2 ms·
> Cryptocat is simpler to use because it's a simpler, less secure system. Simple does not need to mean less secure. HTTPS is easy (for the user) and secure. >
by raverbashing 13y ago
> Cryptocat is simpler to use because it's a simpler, less secure system.
Simple does not need to mean less secure. HTTPS is easy (for the user) and secure.
> They should spend their time building a similar interface for GPG and give up on the custom cryptosystem
Yes, that could be an approach, using a higher level crypto infrastructure and focusing on the UX.
- tptacek 13y agoNo, that's not true. HTTPS is simpler than GPG and also provides less security. You rely on HTTPS/TLS today with certificate-pinned DHE HTTPS connections to Gmail. Clearly, the people who use Cryptocat don't feel like they're getting enough security from Gmail. HTTPS is simpler to use because it's a simpler, less secure system.
- raverbashing 13y agoHow much less secure exactly? Certificate pinning certainly helps in some cases (unless the pinning itself is attacked, which may be possible). You just seem to be confirming my point, that in the name of "more security" they're shunning everything that's not their idea of "perfect security" (which may be faulty). Result: less people using encryption. It's one thing to use a fragile encryption key like the Cryptocat failure, another to exclude RSA in favour of ECC (except if you're dealing with leaking government secrets of course)
- tptacek 13y agoI don't know how to answer this question. I'm not sure what you mean by RSA and ECC. The answer to how much more secure GPG on your desktop is than TLS to Gmail is "much more secure".
- StavrosK 13y agoThe question can be answered in terms of "how many people do I need to trust in each case for my communication to remain private?" In the former case, it's "the intended recipient" and in the latter case, it's "a few thousand people".
- tbirdz 13y agoRSA refers to Rivest-Shamir-Adleman and ECC refers to Elliptic curve cryptography. They are both algorithms which take different approaches to public key cryptography. RSA has been in use for longer than ECC and it's considered to be more well understood. However there are some exciting things going on with ECC, for example it is thought that you could have the same or better security as RSA with a much smaller ECC keysize.
- Sami_Lehtinen 13y agoUsing 521 bits with ECC is comparable to 15000+ bits with RSA.
- jiggy2011 13y agoSSL has various problems, mostly related to CAs. Also it is only easy to use because the server admin has done the hard part for you, therefor you have to trust them. To apply SSL to a cryptocat style system would require both parties to generate keys and somehow verify them, not so simple.
- tptacek 13y agoWhile I think SSL/TLS is "less secure" in some sense than GPG, which is fundamentally end-to-end, I still think SSL/TLS is a good system, if for no other reason than that it's the focus of a huge amount of research. The CA problems with HTTPS/TLS aren't fundamental to SSL/TLS. They're a consequence of browser UI. If you build your own software that uses TLS to make secure connections, you have a variety of options to avoid the browser CA problem; you can run your own CA (every instance of Burp Suite, the industry standard web pentest tool, does exactly that), or you can verify certificate fingerprints statically, or you can invent a new authentication system.
- jiggy2011 13y agoYes, that's a good point. However you are always somewhat reliant on a third party to do the security for you whether that is a CA or an app developer. That third party has to be trusted. It doesn't solve the fundamental problem of: Alice -> Bob without doing. Alice -> Facebook -> Bob Unless both alice and bob know how to generate and manage their own keys (and verify each others keys).
- tptacek 13y agoNo, also not true. You can use the TLS protocol to build a "web of trust" scheme just like GPG's out of self-signed certificates and key continuity.
- jiggy2011 13y agoRight, but web of trusts/PGP are inconvenient in a way that "look for the padlock icon" isn't. Which is likely why they are not in widespread use by the general populous.