8 ms·
A chimp-pig hybrid origin for humans?
- duncan_bayne 13y agoMy gut feel is that this is bat-shit crazy, but wouldn't it be amusing to see the response from the Jewish and Islamic world should it turn out that humans are pig hybrids? ;)
- gojomo 13y agoVindication? The broad (though not universal) taboo against eating primate meat has some basis in the higher risk of shared/cross-species diseases, due to a closer genetic relationship. If there's a little pig in us, that'd argue for stronger taboos against eating pork... exactly as in Judaism and Islam.
- duncan_bayne 13y agoYes - I think many religious taboos have their basis in sensible food hygiene and incest avoidance. But that's not how it's pitched; often the claim is that "pigs are unclean". Which is why it'd be funny.
- floobynewb 13y ago@gojomo, this is what I had thought the original poster meant. Shame it was a better, nicer joke that way around.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- to3m 13y agoI don't think human meat is currently kosher or halal, so would it really matter?
- tome 13y agoCertain Islamic radicals have called Jews the "descendants of apes and pigs". Perhaps these radicals are just excellent evolutionary biologists.
- bayesianhorse 13y agoYou can't make this stuff up. Or can you? At first I thought it's an elaborate joke, but I couldn't find any real pointers to the jocular nature...
- oinksoft 13y agoThis is quite real. McCarthy has been published by Oxford Press. Here it is from the horse's mouth: http://www.macroevolution.net/human-origins.html http://www.macroevolution.net/human-origins.html
- gus_massa 13y agoDo we have a designed ornithologist here to comment about the book? My guess is that all the cases in the book are hybrids between very related bird species. For example, in the PowerPoint presentation, there is a hybrid between two types of crows, other cases are not so obvious, but IANAO. But I didn't see any hybrid between two obvious distant species, for example between an ostrich and a stork.
- thelibrarian 13y agoThere's at least one fairly well-know biology professor/blogger who is unimpressed with what he dubs the "MFAP" hypothesis: http://freethoughtblogs.com/pharyngula/2013/07/02/the-mfap-hypothesis-for-the-origins-of-homo-sapiens/ http://freethoughtblogs.com/pharyngula/2013/07/02/the-mfap-h...
- twstws 13y agoThe thing I find most depressing about these crackpots is that some otherwise productive scientist has to spend an evening debunking their nonsense. And it still doesn't stop. I taught evolution for undergrads, and occasionally had to deal with these issues from students. It takes time to look into them, and no matter how thoroughly debunked the theory, some kids find them too irresistible to let go of. It undermines real education in the end.
- hetman 13y agoWhat often distinguishes the crackpot from the visionary is whether they are eventually vindicated. The latter usually begins their career being perceived as the former.
- nitrogen 13y agoThis is a tautology. Of course visionaries are the ones who were vindicated. That doesn't mean that being perceived as a crackpot is a reliable indicator of being a visionary. It's similar to the argument that opposition equals confirmation -- some religious groups and conspiracy theorists argue that the fact that people oppose them means they are right.
- hetman 13y agoI never said crackpots are guaranteed to be visionaries, though I'm sure it made a convenient strawman for you to argue against. My only point was that you can't be certain either way a priori, to be sure you must actually investigate it (and history tells us even then that's not always going to guarantee certainty).
- jvm 13y agoHybridization is actually a pretty interesting hypothesis for species differentiation in higher vertebrates, given that generations are often very long, hindering traditional accounts of evolution-through-mutation.
- sageikosa 13y agoRecombination occurs very time a new sex cell is produced during the crossing over event, Dawkins dispels the random mutation as the only means of genetic shift very early in his book "The Selfish Gene" as the crossing over process can split chromosomes mid-gene for longer, more complex DNA sequences.
- GuiA 13y ago"These days, getting a Ph.D. is probably the last thing you want to do if you are out to revolutionize the world. If, however, what you propose is an idea, rather than a technology, it can still be a valuable asset to have." Man, those newspapers' opening lines are getting worse and worse...
- Geee 13y agoExtremely interesting. I suggest you to read the article at http://www.macroevolution.net/human-origins.html http://www.macroevolution.net/human-origins.html The author seems to be a well-established scientist, and the arguments are quite plausible, given that this level of hybridization actually could be possible. What I find amazing (based on the article) is that hybridization hasn't really been researched very well, and that hybrids aren't actually infertile, on the contrary to popular belief. As the article points out, this indeed sounds as ridiculous as Darwin's proposal that humans descend from apes.
- gus_massa 13y agoMany hybrids are infertile. There are some documented cases of fertile hybrids in very related animals and very related plants (plants are weird!). http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hybrid_(biology)#Hybrid_species http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hybrid_(biology)#Hybrid_species But and hybrid between a chimp and a pig: simply no way! Even creating a live pig-chimp hybrid is probably almost impossible, a fertile pig-chimp hybrid would be a miracle.
- twstws 13y agoThis. The author makes the absurd claim that because many hybrids are fertile, any hybrid could be fertile. Using hybridization between two closely related birds to support the notion that pigs and apes could breed is ridiculous.
- goldfeld 13y agoThe scientist behind this hypothesis makes no such claim: "For my own part, curiosity has carried me away from my old idea of reality. I no longer know what to believe. Is it possible that so many biologists might be wrong about the nature of human origins? Is it possible for a pig to hybridize with a chimpanzee? I have no way of knowing at present, but I have no logical or evidential basis for rejecting the idea. Before dismissing such a notion, I would want to be sure on some logical, evidentiary basis that I actually should dismiss it. The ramifications of any misconception on this point seem immense." --from macroevolution.net He says it would be possible and there's evidence in physiology. Saying there's no way or that it would be a miracle (and dismissing it for that) is showing a misunderstanding of evolution. Given enough time and enough tries, it could happen. A bacterium becoming a mitocondrium within a cell is one of the most astounding miracles of life and scientists have never been able to reproduce it (and mind you, generations of cells come by far easier and faster than of chimps and pigs), yet it happened, perhaps exactly and only once, but it happened and that's why all animals exist. I think, like the author, that some curiosity and imagination is never a bad thing. It's led to our most interesting discoveries.
- gojomo 13y agoCan chimp-pig hybridization be reproduced in a labratory? (Would it be ethical to attempt?)
- iuguy 13y agoI believe a Dr Krieger tried several times with mixed success. Poor pigley.
- dsjoerg 13y agoMen are pigs!
- a-priori 13y agoSo colour me skeptical. As they say, extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence, and this theory is making several extraordinary claims: 1) A hybridization event indeed occurred in the relatively recent genetic history of homo sapiens (rather than the unusual anatomic features being produced some other way). 2) The hybridization was with a close relative of pigs (rather than another family that has some similar characteristics, or multiple hybridizations that together gave us the unusual characteristics). 3) The hybridization marks the point at which hominids split from the other primates (rather than occurring later in one branch of the hominid family tree). 4) That the genes introduced by hybridization gives hominids their unique characteristics (rather than being inconsequential). In return, the theory presents evidence (anatomic oddities and low fertility) that I would characterize as "interesting" and perhaps "worthy of further study", but certainly not extraordinary. For this to be plausible, there needs to be a second avenue of evidence, one not based on anatomic similarities... That second avenue could be genetic, but they specifically dismiss it, presupposing a mechanism, backcrossing, that leaves little genetic evidence that it occurred. Now, I'm no geneticist, but that sounds a bit fishy to me.
- mr_luc 13y agoClaims, yes. But he doesn't claim it. He puts it forward as a hypothesis. All useful hypothesis are, by definition, extra-ordinary.
- a-priori 13y agoOf course. It was the phys.org post which invoked Sagan's quote, and I was merely reusing it for rhetorical effect.
- mr_luc 13y agoYeah - but there is a real distinction between theory and hypothesis, which that guy is probably acutely aware of. (Cmd-F on one page of his site shows the word hypothesis used 17 times). Reading a bit more, it seems like he's got expertise in a corner of science that could be relevant to what the article calls 'morphological change': "As the increasing apparent, magnificant, speed with which morphological change can occur continues to present itself for us to comprehend, the standard theory of random mutation followed by slow environmental selection, seems to stall. In my own opinion, female choice ... , but other mechanisms of mutation ... , now need to be considered anew. The role of hybridization in driving morphological change, as McCarthy has observed time and time again, particularly in his studies of avian species ... , may be the most powerful mechanism of all." Okay, so if the "speed of change" problem is a pretty wide-open question without a lot of firm answers, and if this guy has staked out a claim in the problem space ... my reaction is basically "good on ya'!" Go play god with interspecies breeding and come back in 5 years with an update. :)
- malkia 13y agoWhat's the different between hybrids and breeds (as in dogs for example)?
- ronaldx 13y agoA simple way to define a 'species' is any group of creatures that can produce viable, fertile offspring. So dogs are breeds - they're part of the same species - because if you mate a great dane with a chihuahua, you'll get a fertile dog (I believe; if you plan to experiment, I recommend the chihuahua is male and great dane is female). If you're lucky, that dog will have desirable characteristics that may one day end up being the parent of a new breed. But horses and donkeys are not breeds - they're different species - because if you mate them you get a mule which is not fertile (a hybrid, therefore). In the end, this definition is a bit too simplistic because it's not necessarily always so clear-cut. Hence the article here :)
- nitrogen 13y agoI would expect that a "breed" should also be stable. That is, pairings between male and female members of the same breed should produce offspring of that same breed nearly every time. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Breed https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Breed
- croisillon 13y agoYour remark "I recommend the chihuahua is male and great dane is female" is interesting, but how true is it? Has anyone experience? Is it harder for a small female dog to bear puppies from a big male dog?
- ronaldx 13y agoThis is highly unlikely origin story. The main problem is that genetic data strongly and consistently suggests we are further from pigs than chimpanzees are. Genetic material often finds ways of crossing species boundaries: in lower organisms, horizontal gene transfer is commonplace. But, this is just not supported by any scientific evidence.
- hetman 13y agoI believe he addresses that by suggesting backcrossing with the chimp line. Still seems extraordinary such a cross should originally be even remotely viable.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- hetman 13y agoWhile the hypothesis itself seems rather unlikely, I think the evidence is interesting enough that further investigation would certainly yield some interesting results in their own right. Major leaps in scientific thinking can often start with some pretty radical albeit erroneous ideas. But even if not true, these ideas can encourage a fresh perspective and a new approach for teasing apart the observable world.
- thotpoizn 13y agoThis. It seems pointless to me to proceed with so much hand wringing and "my science-peen is bigger than yours" posturing, when we have ample opportunities (and plenty of pigs and bonobos) to test the hypothesis via experiment. Isn't that sort of the next step in a fairly tried-and-true method many here are usually quite fond of? Personally I think the odds of any meaningful success are extremely low, but the cost to explore and experiment are also quite low. I'd rather trust "we attempted insemination of {x} bonobos with {y} varieties of pig sperm, but failed to achieve impregnation" (... or succeeded, or whatever) - over "I'm really smart, and trust me - this couldn't possibly work."
- nealabq 13y agoJean Auel's The Clan of the Cave Bear book-series explores the possibilities of Neanderthal/Cro-Magnon interaction, but this article brings up a whole new set of intriguing plot twists.
- a_bonobo 13y agoSo far, there are two proven gene-flow events to Homo sapiens from non-sapiens: Homo neanderthalensis and from the Denisova hominin population. In the latter case science isn't sure yet whether the Denisova hominin was a sub-species or species. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Archaic_human_admixture_with_modern_Homo_sapiens http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Archaic_human_admixture_with_mo... We probably got some immunity-related genes from neanderthals, but probably not red hair - red hair in neanderthals is caused by a different mutation that doesn't exist in humans.
- johnmw 13y ago<low brow comment> So Mrs. Garrison was right all along? http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CRBHxJBUv_A http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CRBHxJBUv_A </low brow comment>
- tokenadult 13y agoGah. Another crap submission from PhysOrg. This has been going on so long that many HN participants have called that out as a bad source before. PhysOrg appears to have been banned as a site to submit from by Reddit (according to what I've read here on HN). I learned from other participants here on HN that there are better sites to submit from. Comments about PhysOrg: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3077869 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3077869 "Yes Physorg definitely has some of the worst articles on the internet." http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3198249 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3198249 "Straight from the European Space Agency, cutting out the physorg blogspam: http://www.spacetelescope.org/news/heic1116/ http://www.spacetelescope.org/news/heic1116/ (press release), http://www.spacetelescope.org/videos/heic1116a/ http://www.spacetelescope.org/videos/heic1116a/ (video), http://www.spacetelescope.org/static/archives/releases/science_papers/heic1116.pdf http://www.spacetelescope.org/static/archives/releases/scien... (paper). "PhysOrg: just say no." http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3611888 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3611888 "The physorg article summary is wrong, I think." http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4108857 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4108857 "Phys.org is vacuous and often flat wrong."
- jhewitt123 13y agoI think each submission should be judged on its own merit. HN might do better to ban crap comments like yours
- specialist 13y agoWho's got time for that? There's a reason we consider the source. The Bozo Bit works.
- jhewitt123 13y agoThe source was Eugene McCarthy from macroevolution.net. I took the time to analyze, weigh, summarize, and find a place to publish it. Physorg took it at face value from me, and published it.
- 13y ago
- webwielder 13y agoPaging Mr. Betteridge, Mr. Betteridge to the white courtesy phone.
- c3d 13y agoInterestingly, this very same hypothesis was the basis for a novel by french author Bernard Werber called "le père de nos pères" (the father of our fathers), published in 1998.
- c3d 13y agoWikipedia article http://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Le_Père_de_nos_pères http://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Le_Père_de_nos_pères
- floobynewb 13y agoI actually find this plausible. Like the author I also have problems believing that random mutation and selection is a complete/adequate explanation. Just a hunch, there's a deeper theory to be had here.