4 ms·
"BART pre-emptively shut down the cell network prior to an #occupy protest" This is not quite false, but potentially misleading for those uninformed. They tur
by dllthomas 13y ago
"BART pre-emptively shut down the cell network prior to an #occupy protest"
This is not quite false, but potentially misleading for those uninformed. They turned off repeaters they owned; the ground blocked the signals. There was no active interference.
Anyone can, of course, draw whatever conclusions they want given the facts, but (as I understand things) those are they, and hopefully we won't get off on "BUT JAMMING CELL PHONES IS ILLEGAL" tangents.
- ChuckMcM 13y agoInteresting comment. They explicitly disabled equipment that provided access to the network which they expected to be used by #occupy protesters in the organization of their protest. They certainly had the 'right' to shut down their own equipment. Their stated intent was to disrupt protests. Egypt turned off the Internet during the Arab spring by turning off their own routers (which they owned and was their right) with the explicit goal of disrupting the protesters ability to organize and communicate. The common theme here is the use of existing infrastructure in the organization and coordination of protests. In both Egypt and BART and Turkey's case the infrastructure had a designed non-protest-organizing modality. When the infrastructure gets shut down to cut off protesters it also impacts non-protesters in a potentially severe way. The lesson here is that it is possible to create infrastructure on demand which does not require all of your participants to be self identifying by carrying some sort of specialized equipment. Had the protesters been using the 'family radio' frequencies, the ones that are so often abused at DisneyLand, searching and removing radios from people allow them to disrupt their organization. Whereas everyone has a phone, so it is impractical to confiscate all phones in order to prevent lawful demonstrations.
- dllthomas 13y agoYes. I am not saying "therefore it was okay", just pre-empting certain unproductive lines of discussion and outrage. If you feel the actions were nonetheless inappropriate, you (and others) have every right to be outraged for real reasons; in fact, I encourage it.