4 ms·
It isn't an incorrect caricature if "a lot of her advocates are purely self-interested idiots". Does not follow... The fact that a lot of Christians are ravin
by mindcrime 13y ago
It isn't an incorrect caricature if "a lot of her advocates are purely self-interested idiots".
Does not follow... The fact that a lot of Christians are raving fundamentalists who reject science and logic, is not a reflection on Christ... likewise, that a lot of self-described Randians may be "purely self-interested idiots" is no reflection on Rand. Rand can't control what the people who come after her and claim association with her name do, any more than Jesus can. Substitute any other famous/influential character from history for Rand or Jesus in the above, and the point remains the same.
- anigbrowl 13y agoI'm an atheist, but grew up Catholic and I know religious doctrine very well indeed. Jesus didn't build his reputation on telling people to ignore science and logic; for every exhortation to his followers that they needed to have some faith in God, there was another one that was very practical, such as 'God helps those who help themselves.' There's no way he expected people to pray for rain only to die of thirst, if there was a lake within walking distance. I don't want to assign the faults of Randians to Rand, but I think it's fair to say tat she disapproved of altruism and reified individualism as the acme of human achievement. I can sort of understand this given the circumstances of her birth and so on, but Rand (or at least the average Randian) seems suspicious of voluntary and specific collectivism as well as mandatory or universal collectivism. I'm a bit of a hermit, but when I am being social I like working on a team and I find the relentless insistence on individualism as the only valid kind of self-actualization rather pathetic.