4 ms·
Here's an experiment. Let's give 92% of all of the income that the rich people make to the poor. How much will there be to go around? Not enough by a long shot.
by briandear 13y ago
Here's an experiment. Let's give 92% of all of the income that the rich people make to the poor. How much will there be to go around? Not enough by a long shot. If we taxed the rich at 100% it wouldn't even cover the budget deficit for one year.
But, these folks that make a fairly middle income suggesting that someone else give more are exactly the problem. No one wants to give more when it reduces their quality of life. There are plenty of people waiting for kidney transplants, yet when was the last time a New Yorker writer went to volunteer to give up a kidney for someone he's never met?
America should ask why manufacturing has left the US. Rising costs. Yet what has caused costs to rise? It isn't like greed is a new invention. Something has changed though .. Burdensome regulation and unfettered litigation for one. Have you ever tried to open a factory in California? Good luck. It can take years and sometimes a decade due to NIMBY politics. In China, you can have a factory opened in just over a year -- construction and government approvals included. I won't suggest we turn into China but the extreme on the other end is what we're facing. The increasing numbers of poor are the result of an economic environment that is primarily caused by limousine left wingers that think they've been anointed guardians of everyone else's destiny. They'd rather stop a factory from being built and have the potential workers in poverty from which they can eventually be saved by government intervention. The cite boogey men such as "CO2" yet, poverty causes for death than CO2 ever has.
The rich CEOs aren't stealing from the people, they're players within the system just like everyone else. They don't make the laws. As far as rich, there are plenty of $120,000 per year developers on HN that wouldn't think of working for $60k. To a poor person, 60k is a fortune. I think some religious figure once said something about casting the first stone.. There was another dude from India that mentioned something about all life being suffering. There will always be poor people because life has winners and losers. To suggest any different is to revisit the 'prosperity' of the Soviet Union in the 1950s.
- Nursie 13y ago>> Let's give 92% of all of the income that the rich people make to the poor. How much will there be to go around? Not enough by a long shot. If we taxed the rich at 100% it wouldn't even cover the budget deficit for one year. This is a bit of a non sequitur. The budget doesn't only go on the poor.
- anon1385 13y ago>Let's give 92% of all of the income that the rich people make to the poor. How much will there be to go around? Not enough by a long shot. If we taxed the rich at 100% it wouldn't even cover the budget deficit for one year. You seem to be under the mistaken impression that the poor don't pay taxes, and that individuals and companies producing the goods they consume don't pay taxes.
- gjm11 13y ago> Let's give 92% of all of the income that the rich people make to the poor. How much will there be to go around? Not enough by a long shot. The top 1% of people in the US have about 20% of the income. The US's GNI is about $14T, so that's about $3T for the top 1%. (So an average of about $1M per person; of course that's the mean; the median will be lower, and the threshold for the top 1% lower again.) The official poverty line in the US is about $23k for a family of four; let's say $6k per person. The number of officially-poor people in the US is about 40M. If we suppose all those people are earning precisely nothing at present, taking them up to the poverty line would therefore cost about $240B, less than 10% of the income of the top 1%. So ... it seems like giving 92% of the income of the rich to help the poor would help them rather a lot, actually.
- inthewoods 13y ago"The rich CEOs aren't stealing from the people, they're players within the system just like everyone else. They don't make the laws." Actually, they do write the laws. They fund special interest groups and give money to politicians to get elected. Big money often writes the law - with those same special interest groups attaching themselves to Congressional staffers and then providing the actual language that goes to the floor. I don't know what world you think you're living in when you can't see how money shapes our politics and laws.