3 ms·
The proper response would have been to dig deeper. Should she have made sure that she couldn't have children first before having sex? Should she have not had se
by yummyfajitas 13y ago
The proper response would have been to dig deeper. Should she have made sure that she couldn't have children first before having sex? Should she have not had sex? How could she verify that that guy was the right guy?
Are you asserting that knowledge of birth control is somehow unavailable, as is knowledge that vaginal sex leads to pregnancy?
- anon1385 13y agoAre most people well informed about the failure rate of birth control? In my experience many are not. The original quote about her having the child of the wrong guy may as well say she 'got raped by the wrong guy'. We are rarely masters of our own fate, although I can see why you as a very wealthy individual like to delude yourself into thinking that, it's more comforting.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoThe birth rate for unmarried women is 4.7%, and the pregnancy rate for unmarried women is about 9%. http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/fastats/unmarry.htm http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/fastats/unmarry.htm http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/nvsr/nvsr56/nvsr56_15.pdf http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/nvsr/nvsr56/nvsr56_15.pdf The "perfect use" (i.e., use a condom every time) failure rate of condoms is about 2%. So at least 60% of unmarried women who give birth and 80% of unmarried women who get pregnant did so as a result of choosing to have sex without a condom.
- potatolicious 13y agoThat's not what "perfect use" means. Perfect use means using a form of birth control every time and using it correctly. Information about contraceptives is greatly lacking in many parts of the US, and condoms in particular can fail in a litany of ways besides their non-use, mostly due to user error. > "So at least 60% of unmarried women who give birth and 80% of unmarried women who get pregnant did so as a result of choosing to have sex without a condom." You're seriously reaching here. This files under the same logic as "20% of animals in the zoo are elephants, therefore the other 80% are alligators". You're jumping from "perfect use (with a gross misunderstanding of the definition of perfect use) failure rate of condoms is 2%" to "therefore it follows that everyone who doesn't fall into bucket A falls into bucket B".
- yummyfajitas 13y agoI think you are correct about the definition of "perfect use" - after googling it, it also includes people who didn't follow the rules of the method. This files under the same logic as "20% of animals in the zoo are elephants, therefore the other 80% are alligators". No, this files under the same logic as "20% of animals in the zoo are elephants, therefore the other 80% are not elephants". You either choose to use birth control and follow the rules of the method (assuming you also choose to have vaginal sex), or you don't. We can compute the pregnancy rate that would result if everyone practiced safe sex or abstinence - any excess must be the result of unsafe sex.
- HarryHirsch 13y agoThis question has been discussed for millennia, and the answer appears in the Talmud, in Berachot 5: A prisoner cannot free himself from jail.
- jjoonathan 13y agoThe information she needed to decide weather or not to have a kid was information about her and her husband's future financial status. She didn't have that -- nobody does. If Murray had a kid (or a few) and his employability then plummeted over the next few years, he would suddenly discover a host of reasons for his newfound hardship, none of which would have anything to do with failings in his moral character. Was the fact that most of her kids dropped out of college entirely their choice or did finances force the matter? Do the savings of moving to a rural area exceed the drop in job availability that would follow? Murray's opinions reek of fundamental attribution error and self-serving victim blaming, as seems to be the case with a great many critics of the "welfare state."
- tossmeup 13y agoKnowledge and access are two different things. Subsidized or free contraceptives and comprehensive sex education are economic multipliers - even for people not able or trying to have kids. Shame it's always at the top of the list as a way to help punish women who like to have sex.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoYou act as if having vaginal sex is not something people can choose to abstain from. That's nonsense - on several occasions, due to a lack of readily available birth control, I chose to receive a blowjob instead.
- saraid216 13y agoI wasn't making a statement about the current reality. I was enumerating relevant questions that needed to be asked.