2 ms·
The problem arises when people make the mistake of thinking that number theory naturally lives in the non-negative integers; its natural embodiment is the entir
by cperciva 13y ago
The problem arises when people make the mistake of thinking that number theory naturally lives in the non-negative integers; its natural embodiment is the entire ring of integers.
Within this ring, the integers are divided into four sets: Zero, a (unique) value which when multiplied by anything yields itself; the Units {1, -1}, which are the elements with multiplicative inverses; the Primes {2, 3, 5, 7, ...}, which are the elements which cannot be written as the product of two non-Zero non-Units; and the Composites {4, 6, 8, 9, ...} consisting of everything else.
- anatoly 13y agoUnits also have the property that they cannot be written as the product of two non-zero non-units. There's no important reason for Units and Primes to be disjoint sets. Units could be considered primes. It would make some things more convenient and others less convenient. For example, a prime decomposition of an element would really be a prime decomposition and not "up to a unit"; on the other hand, a proper statement of its uniqueness would be more bulky. Ultimately mathematicians decided that it's much more convenient to not consider units to be prime. It does seem to be a matter of convention, with no deep significance to it.
- cperciva 13y agoThe property of being invertible is very important. It may seem trivial in the context of the integers, but it's far more significant when you broaden your outlook to other rings.