5 ms·
No, Klein is absolutely correct, and you are absolutely wrong. Roberts has the power to appoint FISA judges. That power is clearly the power to "shape the sur
by lisper 13y ago
No, Klein is absolutely correct, and you are absolutely wrong. Roberts has the power to appoint FISA judges. That power is clearly the power to "shape the surveillance state." There is no mechanism to review his appointments, hence the power is unaccountable. Roberts alone has this power, hence "exclusive." And until the law is changed, he has this power for as long as he is chief justice, hence "lifetime."
- tptacek 13y agoThere absolutely is a mechanism to review his appointments. Not only could Congress pass a law recalling any FISC judge, but it could also pass a law revoking Roberts authority over FISC, or abolish the FISC court entirely. There would be fuck-all Roberts could do about it.
- angersock 13y agoCongress could do a great many things--and yet, here we are. I think you have too much faith in our legislative branch. (Consider the turnout for the briefings on this nonsense a couple of weeks ago--most skipped out to catch flights home.)
- tptacek 13y agoI have very little faith in Congress, but I don't need to in order to make the point I'm making.
- sigzero 13y agoThe whole point is that Congress CAN change everything about the FISC courts and Roberts CANNOT do anything about that. So the article is wrong on that aspect.
- fnordfnordfnord 13y ago>(Consider the turnout for the briefings on this nonsense a couple of weeks ago--most skipped out to catch flights home.) Attending those briefings is a poison pill. Before being briefed, members must swear not to reveal any of the content of the briefing.
- angersock 13y agoSo, the right thing to do would be to protest that fact loudly to their constituents--something which I do not believe they've done. As it is, they simple look derelict in their duty.
- cpleppert 13y ago>>Not only could Congress pass a law recalling any FISC judge I'm not sure this would be constitutional. Courts have rules that the term limits on FISA judges don't impact their standing as regular article III judges. Arbitrary removal almost certainly would.
- tptacek 13y agoThey can't remove federal judges from the federal bench.
- censored 13y agoNot if NSA has enough dirt on each congress-person (or their family)
- tptacek 13y agoOr if they use their secret NSA drones to drone strike them.
- censored 13y agoThey don't need to, when the surveillance ensures compliance with the implied threat. Or are you just trolling?
- jlgreco 13y agoYes, he is mocking you by suggesting something outlandish to imply what you are suggesting is also outlandish. Nevermind that politicians being blackmailed is hardly unheard of...
- fnordfnordfnord 13y agoGood point! I checked, and it turns out that it is not written in any law passed by congress that the NSA is explicitly empowered to extort congressmen for its own ends. So, yeah, that guy is just crazy for suggesting such a thing.
- lisper 13y ago> There absolutely is a mechanism to review his appointments. Not at the present time there isn't. > Congress [could] pass a law Saying that Roberts's appointments are reviewable because Congress could change the law is exactly analogous to saying that murder is legal because Congress could change the law. It is true that Congress could change the law. But unless and until it actually does change the law, murder is in fact illegal, and Roberts's appointments are in fact not reviewable.
- tptacek 13y agoCongress cannot make murder legal. Congress can strip Roberts of his FISC powers. The situations are not analogous.
- lisper 13y ago> Congress cannot make murder legal. I chose a bad example because murder is generally illegal under state law, not federal law (though there are exceptions). But there are things that are illegal under federal law that Congress has the power to change. Those things are in fact illegal (now) notwithstanding that Congress could change the law and make them legal. Likewise, Robert's appointments are not reviewable (now) notwithstanding that Congress could change the law and make his appointments reviewable.
- tptacek 13y agoIt has nothing to do with state versus federal and everything to do with the core issue here. Congress can't make murder legal because to do so would be unconstitutional.
- bradleyjg 13y agoAre you talking affirmatively authorizing murder rather then simply not penalizing it? Because I can't think of any constitutional provision that even hints at a requirement for Congress to promulgate a penal code at all.
- 13y ago
- coldtea 13y agoYes, but why argue for the beef of the matter, when you can argue about metaphors and rhetorical misuses?
- tptacek 13y agoBecause the subtext of the article is that Roberts himself is an intractable obstacle to reforming FISC, when in fact all the responsibility for doing so is properly on Congress, at whose pleasure Roberts serves in his capacity as FISC judge appointer. The article is inadvertently letting Congress off the hook.
- zhemao 13y agoWhat part of the article suggests that Roberts is an obstacle to reform? The article only states that in its current formulation, FISC does not have a lot of accountability because the judges are all chosen by Roberts with no input from any other part of government.
- tptacek 13y agoThe only branch of government that doesn't have influence over FISC is the executive, which runs NSA.
- ScottBurson 13y ago> The article is inadvertently letting Congress off the hook. Perhaps Klein could have briefly reminded readers that the "A" in "FISA" stands for "Act" -- that is, of Congress -- but this is a blog post in the Washington Post. I can't fault Klein too much for overlooking that not all readers might share that bit of context.
- lawnchair_larry 13y agoI don't think that is the most reasonable interpretation. I think the article argues that we do need reform, because in its current state, the system does exhibit the properties described. It's not letting congress off the hook, it's painting a bullseye and applying pressure for them to pull the trigger. Until they do so, John Roberts has exclusive, unaccountable, lifetime power to shape the surveillance state. While I too prefer code that compiles with -pedantic, I'm willing to forgive this author, and I don't see anything to suggest that the author believes that he is an intractable obstacle. I even think it's extraordinarily unlikely that any journalist sincerely believes that any single person is a permanently intractable obstacle in the government, so it makes the most sense to assume that was not the motivation.
- anigbrowl 13y agoYou (and Klein) are wrong. Congress could shut down the FISC apparatus tomorrow and Roberts could do nothing about it (in fact, he'd probably give a sigh of relief, as he doesn't seem to particularly enjoy the administrative aspects of his job). Congress does not have that power with regard to any of CJ Roberts' Article III privileges. This is a fundamentally important point. Talking about the probability that Congress will do this or that is irrelevant.
- lisper 13y ago> Congress could shut down the FISC apparatus tomorrow Actually, they couldn't. To shut down FISC they would have to pass a new law, which they could not do tomorrow because they are not in session tomorrow. And then the president would have to sign the law, or Congress would have to override his veto. Yes, it is possible to change the law, but it's not easy. Likewise, the Constitution could be amended to rescind Roberts's Article III privileges. So the situation is exactly analogous. But as you yourself point out, the probabilities that these things will happen are irrelevant. What matters is that until the changes are actually made (by whatever process is needed to make them) the situation is what it is. And the situation at the moment is that Roberts's appointments to the FISA court are not reviewable by anyone. So Klein is right and you are wrong. Deal with it.
- tptacek 13y agoThe reason it's unlikely isn't that it's hard for Congress to change it; it's that Congress' constituents don't want them to. And that should give you pause about the prospect of some judge doing it for them, because nobody elects federal judges. We are not a nation ruled by philosopher kings.
- lisper 13y ago> Congress' constituents don't want them to That is far from clear. But either way, it's irrelevant to the matter at hand. The fact is that you are wrong about Klein. Until you acknowledge that and retract your top-level claim, there's no point in discussing anything else. Life is too short.