5 ms·
For all the people ranting about what an incompetent this guy is, why does no one complain that stuff like GPG is so complicated that 1) Ordinary people probab
by davidw 13y ago
For all the people ranting about what an incompetent this guy is, why does no one complain that stuff like GPG is so complicated that
1) Ordinary people probably can't use it.
2) It probably would be pretty easy to talk ordinary people into sending you their private keys/passphrases/etc... in the guise of 'helping' them, because it's so complicated.
No one seems to talk about horrible complexity as a big security vulnerability.
Also, I agree that there is something not quite right in the security community that often makes them talk with their Comic Book Guy voices.
- DanBC 13y agoeh, I've said that many times. I've even said it on HN.
- zainny 13y agoBut why would anyone even bother trying to fix the situation? Any attempt to will just result in the entire crypto community community calling you "worthless" and "unqualified". This is the entire problem. Funnily enough, I imagine the original implementers of the major crypto libraries we use today and take for granted would probably equally be called "idiots" and "losers" if judged by today's internet crypto heroes. The crypto community is flat out toxic. You ain't gonna see progress from anywhere until the situation changes.
- davidw 13y agoI think you're being unfair by painting them all with the same brush. But there is definitely a 'tone' in that community that I find very off-putting. This thread was interesting - tptacek seems like a nice enough guy - he's very helpful here and certainly knowledgeable, and generally pleasant to interact with: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5776111 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5776111 I agree with you that the "don't do that" attitude seems a bit... binary. Who decides who gets to do what? At what point does it become 'ok' to do crypto stuff? What kind of crypto stuff? Putting together pieces like SSL and GPG? Writing crypto libraries? New crypto algorithms? I'm mostly a believer in leaving the latter to people who have demonstrable competence in the field, but lots of people need to put together pieces in some way and the "don't do that" attitude does not really solve that problem.
- tptacek 13y agoDon't let me off the hook; I am 1000% "that guy" when it comes to software security stuff. Also US law, sous vide cooking, C software development, the music of the Elephant 6 collective, tech entrepreneurship, and parenting.
- oinksoft 13y agoIt's my perception that people seriously involved in mathematics, particularly sensitive things like crypto, must have a thick skin. It's a field that is all hard skills and no soft skills, and I'm not sure it could practically be any other way. The professional is either intensely correct or incorrect, and often provably so. Like in this case. I can call your ChicagoBoss application crap, say it is far from OTP design principle, baked with magic parse transforms, etc. and I'd be an asshole because it's a matter of design opinion, not provable fact. The author here has published a crack that absolutely proves that the CryptoCat guys were wrong, and that matters.
- davidw 13y agoIt's very easy to say someone is wrong, though, without calling them a shithead. Indeed, you could even go so far as to say that it fosters a more open, inviting atmosphere if you concentrate on what's right, and what's wrong, and let people have the freedom to be wrong without being labeled assholes, incompetents, and worse. This is why you don't find, in most scientific papers, descriptions of other scientists work as 'crap' or 'stupid', even if they do point out the most glaring of errors. It's left to the reader to assign the 'stupid' label. In this specific case, I agree that there's some justified anger at labeling something ready for public consumption that appears not to be. But I just get a sense of so many crypto/security discussions being a dick-waving contest.
- Ixiaus 13y agoYou know, it's funny, because as a programmer and watching this interaction happen over the years (between programmers and people that are good at cryptography/security) I've come to this conclusion: It's down to the fact that developers are not engineers. In the sense that anyone can "sling" some code together and call it an application; but that isn't engineering. Cryptographers have a similar set of moral and ethical imperatives that medical doctors, civil engineers, or even aerospace engineers (may) have. If the guy down the street that's read a few books and built a few tree houses (or maybe even something more complex and impressive) goes to build a bridge intended to be used by anyone; any sane civil engineer would have every right to trash on him. I don't entirely understand the mushy "be nice to him, he's learning" attitude everyone has (that's what school and learning environments are for!!!) because it's precisely that personal attitude that has resulted in the loss of credit card data, sensitive passwords stored in big services, secrets that people would (literally) kill for, &c... This shit isn't a joke and I fully support any cryptographer being a hard-ass because they are the ones that put in the time to learn, practice, fuck up, and re-learn what it means to encrypt something. As programmers we don't even have a code of conduct, or ethical pact. Cryptographers have one but, they do, not because they all sat down and decided they should but because it's a natural consequence of what it is they are working on. As a cryptographer you cannot morally support an incompetent (and even a competent) programmer in rolling their own crypto; not because they are all assholes, but because they believe in privacy to a degree the rest of us don't.
- DanBC 13y agoWait, if someone created documents to help people use PGP or GPG, and released those as beta versions, I believe they'd get mostly useful help and advice. I agree that they'd still get some toxic comments. This is a problem. As understand it the Math stack-exchange site had problems with toxic members. Perhaps it's a math thing?
- davidw 13y agoIt's more than documents, it's that they wrote those programs with complex ways of interacting with them. To be fair, they have improved with time, but I don't want to let that get in the way of making my point. I'm going to dredge up my best Comic Book Guy to comment as an example: "The audacity these security guys have to release such critical software with such a poorly considered user interface is mind boggling, and makes it clear that they care not one whit for their users. Someone so incompetent in the field of user interaction should probably stay in their room playing with crayons. This software is full of stupid UI mistakes, and run by people who clearly know nothing about interacting with other human beings - our only meager consolation from this is that they will clearly never manage to reproduce". Now, I'm just kidding around, am extremely glad we have the software we do have, and am pretty shitty at making UI's myself, but that kind of discussion is really not pleasant at all to deal with.
- napoleond 13y agoI can personally verify this. Anecdotal, but still: for the past several months I've been working on an app that makes PGP/GPG easier to use for average people[0], and the crypto community has been astoundingly supportive (I was scared, at first). The difference is that my team isn't rolling our own crypto, and we've been adamant about that from the start. 0. http://parley.co http://parley.co
- tptacek 13y agoI hear this all the time but I think it's a little verkakte. Here's why: First, GPG isn't that hard to use. When people say this, I assume they're referring to the command-line tools. But nobody advocating GPG for "ordinary people" thinks they should be using the command line tools. Here's the day-to-day UX for GPG in Mail.app: (1) ask for acquaintance's key, (2) double click it in the email message when it arrives, (3) optionally call acquaintance the first time you use the key to verify it, (4) send acquaintance mail. Depending on your settings, you may need a step (5), "push encryption button in mail composer window". Second, to the extent that GPG is fussy, it's fussy because it's trying to solve a difficult problem. Wanting the problem to be easier doesn't make it easier. We would all be better off if all mail was opportunistically encrypted (OE was the dream of the late '90s, where you wouldn't even need to ask, and software would just figure out when it was possible to encrypt traffic). But GPG is doing more than OE does, because GPG is guaranteed end-to-end, even in conversations with multiple people. OE-style encryption is not that far from what we already have today with certificate-pinned DHE TLS to Gmail. We could definitely use better UX for PGP (the fact that GPGMail is the best we have right now is telling). But that's not what tools like this are; they're not a better UX for a proven system. They're not even the same kind of system. Cryptocat provides weaker guarantees than GPG does. It's simpler to use because it's a simpler, less secure system. As to Comic Book Guy voice: yes, that's something that happens in infosec. You should be able to see why: it's a field populated by nerds that is uniquely adversarial. Bruce Schneier hasn't taken that tone with Cryptocat, but he's taken it with other people. If you go looking for patronizing, pedantic, dismissive tone in infosec, you're sure to find it. But let's not lose sight of the fact that the people taking that tone are (a) in this case right and (b) taking the time to communicate that rightness on their own dime. Nobody paid Steve Thomas or Adam Langley to find bugs in Cryptocat.
- davidw 13y agoI don't really have a dog in this fight, I'm not defending cryptocat, but pointing out that the "dealing with people" part is difficult, too, and that in some ways, crypto software hasn't done a particularly good job at it, especially in the past. Presumably, they have improved at it over time thanks to the suggestions, comments, and help of others. I agree that it's a difficult thing to make simple for 'ordinary people'. I think "adversarial nerds" hits the nail on the head. I understand it, but I don't have to like it.