3 ms·
Another thing one could try is to give everyone a guaranteed low wage job. This has fewer perverse incentives. It would also help government budgets - for exam
by yummyfajitas 13y ago
Another thing one could try is to give everyone a guaranteed low wage job. This has fewer perverse incentives.
It would also help government budgets - for example, BART trains could be cleaned by some unemployed individual making $10k/year rather than some unionized worker making $75k + benefits (or whatever the exact numbers are).
- johnchristopher 13y agoUniversal revenue of $10K allows individual to train for better jobs but a guaranteed low wage and physically demanding job make it harder to train or to get an education.
- dasmoth 13y agoDoesn't that make it very hard for the private sector to recruit low-end employees?
- yummyfajitas 13y agoNo, it makes it easier. All the private sector has to do is offer $11k. With a guaranteed income, $11k would likely be insufficient - why work for $11k when you can enjoy a life of leisure for $10k?
- dasmoth 13y agoI thought the discussion here was basic/universal income. Isn't the idea that the person paid $11k ends up receiving $10k + $11k - %tax. Otherwise you end up with 100% marginal tax rates, like in traditional benefit regimes.
- potatolicious 13y agoDo you seriously believe that anyone living in the US on $10K/year is "enjoying a life of leisure"? This is the same category of lunacy as the "the homeless are just too lazy to work" argument. Anyone who has even seen the reality on the ground for people in these situations would know not to make them.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoI strongly suspect most people living on $10k/year are enjoying a life of leisure. I don't have data on a $10k/year cutoff specifically, but available data on people below the official US poverty line certainly agrees with this general picture. http://www.bls.gov/cps/cpswp2011.pdf http://www.bls.gov/cps/cpswp2011.pdf (Note: I'm defining a "life of leisure" as one in which you choose not to work, and instead enjoy leisure time. This describes most of the poor in the US. Of course, if you define "life of leisure" as having a butler and a solid gold toilet, you get different results.)
- potatolicious 13y agoIndeed, it appears we have the same definition of "life of leisure", but to be blunt, as someone who has worked in organizations that serve the poor, you are completely out to lunch. No one is enjoying life in this country at $10K/year. The life of someone at that level is a constant barrage of worries, of harassment, of choosing between having one basic necessity of life over another. No one chooses to be there, and certainly no one would stay if they had the opportunity to exceed it. > "but available data on people below the official US poverty line certainly agrees with this general picture." You're going to have to cite specifics from that document, because all I see are labor force participation rates and income levels - there is nothing in there about people choosing not to work in favor of "enjoying leisure time". > "This describes most of the poor in the US." Really? You think the day laborer standing outside Lowe's hoping for a job has chosen to be below the poverty line, and instead has chosen a life of leisure? I'm going to state this in the most civil way I know how: you are sorely lacking in perspective - and this is after reading all of your posts in this thread so far - and for your own sake, and the sake of people you share this society with, go volunteer at a poverty or homelessness-related organization for a month. You have beliefs that are in no way grounded in reality, and the numbers you continue to cite to make your argument are between nonsensical and specious. Please find some way to experience the issues from within.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoLabor force participation rates are the relevant statistic. A person who chooses to either work or look for a job is participating in the labor force. You think the day laborer standing outside Lowe's hoping for a job has chosen to be below the poverty line, and instead has chosen a life of leisure? No, I think the 80% of the poor who chose not to participate in the labor force are the ones who have chosen a life of leisure. The day laborer you mention is one of the 20% or so who made a different choice.
- anigbrowl 13y agoWait a minute, you proposed 'to give everyone a guaranteed low wage job' for $10k. Now, I don't think this is so unreasonable, depending on how it's implemented, but it's not a 'life of leisure.' Have you switched to talking about unemployed people getting $10k, or what?
- yummyfajitas 13y agoThe guaranteed low wage job would not result in a life of leisure. The current welfare system does, and probably the basic income system also would.
- rndmize 13y agoOn the contrary, guaranteed low wage jobs sounds like it has all kinds of perverse incentives - for politicians and corporations. Not to mention, why should people have to do worthless government-assigned work to get that money? Yes, of course, there will naturally be some people that would take the 10k and live on it - as best as can be managed - but I think it would free up a great many other people to pursue work they're actually interested in, especially in the arts. In past times, the majority of human work was growing food. Today, less than 2% of the population can feed everyone else. As a result a great many people had to find other work; and they did. But now it seems that software and automation will reduce the number of people needed to do all other kinds of required work to a minimum, as happened to agriculture. Coincidentally, artistic work by and large pays less than ever today due to the ease of piracy (you can trace the profits of RIAA over the last 3 decades for a good example of this) even as more people than ever are able to do artistic work (better tools) and reach an audience at no cost (better communications). Art and entertainment will be the last bastions of human "work" when current trends start to max out. So - why not have a society where people are free to pursue the work they're interested in, whether it pays or not; where art and entertainment are possible to freely create or consume, unconstrained by the bounds of the market; and where the necessary work for human survival is compressed to a minimum of needed people that are interested in those matters and/or the money that comes with them?
- 300bps 13y ago>Yes, of course, there will naturally be some people that would take the 10k and live on it - as best as can be managed That's the thing. If $10,000 is the new $0, then it will be worth $0.
- mdda 13y agoNo : Potatoes will cost the same for everyone (even the rich). So the cost of purchasable goods does not decrease (which would happen, if some people got free potatoes, for instance). Agreed, there would be more money in the economy, so there would be a step-wise inflation, but the pain would be shared out (mainly according to ability to pay). The benefit of a basic income is that any paid work would simply add to your take-home cash. At the moment, means-tested benefits can cause people entering into the workforce to have benefits removed - so that their implicit marginal tax rate can exceed 100% (i.e. they are worse off working). Even if this perverse situation isn't directly manifested, the very poor suffer some of the highest implicit tax rates due to benefits being removed. Which is a crazy situation.
- Tichy 13y agoWhat kind of jobs do you have in mind? I have taken to saying "Everybody should have the right to a job as 'Verwaltungsfachangestellter'" (something like an office clerk). But I tend to say that in jest...
- yummyfajitas 13y agoAny low skill government job. Cleaning the BART/NYC subway/etc, simple construction work, etc. This isn't actually that wild an idea - this is what FDR did with the NRA during the great depression.
- Tichy 13y agoNot sure if assignment will be that easy - might create a lot of jobs in administration? Another thing I have realized: proponents of government spending are always right. Of course there is an optimal way to spend money, and in theory government could just decree that money should be spent in that way and things would run in an optimal fashion. The problem is that advocates of government spending tend to skimp over the aspect on how to actually determine optimal spending.
- king_jester 13y ago> Another thing one could try is to give everyone a guaranteed low wage job. This has fewer perverse incentives. This sounds like a great way to create and maintain an underclass of laborers who make less than minimum wage. No person should be forced to work just to eat or have shelter.
- epicureanideal 13y agoBut others should be forced to work to give that person food and shelter?