3 ms·
Argument from emotion.
by SilasX 13y ago
Argument from emotion.
- coldtea 13y agoYes. Because we are humans, not Vulcans. Someone saying: "Don't hit me, please" is also an argument from emotion.
- astine 13y agoThat's not an argument, it's a request.
- antiterra 13y agoSwooping down to declare a fallacy then immediately swishing your cape and dashing away is highly unlikely to gain much social traction or admiration. Also, when arguing if something is in a particular spirit, it's appropriate to discuss emotions and principles.
- SilasX 13y agoIt was just a brief way of saying, "All you've communicated is that the equation of the two doesn't feel right, without giving anyone a reason to deem your view more persuasive." This is basically what happened: A: That seems dangerously close to eugenics, in that it's weeding out people with bad genes. B: Oh yeah? If you distorted your view by listening to crying moms who agree with me (and not similar weepers on the other side), you'd agree with me. Me: Argument from emotion.
- moomin 13y agoLet's try something a little more intellectual: there's also the aspect that eugenics is an idea directed to the improvement of humanity (an idea I'm... suspicious of) and abortions are decision by individuals reflecting individual circumstance. I don't believe these decisions are made on the eugenics basis: that disabled people are somehow worse than other people. Eugenics is relatively easy to judge: you can get all the facts. Individual decisions are always harder: you don't know the full circumstance. I'm not saying that their aren't abortions made for obscene reasons (terminating girls is an obvious example), but not all are.
- moomin 13y agoI claim that any argument about "in spirit" is necessarily about emotion. The original statement struck me as veering pretty close to Godwin's law.
- deadairspace 13y agoArgument from fallacy.