4 ms·
> Congress cannot make murder legal. I chose a bad example because murder is generally illegal under state law, not federal law (though there are exceptions).
by lisper 13y ago
> Congress cannot make murder legal.
I chose a bad example because murder is generally illegal under state law, not federal law (though there are exceptions). But there are things that are illegal under federal law that Congress has the power to change. Those things are in fact illegal (now) notwithstanding that Congress could change the law and make them legal. Likewise, Robert's appointments are not reviewable (now) notwithstanding that Congress could change the law and make his appointments reviewable.
- tptacek 13y agoIt has nothing to do with state versus federal and everything to do with the core issue here. Congress can't make murder legal because to do so would be unconstitutional.
- bradleyjg 13y agoAre you talking affirmatively authorizing murder rather then simply not penalizing it? Because I can't think of any constitutional provision that even hints at a requirement for Congress to promulgate a penal code at all.
- lisper 13y agoThat is ridiculous. Congress could make murder legal (at least at the federal level) by simply repealing 18 USC 1111. There is nothing in the Constitution that would prevent them from doing that. Murder would, of course, still be illegal at the state level, but focusing on that would be missing the point rather badly. Murder is a red herring. The fact of the matter is that there are things that are not legal by virtue of the existence of federal laws. Congress could make those things legal by repealing those laws, but until and unless it does so those things are illegal. Likewise, the fact of the matter is that Roberts's appointments to the FISA court are not reviewable. Congress could make them reviewable, but until and unless it does so, they are not reviewable. That Congress could make them reviewable in the future does not make them reviewable in the present and more than the fact that Congress could make something legal in the future makes it legal in the present. It takes an extraordinary level of obtuseness not to grasp this elementary linguistic point.
- apalmer 13y agoPretty much ^^^ I think this is an interesting but (apparently) subtle argument, so lets take it a step further for illustration purposes. The US could repeal the first amendment, and explicitly make being a buddhist illegal, if enough congressmen got on board. There is a clear well known process for this, and in fact even precedent as previous amendments have been repealed. This does not make it incorrect to say 'freedom of religion is a inalienable right in the USA', because it is such today, as the law stands, the fact that congress has the power to change this doesn't make it a false statement...
- zowch 13y agoPedantic and tangential, but in your example, the statement would still be incorrect, as a revocable right is, by definition...well, alienable.
- AnthonyMouse 13y agoThat's kind of the point. You can't argue that a specific right is not inalienable just because a process exists by which it could be denied, unless your point is to argue that no rights can ever be inalienable, or that no power can ever be unaccountable, etc. We say that someone is unaccountable when the process required to lead to their accountability subsequent to misbehavior is in practice not likely to occur, not when the absolute lack of accountability can be proven with mathematical rigor. This is the same pedantry that leads engineers to come up with crazy legal arguments. The fact that velocity is relativistic and relative to an external observer not subject to the rotation of the Earth your vehicle was not exceeding the speed limit is not going to get you out of a speeding ticket, no matter how many times you argue that it's technically correct. Because when people say things they do so within an accepted context that doesn't include the sort of pedantic absolutism that would cause arbitrary good faith statements made in the course of normal conversation to become technically inaccurate when weighed against impossible standards.
- bulatb 13y agoAny "right" can be revoked by someone with a bigger gun.
- rhizome 13y agoCongress can and has made murder legal: people executed under the death penalty have "Homicide" listed on their death certificate as the cause of death.
- CamperBob2 13y agoCongress can't make murder legal because to do so would be unconstitutional And conveniently enough, who gets to make that call? How you can argue that this isn't a rigged system is, well, interesting.