4 ms·
STDs are hardly propaganda, and promiscuity does indeed increase the risk. Besides she was clearly a troubled youth, with sexual abuse home and her further abu
by varjag 13y ago
STDs are hardly propaganda, and promiscuity does indeed increase the risk.
Besides she was clearly a troubled youth, with sexual abuse home and her further abusive relationships conveyed early in the movie.
- xauronx 13y agoAids was invented by the right wing propaganda machine to punish homosexuals though, so tomato tomato.
- bruceb 13y agoMajor Dan was getting it on with prostitutes but he doesn't get aids. It also showed the anti war guy just happens to be a women beater...
- varjag 13y agoMajor Dan gets both legs lost and ends up a pathetic drunkard in wheelchair without purpose, I'd think it's bad enough, no? And John Lennon, with his "Imagine", was a wife beater. Do not confuse political convictions with person's character.
- mhurron 13y agoAre you saying anti-war protesters can't be women beaters? That liberated women can't get AIDS? That in the late 70's prostitutes were guaranteed ways of getting this disease that wasn't widespread yet? Forrest Gump had very real characters. Jenny had a shitty life, which continued to be shitty by her choices. This really happens to people from shitty backgrounds because they don't recognize shitty situations as shitty, but as normal. Had she stayed with Forrest, her life wouldn't have been that way, but she still could have been the strong woman that was part of her personality. She just didn't recognize when a good thing came her way. Lots of people did heroin and hookers before AIDS was everywhere, not all of them contracted HIV. That's the nature of a mystery disease. Lt. Dan also fell into a depression that Forrest helped pull him out of, just by being a good influence. Lt. Dan had the life Jenny could have, Forrest made the lives of people around him better by being a good person. Between that and the rapid changes the world went through from 1950 to ~1985 is what the movie is about. It's not a propaganda film, despite your strongest wishes that it were.
- loup-vaillant 13y agoPropaganda or no, our brains do have a tendency to mix up correlation and causation (most notably because many times, correlation does come from causation), and a tendency to draw conclusions from fiction as well as from reality. Someone who notices both her AIDS and her left-wing behaviour will likely be a tiny bit more confident that one causes the other. (Now, I do see her as a prisoner of her shitty situation, and not as a "liberated" woman.)
- eshvk 13y ago> Someone who notices both her AIDS and her left-wing behaviour will likely be a tiny bit more confident that one causes the other. So just because some people are woolly headed, artistic endeavours should show only one-dimensional characters? Reality is filled with Syrian rebels who eat hearts, rapists who were nice to their mothers and computer programmers who pray to god.
- loup-vaillant 13y ago
- pg 13y agoThis thread has descended into self-parody. I encourage you guys to go do something else.
- bruceb 13y agoYeah I didn't want to get into it but sometimes some BS bugs you and its hard not to comment. I try to stick to non political on HN. Kinda rewarding "bad" behavior though right? this is the first time PG has sorta commented on any comment I have made.
- YuriNiyazov 13y agoI'm afraid that if you think PG will continue to tell you to stop after this time, you are wrong. The next step is probably you being hellbanned by one of the admins, or by software.
- jfoster 13y agoI wonder if "please stop" is a way of triggering (or arming) a hellban. Would be quite clever if it is, I think.
- huherto 13y agoJust like in real life. Some people got it, some people didn't. I also thought it was great how they handle the subject in that movie. And what about Forest who loves Jenny regardless anything on her past?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]