4 ms·
His meaning was quite clear from what he wrote. If you must, argue against his points, don't just appeal to emotions - they are never useful for conducting poli
by tomjen3 13y ago
His meaning was quite clear from what he wrote. If you must, argue against his points, don't just appeal to emotions - they are never useful for conducting policy.
- enraged_camel 13y agoI'm not appealing to emotion. My question is rather simple and I want him/her to answer it.
- icebraining 13y agoIt's not just an appeal to emotion, there's a valid point in enraged_camel's post. It's not hypocrisy to defend redistribution only by people who own more than X, even if that X is above the author's income. There's a qualitative difference between owning a median income and "fuck you money". regal's point, on the other hand, is not only completely speculative, as it's completely irrelevant, because the argument isn't invalidated even if stated by an hypocrite.
- fudisgud 13y agoscoff Funny you're complaining about that comment: This whole piece is one big emotion appeal for class warfare and unionism "If only Little Johnny's parent's union jobs didn't disappear, then he wouldn't have lived in a broken home, and would have buckled down and gone to college!" "Why does this group of people, who I know little about as individuals, have it so well?!" Typical bleeding-heart bull, which is, of course, what this movie is about (and how this author barkers for his friend's movie). "Come one, and all, see how unfair life is in America!" It's too bad these families both work so hard and barely get by. Maybe they did get screwed over by circumstance. Maybe they shouldn't had assume union jobs were forever. Maybe the lure of a paying job today to help the family kept those kids out of college. Or maybe those kids were fuck ups and didn't take school seriously. I guess I should pay for a ticket to find out if I should feel superior to the family or to the CEOs. Complaining about how life is unfair will get folks into the art movie theater, but it's not going to provide opportunities for these families to better their lot.