3 ms·
He basically says that the goal of both whole language and phonics is to teach phonics, but whole language teaches phonics differently. That is, if students can
by Alex3917 18y ago
He basically says that the goal of both whole language and phonics is to teach phonics, but whole language teaches phonics differently. That is, if students can figure out what the word is by looking at the picture then they then can learn the sounds of the phonemes that make up this word. Some phonemes still have to be taught by rote, but kids can learn most of them by actually reading. He compares this to phonics, where he says kids memorize sounds on flash cards and then read workbooks filled with sentences like "mat hit the cat." He says that if students start by reading real books then they retain much more of their intrinsic motivation to read, rather than learning to read the way we learn to type.
Further, he says that whole language is not currently used in more than 1% of classrooms, so it's impossible that whole language has caused the decline in reading skills.
- tokenadult 18y agoif students can figure out what the word is by looking at the picture Oh gosh, that's terrible. There is a very great response to the whole look at the picture nonsense in the book Education's Smoking Gun by Reginald Damerell. http://www.amazon.com/Educations-Smoking-Gun-Destroyed-Education/dp/0881910252 http://www.amazon.com/Educations-Smoking-Gun-Destroyed-Educa... There is an illustration of a cat, not so different from this image, http://spoilurpets.com/images/Thermal%20Cat%20Mat.JPG http://spoilurpets.com/images/Thermal%20Cat%20Mat.JPG and the illustration is labeled in Chinese. I burst out laughing as soon as I saw the illustration, because I can read Chinese, so I knew the punchline. The children are shown the illustration, and asked to guess the meaning of the Chinese characters in the caption. In the illustration that Reginald Damerell commissioned his graduate student from Taiwan to produce, the Chinese characters did not say "the cat is on the mat," but rather "the cat's eyes are open." One thing that I really like about the book Let's Read: A Linguistic Approach, by an eminent linguist and an equally eminent lexicographer, is that the stories have no illustrations whatsoever. Indeed, the final story in the book, called "The Picture Country," is beautifully evocative and remarkably visual story told entirely in words, which makes the point to children that once they know how to read, they can see more beautiful pictures in their mind than one could find in all the book illustrations in the world. That is genuine reading.
- Alex3917 18y agoThanks, grabbed a copy of the first book on Amazon and bookmarked the second.