3 ms·
> but they were caught fighting against Allied forces in a war zone. Wow, that is incredibly misinformed. And even if it were true (it is not), it does not jus
by epistasis 13y ago
> but they were caught fighting against Allied forces in a war zone.
Wow, that is incredibly misinformed. And even if it were true (it is not), it does not justify torture. Torture is always despicable, and there's a permanent moral stain on the nation that perpetrates torture, no matter who is being tortured. There is no excuse. No excuse.
- rayiner 13y agoTorture is despicable, but there is an ongoing debate about whether anything going on at Guantanamo (as opposed to Abu Ghraib) is actually torture under the international definitions. It's not a settled issue like you're making it out to be.
- yardie 13y ago> there is an ongoing debate Is this like the debate on climate change? Where 99.99% of the scientists agree it's man made, yet a few others think it's natural. > It's not a settled issue like you're making it out to be. Yeah, I think it's pretty much settled by everyone but the US government.
- tptacek 13y agoIt seems pretty clear that torture did happen at/around GTMO, and that it ceased (modulo force feeding) under Obama.
- jayfuerstenberg 13y agoI think this is why Mod Def decided to volunteer for this procedure. He wanted to show us the degree to which it is or isn't torture.