22 ms·
I don't know what he usually says, because I don't follow him, but I remember hearing him in a speech say that "you shouldn't use Cryptocat if your life depends
by mtgx 13y ago
I don't know what he usually says, because I don't follow him, but I remember hearing him in a speech say that "you shouldn't use Cryptocat if your life depends on it" or something like that.
I've just checked, and he seems to give that warning on the site, although below the fold:
"Cryptocat is not a magic bullet. You should never trust any piece of software with your life, and Cryptocat is no exception"
https://crypto.cat/ https://crypto.cat/
- DanBC 13y agoWell, that's good. I can't edit my comment, so I accept here that I'm wrong about that.
- amouat 13y agoIt's somewhat undermined by the statement directly above it: "LGBTQ activists use Cryptocat to keep private matters private. Journalists use Cryptocat to keep their stories and research confidential. Cryptocat is made for everyone." which suggests that it is secure and reliable enough to be used in sensitive situations.
- venomsnake 13y agoOutings in large parts of the world - even in the first world can be life threatening. This contradicts directly with don't use it if your life depends on it.
- kybernetyk 13y agoTo me that disclaimer sounds rather like those disclaimers on dietary supplements. They have to write that the supplement isn't medicine and might not work but the whole product packaging and marketing implies that it will work just like medicine. "Yeah, yeah, crypto cat is software and no software is perfect. But ... that's just a stupid disclaimer. Use cryptocat anyways, guys."
- tptacek 13y agoElsewhere: "Cryptocat Passes Security Audit With Flying Colors". "It’s no secret that there was a lot of celebration here at Cryptocat over these results. Completely passing an audit with zero weaknesses or vulnerabilities is a rare event even for very high-profile software. This is perhaps Cryptocat’s greatest achievement yet."
- thesmileyone 13y agoWould it pass a Matasano audit? ;)
- tptacek 13y agoI have no idea. We wouldn't have assessed it. A single person/week to assess a whole multiparty cryptosystem? Absurd.
- marshray 13y agohttps://blog.crypto.cat/2012/12/lebanese-government-asking-for-facebook-passwords-cryptocat-statement/ https://blog.crypto.cat/2012/12/lebanese-government-asking-f... vvvvvv quote begins vvvvvv (هذا المقال مترجم إلى اللغة العربية فالأسفل) – Arabic Translation follows We’d like to talk about today’s news in Lebanon concerning the Lebanese Internal Security Forces demanding access to Facebook passwords from the Minister of Telecommunications. This notion is unacceptable, and the Cryptocat Project is moving forward on proposing solutions for Lebanese people on how to protect themselves against this sort of seizure, should it happen. What Cryptocat can do for you We would like to suggest to Lebanese citizens to use Cryptocat instead of Facebook chat to communicate. You can download Cryptocat here (it’s available in Arabic) — to the best of our ability, we have attempted to make Cryptocat a private, useful and open platform for easy to use IM. We want to offer it as an alternative in this time of potential legislative abuse. Cryptocat cannot promise you perfect privacy — at best, we are promising a slightly better alternative to Facebook chat. What Cryptocat can’t do for you Here we must repeat the warning from our project website: Cryptocat is not yet ready to be used in extreme situations. Don’t rely on Cryptocat if your life is threatened — it’s experimental software. But that doesn’t mean that Cryptocat can’t provide reliable, useful privacy for many individuals. Use Cryptocat if you are in Lebanon and want to talk with your friends without the notion of a government request for Facebook passwords hanging over your head. I am in Beirut I (Nadim, Cryptocat developer) am currently in Beirut. You can reach me at nadim@crypto.cat — send me an email if you have any questions on how you or your community can protect your digital privacy, please come to my workshop at the Lamba Labs hackerspace tomorrow. ^^^^^^ end of quote ^^^^^^