7 ms·
Paul Dirac's handwritten notes for his PhD, the first ever on quantum mechanics
- Osmium 13y agoThere's nothing like looking at that Table of Contents to put your own PhD in perspective!
- herge 13y agoHow big was your table of contents?
- Osmium 13y agoIt's less the size and more the breadth. A lot of people in sciences now feel like the "big discoveries" have been made (at least until the next paradigm shift comes along) and all we can do now is an incremental grind in some highly specific area. Reading Dirac's table of contents is like reading the chapter headings in my undergrad quantum physics textbook. The thing is though, he's actually responsible for a lot of it!
- hga 13y agoIndeed, although some of this is the luck of timing. E.g. Richard Feynman would likely have been one of the great names in quantum mechanics ... if it weren't for the fact he was 8 years old right then. Linus Pauling, born 17 years earlier, became the 20th century's most preeminent chemist in part because he was a fricking genius and writer (many of his books are still useful today), but key was that also in 1926 he got a Guggenheim Fellowship to study under some European physicists like Bohr and Schrödinger for a couple of years, and was therefore one of the first to apply quantum mechanics to chemistry, a very fruitful approach.
- dnautics 13y agoWait, Feynman wasn't one of the "great names in quantum mechanics"??
- skndr 13y agoI think the point is that Feynman came later to contribute to Quantum Electrodynamics, the "first theory where full agreement between quantum mechanics and special relativity is achieved."* * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_electrodynamics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_electrodynamics
- cli 13y agoFeyman was too young for the really fundamental work on quantum mechanics. He won his Nobel prize for his work on quantum electrodynamics. However, he created the path-integral formulation of quantum mechanics, which can be thought of as another way of describing quantum mechanics.
- dnautics 13y agoyeah, I was thinking, uh, the path-integral formulation?? Which IIRC is still kind of mathematically ill-defined, but still. making a fundamental discovery is not necessary to be a 'great mind', I think. As the man himself said, 'what I cannot create, I do not understand'.
- abecedarius 13y agoIt's worth mentioning that the path-integral formulation had a seed in Dirac: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Path_integral_formulation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Path_integral_formulation
- hga 13y agoYes, echoing the others Feynman was too late for the foundational, completely change your view of the universe stuff. Gamow's Thirty Years that Shook Physics: The Story of Quantum Theory http://www.amazon.com/Thirty-Years-that-Shook-Physics/dp/048624895X http://www.amazon.com/Thirty-Years-that-Shook-Physics/dp/048... is the standard non-specialist account of this, it starts with Plank right after the turn of the century and is essentially complete in 3 decades, about when Feynman was in high school and teaching himself serious math.
- gwern 13y agoOne of the interesting things in http://businessinnovation.berkeley.edu/WilliamsonSeminar/jones040507.pdf http://businessinnovation.berkeley.edu/WilliamsonSeminar/jon... is the graphs and comments on quantum mechanics - everyone involved got degrees and did their Nobel-worth work astonishingly young. The 'bag of jewels' metaphor really is apt, because it seems you had only to be young and flexible-minded to do groundbreaking work. There will probably never again be a period of such riches in physics (he said in 2013, more than a century after Planck's quanta). http://rjlipton.wordpress.com/2013/06/25/it-takes-guts-to-do-research/ http://rjlipton.wordpress.com/2013/06/25/it-takes-guts-to-do... also comes to mind as Dirac and quantum mechanics related.
- snowwrestler 13y agoIn the late 19th century, many physicists thought they had physics pretty well sewn up, with just a few loose ends. Of course it turns out that those loose ends led to quantum mechanics and relativity, completely revolutionizing the field. Today it seems that physics has most things pretty well figured out, but there are the loose ends of dark matter and dark energy. We don't know exactly what they are, but they seem to make up almost 95% of the content of the universe! So there might still be a chance for another wholesale revolution or two in physics.
- dmead 13y agoso many threads on hacker news get voted to the top without any comments at all. usually you're supposed to read the article, but in this case i doubt anyone is really capable of understanding it. so in conclusion, aside from this one the article has the appropriate number of comments.
- gaze 13y agothis is all very standard stuff for a physicist. Any first or second year grad student should have an easy time digesting this.
- logicallee 13y ago"Pshaw, even the most dimwitted individual should understand this, provided they have a BS in physics, were accepted to grad school, and are in their first or second year."
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- pja 13y agoNah, this is undergrad physics these days. 3rd or 4th year undergrad physics admittedly :)
- gaze 13y agoRelativistic quantum mechanics typically isn't covered during undergrad. Maybe touched on briefly.
- tfgg 13y agoI don't know what university you went to, but it definitely was on my course. Second or third year. The idea that you wouldn't cover relativistic QM in undergrad physics is pretty absurd, and probably indicative of how shallow American undergrad degrees are.
- nrmn 13y agoHere is a link to the pdf to save anyone from the signup process. Which was painfully long and annoying. https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/155545/dirac_1926_dissertation.pdf https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/155545/dirac_1926_disser...
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- nrmn 13y agohttps://docs.google.com/file/d/0BzwdtDAz5dlwTXVyUzZPQkZQVEk https://docs.google.com/file/d/0BzwdtDAz5dlwTXVyUzZPQkZQVEk I hope Google is nicer.
- yarapavan 13y agoHere is a link to skydrive copy: https://skydrive.live.com/redir?resid=EC25CEEFA14ACEE1!654&authkey=!ACfktsfGdjdRZMM https://skydrive.live.com/redir?resid=EC25CEEFA14ACEE1!654&a...
- jervisfm 13y agoI didn't realize that academia mandated a sign up for download of content. IIRC their position was that signup would be optional in order to differentiate themselves from traditional academic publishers who protect access to their content with paywalls/subscriptions. Clearly, either I was mistaken or they have changed their policies.
- RVijay007 13y agoLooks like your link is so popular that Dropbox has temporarily disabled it!
- nrmn 13y agoYea, dropbox has a 20gb limit on public downloads so the file being ~28mbs means its been downloaded around 700 times.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- JosephRedfern 13y ago"The Strangest Man: The Hidden Life of Paul Dirac" is a good read if your interested in learning more about Dirac's life.
- keithflower 13y ago"...Dirac was absorbed in writing his Ph.D. thesis, a compact presentation of his vision of quantum mechanics. Confident though he was of his understanding of the theory, he knew as he wrote his thesis that it was not the whole story, for he had recently heard than an alternative version of quantum theory had appeared, one that completely different from Heisenberg's. The author of the new version was the Austrian theoretician Erwin Schrodinger, working in Zürich. He was 38 years old, a generation older then than Heisenberg and Dirac, with a formidable reputation in Europe as a brilliant polymath. Dirac ignored Schrodinger's theory in his PhD thesis "Quantum Mechanics", the first to be submitted anywhere on the subject. The thesis was a great success with his examiners who took the unusual step on 19 June of sending him a short hand written letter congratulating him on the "exceptional distinction" of his work. ....Dirac disliked celebrations and formality, so he was almost certainly not looking forward to the ceremony. He could have taken the degree without attending it but decided to be there in person for the sake of his proud parents, especially this father, who had given him the money that enabled him to begin his Cambridge studies. ...Wearing evening dress with a white bow tie, a small black cap and black silk down with a scarlet-lined hood, he knelt on a velvet cushion, placed his hands together and held them out to be grasped by the Vice Chancellor, who delivered a prayer-like oration. Dirac arose, a doctor. Like his father, he had no need of holidays – the long vacations were not for relaxing but for hard work. The university was about to hibernate for the summer and would be virtually devoid of social distractions for the few scholars remaining. It was the perfect environment for Dirac to concentrate even more intensively on his work. Heisenberg and Schrodinger had knifed a sack of gemstones, and the race was on to pick out the diamonds. -- Graham Farmelo, The Strangest Man
- newobj 13y agoDirac went to FSU? Wha???
- pja 13y agoMaybe they bought his papers from the estate after he died?
- Little_Peter 13y agoYes, he went to Florida State University in the dawn of his career. This explains the watermark.
- Panoramix 13y agoIndeed, he went to Bristol and Cambridge, whence he developed his relativistic quantum theory. He relocated to Florida towards the end of his life. *edited the part where I assert OP was wrong.
- Little_Peter 13y agoWe are splitting hairs here. What is wrong? That his career dawned in Florida?
- Panoramix 13y agoI'm sorry, I completely misread what you wrote!
- glurgh 13y agoThe 'dawn' part is wrong. http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/dawn http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/dawn
- gruseom 13y agoIn English, "dawn" only occurs in the morning, so when used metaphorically it always refers to the advent of a thing. The word you're looking for is "twilight", which when used metaphorically means the end or decline of a thing. Thus Nietzsche's Götzen-Dämmerung is translated Twilight of the Idols. There's also the word "dusk", which is the opposite of "dawn", but it tends not to be used metaphorically.
- Aqueous 13y ago'Quantum Mechanics by Paul Dirac' Other historical theses: 1. 'Gravity by Newton' 2. 'Evolution by Darwin' 3. 'The Earth Orbits the Sun, Not the Other Way Around by Copernicus'
- kirk21 13y agoWow! This must have been a lot of work to write this all down. We are creating tools for PhD students so they can work more efficiently. bohr.launchrock.com
- gjm11 13y agoPlease stop spamming HN with advertisements for this. You have posted 9 of these, generally with only the most tenuous relevance to the thread in which you have done so. In one case you appear to have been trying to pretend not to be affiliated with the company in question. Please stop.
- racl101 13y agoI smell what Dirac is cooking!!!
- geraldalewis 13y agoThat is the most beautiful handwriting I have ever seen.
- gtani 13y agoI asked my Dad about Dirac, he never met him but he once wrote him asking for clarification of something in a book, and got a handwritten letter back. He doesn't actually remember what was in the letter, but he does remember that somebody borrowed the letter and never returned it. Pissed him off, so we're going to try to get it back.
- twentysix 13y agohttp://ecommons.library.cornell.edu/bitstream/1813/80/34/streaming_80_6.html http://ecommons.library.cornell.edu/bitstream/1813/80/34/str... http://ecommons.library.cornell.edu/bitstream/1813/80/35/streaming_80_7.html http://ecommons.library.cornell.edu/bitstream/1813/80/35/str... http://ecommons.library.cornell.edu/bitstream/1813/80/36/streaming_80_8.html http://ecommons.library.cornell.edu/bitstream/1813/80/36/str... These three lectures by Hans Bethe are really interesting to watch and gives you a historical perspective on the development of Quantum Physics. Given his age, the delivery is a bit slow, but it piques your interest in the subject.
- baggers 13y agoVery nice! ------ I'll throw another link into the pile. A 54min lecture on the life of Paul Dirac. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YfYon2WdR40 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YfYon2WdR40 The lecturer is very engaging and this a very approachable talk for those not versed in physics.