6 ms·
So, let's see. The NSA does it, GCHQ does it, DGSE does it. The operating assumption should be that all countries are monitoring all communications for at least
by jgrahamc 13y ago
So, let's see. The NSA does it, GCHQ does it, DGSE does it. The operating assumption should be that all countries are monitoring all communications for at least metadata. Personally, I would not be the slightest bit surprised to learn that all phone calls are being recorded and as much Internet traffic as possible.
I'm not surprised by this news at all. The technical means have been there for years and years. And the desire has been there for much longer. Anyone who reads the history of SIGINT will understand that the desire to capture all communications is perfectly normal in that environment.
Snowden's "revelations" are completely unsurprising to anyone who has thought about this and the technology. I'm still waiting for him to reveal something actually surprising.
- motters 13y agoJust because it's unsurprising that doesn't make it ok.
- bnegreve 13y ago> So, let's see. The NSA does it, GCHQ does it, DGSE does it. The operating assumption should be that all countries are monitoring [...] USA, UK and France are not any contry the're all at the top of this list: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_military_expenditures http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_military_e... It doesn't say much about other contries.
- lucian1900 13y agoIt is still very useful to have proof. It dispels the image of conspiracy theory.
- coldtea 13y agoWe are way past this now. If anything, we have the opposite problems of "apology theorists" and "coincidence theorists". People have been trained to think "conspiracy" is some BS endeavour that includes aliens in Roswell, mind control, illuminati etc. Fact is, most of history has seen covert action by governments and organisations. Those are also conspiracies (by definition), and it's totally wrong (and disingenuous) to lump them with BS conspiracy theories.
- panacea 13y agoIt's no big deal. We all suspected it. It's so unsurprising that the US forced a foreign president to touch down and have his plane searched in a foreign country to try and catch the whistleblower.
- threeseed 13y agoYou needed proof to know the US government was spying ? It isn't some giant secret you know: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Security_Agency http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Security_Agency
- lucian1900 13y agoUntil recently, it was considered ridiculous to think that the NSA is spying on citizens of countries allied to the US. Now we have proof.
- Aloisius 13y agoRidiculous by whom? It wouldn't surprise me if we spied on our allies citizens and then sold the intelligence to our allies so they didn't have to. I mean, we have in the past warned allies that one of their citizens was planning an attack. It should have been obvious that meant we were monitoring their citizens.
- rtpg 13y agoI think people too often discount the fact that for the NSA system, there's actually oversight. Or at least they try very hard to make it seem like there is. I haven't seen that in the European stuff, and that's what worries me.
- morsch 13y agoWhether or not it's surprising is totally irrelevant and you should stop pretending it isn't, if that is what you're saying. But you've got an interesting point in that the desire has always been to capture everything -- while the technical means to do it have been available for a couple of years. Along with a further shift in how people communicate towards easily moniterable technology, that is the crux of the matter. It was one thing to have secret societies intent on capturing everything in the 60s, when technology limited the scope of the operation. It's another thing when that intention is not readjusted to the societal and technical realities of 50 years later. That's why it seems like such a sudden, surprising change in policy to some who haven't kept up with the technical possibilities for surveillance, while others realize it's been a slow change going on for decades now. And of course, for the past decades some of us have been trying to point out the technical possibilities to everyone who would listen, only to get told that just because it's possible doesn't mean it's being done -- we're not surprised by Snowden's leaks, but certainly vindicated.
- jgrahamc 13y agoThis is a discussion on HN, not in a general public forum. Sure, the general public is probably surprised by what's been revealed but we should not be.
- kenjackson 13y agoI've actually found the less technically savvy less surprised and less outraged.
- lttlrck 13y agoHmm. Maybe HN isn't the community I thought it was then.
- contingencies 13y agoSome. I think it depends if you can explain it properly. That was supposed to be the media's job, in the 'self-regulating' system of democracy. Obviously, that failed. So now we have non-democracy, and little way out except...
- grey-area 13y agoI'm not surprised by this news at all. The technical means have been there for years and years. Have you thought through the implications of this? To me capturing and storing all the information we generate is really dangerous, and there's no way I'd want a log of everything in my life to be accessible to my secret service, my government, police, and the secret services of anyone they might wish to share it with (in particular the NSA) in secret and without my permission. You've carefully avoided stating an opinion on these actions of our security services, but presented it as a fait accompli that we may as well just live with. I disagree. They've lied to us about what they were collecting (everything) and lied to us about what it is for (terror). I see no reason to trust any assurances or controls which are introduced on access, and the only way to stop abuse is to stop collection. It appears they're not yet at the point where they can store all information indefinitely, but that point will arrive soon, and I think we should stop them before it does. I don't even trust the current politicians and police with this information on every citizen, let alone any conceivable politician who might come to power in the next few centuries. IMHO we should have strong protections banning outright the collection and collation of this sort of material except where there are reasons to be believe someone is a serious criminal (violence, fraud, terror), with judicial oversight, for a limited time, with the data deleted after the trial. Just as the police are not allowed to demand DNA samples from entire populations in order to solve a crime, security services should not be allowed to store our every move and thought in the name of defending liberty, it makes a mockery of the concepts they claim to be protecting, and is extremely dangerous in the long term.
- jgrahamc 13y agoYou've carefully avoided stating an opinion on these actions of our security services, but presented it as a fait accompli that we may as well just live with You want my opinion? I agree: it's very dangerous for the state to have detailed information about an individual's life. The potential for abuse is enormous.
- grey-area 13y agoThank you. I find that information far more interesting than whether you are surprised by surveillance, but perhaps that's just me.
- tomelders 13y agoAnd for what, with surveillance like this, how is there still crime and terrorism? either it's ineffective or they're overselling the capabilities or they're more interested in dissidents, and judging by the way activists and whistle blowers are being treated, i suspect this is the real reason these systems exist. EDIT: Or there's some other threat none of us know about and these systems are working perfectly at keeping us all safe... but that's a long shot.
- a3n 13y agoWe have never been attacked by space aliens. The system works.
- TeMPOraL 13y agoActually, we have been. Twice. That you never heard about this is the proof the system works. (don't ask me how I know about those attacks)
- threeseed 13y agoSo the government is NOT trying to prevent terrorism but instead has setup these elaborate systems just to prevent activism and whistle blowing. You sure that aliens aren't involved somewhere in there ? The FACTS are this. The head of the NSA has testified in front of congress that over 50 potential terrorist acts were thwarted because of PRISM since 9/11 including bombing of the NY subways and stock exchange. And there is no evidence that the infrastructure the NSA has is available to every single cop in every town in order to fight crime.
- asynchronous13 13y agoThe head of National Intelligence testified in front of congress, too. When asked if they were collecting "any type of data at all on millions or hundreds of millions of Americans", he said, "No.". When the question was repeated, he said, "Not wittingly." So he outright lied to congress. The information that you claim is a fact is from a source that I no longer believe.
- 13y ago
- JulianMorrison 13y agoWe need to stop being so blasé about the way countries spy on each other and the general public. No, it's not anything new. Yes, spies spy, that's their job. But it shouldn't be their job.
- PavlovsCat 13y agoExactly.. so many unexamined assumptions go into all this.
- coldtea 13y ago>Snowden's "revelations" are completely unsurprising to anyone who has thought about this and the technology. I'm still waiting for him to reveal something actually surprising. To someone used to an abusive relationship, no abuse is surprising. "Oh, now he hit me with a metal club. Big fucking deal" That doesn't make it acceptable or non dangerous. So I wouldn't be waiting, like a mere spectator on something that doesn't affect me, for him to "reveal something actually surprising".
- tptacek 13y agoHe didn't say "big fucking deal". A guy menaces you with a metal club. Then he hits you with it. That's a big fucking deal, and also not a surprise.
- _djo_ 13y agoExactly, this is what I've been pointing out: Every government with the means to monitor domestic and foreign communications does so and invariably stretches the law in order to achieve it. That's why I've felt the focus on the NSA and GCHQ (i.e. the US and and UK) was misplaced. The focus should be on better privacy protections and rolling back state surveillance in all countries, not just the two whose programs are the best-known. In fact the understanding of how widespread this is may reignite the push for better client-side privacy and anonymity protection tools.
- logn 13y agoI have good info that NORAD has been tracking Santa for years with GPS tracking by remotely enabling cell phones he's carrying as presents. In seriousness though, you're absolutely right and I feel the same way. I think the important thing here is that it's the first time the general public (and much of the tech community) has been presented this information in a straight-forward way. Also, people who had long ago deduced everything being revealed now (like me) will hopefully see the full extent of everything that's been happening. I have additional things I figure have been going on but which I loathe to discuss for fear of sounding paranoid. However, I used to feel that way when talking about the gov't reading email and tracking your FB activities, so it's nice to finally be able to discuss that with people and not seem like a lunatic or have the issue immediately dismissed. edit: But let me make a tinfoil hat prediction now, and I can point back to this post one day to maybe win a bet: The private data collected on everyone is being shared with government workers (and private contractors) on all levels in some form. I think that many, many depts and orgs across federal, state, and local levels are privy to our personal/private data at least in aggregate/anonymized form whether they realize it or not. For instance, I think at least a small portion of police and fire responses are triggered by our private data, perhaps in a way that those responders don't even realize. It's a crazy idea and perhaps I'll head over to the TwoPlusTwo forums to begin taking bets :)
- mtgx 13y agoI hate, hate, hate comments like these. They serve absolutely no purpose other than saying I told you so. Yes, some of us understood the spying is broad, but I don't think most of us expected the cables to be tapped directly, and take all the data like from a firehose and store it all. How can you say even that doesn't surprise you? And even if it doesn't you think 99% of the people out there understood this? Does your mom or dad think it's okay their phone calls are stored and analyzed by the government? Anyway, just because you (probably) knew this was going on, doesn't mean there shouldn't be a time to get outraged about it.
- achughes 13y agoNo. OP is saying that he is not outraged because he wasn't surprised. He may not like the fact that it is happening, but he is not outraged. That was the point of the comment. A little bit of 'I told you so', and a little more of 'stop getting so upset, because if you really cared you would have known.' The only thing that changed with Snowden is that now you know about it. But lets be honest, we are talking about spying. If we didn't already know, we should have assumed, because the point of spying is to know everything. What did everybody thing spying was? Because it certainly isn't legal. And now that everybody understands what spying entails I am supposed to be outraged? Yawn. Wake me up when the secret police ACTUALLY start taking people away. Because until till then, the NSA is doing its job, and that is spying however legal or illegal it may be. But when that day comes, if history serves as any precedent, I'll know about it before you do.
- pinaceae 13y agoor even more to the point, national intelligence agencies actually spy, news at 11. if i were journalist i would compile a list of all of those agencies and then release a "story" each week. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_intelligence_agencies http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_intelligence_agencies enough to milk this topic for years. i am austrian, so our HNA http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heeresnachrichtenamt http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heeresnachrichtenamt would be my "scandal". they run a sigint station smack in the center of vienna, located in a WW2 flaktower. public knowledge, but just add Snowden, Morales, some other bullshit and voila, another great feat of journalism.
- _k 13y agoIt's no surprise but give me 6 months of your data and I will use it to turn you into a criminal. It's no surprise but it's a huge problem.