11 ms·
Legally speaking, the workers are paid as contractors rather than employees. They set their own hours and are not under any obligation to accept work they don't
by enraged_camel 13y ago
Legally speaking, the workers are paid as contractors rather than employees. They set their own hours and are not under any obligation to accept work they don't want to do. As such, they don't have to pay payroll taxes and are not subject to laws such as minimum wage.
- pyoung 13y agoI am pretty sure contractors have to pay payroll taxes. It is one of the reasons that companies are increasingly classifying employees as contractors, the burden of the payroll tax falls on the contractor entirely (normally it is split 50/50 between employee/employer).
- philwelch 13y agoThat doesn't make much sense--payroll tax is roughly 15% either way, so with employees you just pay them 7.5% less than a contractor for the same benefit. The real reason for contracting is that the paperwork is much simpler. You don't need an HR department. And the guy gets automatically laid off after a few months without the incident reflecting on either you or him, so there's less risk. There's another side to it where you can hire a "contractor" on an n-month term, but instead of paying the contractor directly you go through a middleman who hires the contractor as an employee and provides (shitty) benefits and takes care of taxes.
- g4m8i7 13y agoOr you pay them the same, and skip out on benefits as well as payroll taxes and your ROI is much higher.
- nazgulnarsil 13y agoyou can not "split" taxes between employer and employee. The employer cares only about how much the total cost of employing someone is. The makeup of the cost is irrelevant.
- pyoung 13y agoThe point is that employers are classifying employees as contractors because they can get away with offering the same 'salary', but avoid paying payroll taxes and benefits. We can get pedantic about 'who is really paying what', but in the end, companies are using this tactic to screw over their employees. There are many cases where taking work as a contractor makes sense (mainly, short-term/part-time work), but people need to be aware of the costs, and take them into consideration when comparing job offers.
- grecy 13y ago> not under any obligation to accept work they don't want to do The fact they are choosing to do it shows they have no viable alternative, which means things must be pretty bad where they are living
- diminoten 13y agoOnly a small percentage of workers are using MTurk as a primary source of income, so I wouldn't agree with the assertion that "things must be pretty bad".
- grecy 13y agoYou think that people working for less than minimum wage is not a problem?
- diminoten 13y agoYes.
- grecy 13y agoOnce again, I'm very happy I don't live in your country.
- enraged_camel 13y agoThe bigger point you need to understand is that if minimum wage was enforced at MTurk, it would significantly raise the prices, and many requesters would simply stop using the service. This would result in less work for everyone.
- grecy 13y agoBy that logic, no jobs should have a minimum wage, lest it drive up the price of having employees and then there would be less work for everyone.