4 ms·
The bottlenecks in their escape were the doorway and the crew's deployment of the inflatable slide. Rushing the door in a panic would have done nobody any good.
by justin66 13y ago
The bottlenecks in their escape were the doorway and the crew's deployment of the inflatable slide. Rushing the door in a panic would have done nobody any good.
In a situation like that, why wouldn't you grab your bag if it was readily accessible? It seems like healthy, rational behavior rather than a symptom of extreme confusion.
- vilhelm_s 13y agoThe safety briefing before every flight tells you not take take any bags when emergency evacuating the plane.
- VladRussian2 13y agoit is interesting how emergency this emergency situation is - the people are being let out only through one door, and they aren't additionally channeled through business class door even though business class people have obviously already left, and there seems to be no damage to the plane blocking the economy to business class passageway. The emergency exit atop the wing is also not activated. I mean it seems that it isn't that big of an emergency from POV of the people inside the plane.
- Osmium 13y ago> Rushing the door in a panic would have done nobody any good. No one's suggesting this. You can both leave the plane in a calm manner and leave your bags behind. As far as I'm concerned, there's no good reason to take your bag unless it's actively obstructing the way out -- which, in fairness, could well be what's happened here. Off-hand, some reasons not to: the aisles have limited capacity, and more bags in the aisles mean fewer people can be queueing ready to get off. It will take longer to figure out how to use the slide if you want to go down it with your bag, especially if the bag is heavy or large. The bag might have sharp corners which could damage the slide (if I remember rightly, people are advised to remove sharp-heeled shoes for this reason). Seconds count in situations like this. I think people have taken the "keep calm" message to heart and, if anything, need to be taught to treat this kind of thing more seriously. The reason I mention this is that I'm reminded of the bystander effect: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bystander_effect#Emergency_versus_non-emergency_situations http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bystander_effect#Emergency_vers... e.g. > The students were placed in a room-either alone, with two strangers or with three strangers to complete a questionnaire while they waited for the experimenter to return. While they were completing the questionnaire smoke was pumped into the room through a wall vent to simulate an emergency. When students were working alone they noticed the smoke almost immediately (within 5 seconds). However, students that were working in groups took longer (up to 20 seconds) to notice the smoke. These peoples lives could have been in imminent danger, but they might waste precious seconds to leaving the plane because of social pressures (e.g. someone sees one person taking their bag, so thinks it's okay to do so themselves, or subconsciously thinks the situation is not that serious). People should keep calm, but they should also know to treat the situation as it is -- an emergency. But as I say, this is all speculation, and may not be relevant at all in this specific instance. I just hope everyone's okay.
- justin66 13y ago> Off-hand, some reasons not to: the aisles have limited capacity, and more bags in the aisles mean fewer people can be queueing ready to get off. I can see what you're saying but "number of people queued in the aisles" isn't an important measurement at all. The important thing would how much the overall rate of passage through the exits is affected by the people who grabbed their bags. I expect the rate of passage through those exits has a lot to do with what people do when they reach the bottom of the slide. That certainly might be affected by what they're carrying, but then again, people might have simply been tossing their bags over the side. You can't rely too heavily on a single photograph to analyse these things. > I think people have taken the "keep calm" message to heart and, if anything, need to be taught to treat this kind of thing more seriously. The alternatives are to keep calm or panic. I guess "seriousness" is subjective but when it comes to calmness vs. panic, I know which alternative I'd prefer the people around me to exhibit in an emergency. Particularly in a confined space. How is this even an argument?
- justin66 13y agoAfter seeing the following photograph (1 of 18) I'm confused. Contrast it with the original one we were talking about: http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/chi-san-francisco-plane-crash-20130706,0,284092.story http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/chi-san-francisco-plane-c... Never mind the whole issue of people grabbing their bags. That plane was rather seriously on fire and the people in the original photograph don't appear to be very concerned about moving away from it. Strange.
- bane 13y agoAlso, since it's an international flight, people's travel papers are likely in their backpacks, etc. If you take the time to grab your backpack, you may as well grab whatever else before you head out.
- aylons 13y agoI wonder if they refuse ingress to the USA based on lack of documentation in these cases.
- lifeformed 13y agoA lot of plane crash deaths happen after the crash - burning fuel can spread quickly and kill or incapacitate people inside. Every second counts. Even if you already have your bag in hand, you're leaving less room for others in the aisle.
- sbierwagen 13y agoThe bottlenecks in their escape were the doorway and the crew's deployment of the inflatable slide... why wouldn't you grab your bag if it was readily accessible? Wrong. In order to be certified airworthy, you have to be able to evacuate an airliner in 90 seconds, in the dark, with some of the emergency exits blocked. Here's an A380 doing it: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4TAkAcQOnQY http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4TAkAcQOnQY Here's a 777: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4TAkAcQOnQY http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4TAkAcQOnQY If everyone stops to grab their bag, it can take ten times as long. If the plane is on fire, then people die.
- justin66 13y agoThanks. That is impressive. The whole thing now makes me wonder if there was some very deliberate reason for their egress to be delayed. Something having to do with fire or the risk of fire? (I really have no idea)
- blake8086 13y agoYou linked the same video twice. (thanks, though)
- sbierwagen 13y agoWhoops. And of course I check back 7 hours after the edit window.
- teamonkey 13y agoThey should show that as the pre-flight video.