren't files, but even in a well-written program, "num_files" could have a range of meanings depending on context. The word "relevant" has a broad range of meanings in English, and consequently in the law. The precise meaning must be evaluated in context.
- rhizome 13y agoThe English word "relevant" does not have a broad range of meanings. It does have a wide range of applicability (relevancies, if you will), like many adjectives. In this context "relevant" preserves its meaning as an adjective describing a thing's bearing on another thing. It's the nouns connected to it that have changed. The nouns are what's at issue here: whether surveillance even needs to be connected to anything (the other thing that something has bearing on, connected by the word "relevant [to]").
- tptacek 13y agoIt's easy to come to the conclusion that a big part of what's happening the news media is that lay journalists are each coming to their own idiosyncratic and incompatible conclusions, often from first principles, about how the law operates. "What I've discerned," you imagine them thinking, "is that SCOTUS first issues rulings defining what words like 'relevant' mean, and then the principle of stare decisis give that definition force going forward." Of course that's not at all what happens. To see why, you merely need to look at the different ways the word "relevant" are routinely used in law; relevance is germane to hiring decisions, to college admissions, to admissibility of evidence in civil cases, and to the commerce powers of the federal government. Clearly all these concepts aren't regulated by Terry v Ohio! (It is, as Kerr points out, very possible that the courts are relying on Terry in this case. But if they are, what's notable is the application of Terry at all, not a change in the meaning of Terry.)
- rhizome 13y agoIt's easy for self-styled intellectuals to focus on the most complicated forces in a topic, so it makes sense that they would miss the forest for the trees by focusing on the law in this case. It allows a tangled web of objects to be connected in order to allow pre-existing preferences to be restyled into a dry logic, like postmodern theory or a positive Michael Buble review. The word "relevant" is used in so many different ways because it's an adjective. You don't say "look at how many different meanings there are for the word, 'green': green cars, green makeup, green grass." The word, "relevant" is the same way, except that it takes two nouns or noun phrases, necessarily, because the only meaning of the word is to describe that they are connected, that they are germane to each other. "[R]elevance is germane to college admissions" is a meaningless phrase because "relevant" and "germane" are somewhat synonyms. "Relevance is relevant to evidentiary rules." OK. The context here is an argument of what the terms of relationship are and whether and what those have been changed to. The Terry test speaks to what the surveillance is relevant to. It's not a change in the meaning of Terry, it's a change in the relationship of the surveillance to a particular standard. It could be Terry, it could be something else, but at the end of the day, in the equation "X is relevant to Y," Y is the thing that's changing (or missing, if you follow emptywheel).
- tptacek 13y agoI think I get what you're saying; you don't care what the law says, because you believe surveillance on the NSA's scale is wrong. I'm not sure who you think you're arguing with. You indulge the nitty-gritty detail of the topic I'm discussing anyways, in order to dismiss what I said. But your dismissal doesn't make any sense; you appear incapable of comprehending that there's a second order of relevance at play in cases determining what "relevant" means to different circumstances. Is the color of someone's hair relevant to predicting their performance on a job? Objection! Requires court to recursively evaluate concept of relevance! Overruled. I don't know who you're referring to when you point to "self-styled intellectuals", but if it's a participant on this thread, I'd note that nobody here has taken to calling you names.
- rhizome 13y ago