2 ms·
I found this part of the article particularly interesting, because I've seen more than a few comment threads on HN lately where people say you can't be arrested
by grecy 13y ago
I found this part of the article particularly interesting, because I've seen more than a few comment threads on HN lately where people say you can't be arrested for resisting arrest alone (as it makes no logical sense)
Because Contempt of Cop has yet to be codified into our criminal statutes, the trooper allegedly drew a blank at first when filling out his report. But even the final reduced charges are ridiculous, especially the resisting arrest charge. If you're going to charge someone with resisting arrest, it should logically follow that an arrest was already in progress.
- tptacek 13y agoCan you point us to a thread where someone actually said you can't get arrested for resisting arrest? That's a nonsensical belief. You do not have a right to resist arrest.
- grecy 13y agoThey said you can't be arrested for resisting arrest alone, of which there have been many recent cases.
- tptacek 13y agoI'm not sure I understand what you're saying. If you're arrested "for resisting arrest", there must have been some arrest in progress. I assume the claim is instead that the arrest was somehow invalid. Some states have an affirmative defense to "resisting" charges when excessive force is used, but otherwise: resisting arrest is itself a crime. If the police try to arrest you, don't fight back.
- grecy 13y ago> If you're arrested "for resisting arrest", there must have been some arrest in progress. That's exactly how a sane person would expect it to work, but it's not the case lately in America. There have been many recent examples of people being arrested and the only charge is "resisting arrest". Of course they get let out of jail 12-24 hours later, but at that point the police have removed you from what you were doing (protesting, for e.g.) and they now have your fingerprints, photo and you have a history of arrest. A quick Google gave me: http://www.naturalnews.com/040399_adam_kokesh_resisting_arrest_philadelphia_protest.html http://www.naturalnews.com/040399_adam_kokesh_resisting_arre... There are many more examples.
- tptacek 13y agoHopefully nobody is disputing that the police sometimes arrest people for bogus reasons.
- anigbrowl 13y agoBut it was. Consider the following sequence of events, though please do not construe this as approval of the police officer's actions - I don't approve of how he acted and think all charges should be dropped. 1. Police officer tell old lady to depart. 2. Old lady starts gathering her stuff. 3. Police officer loses patience, hustles old lady along. 4. Old lady whacks police officer in face. < This is the felony assault 5. Police officer places her under arrest. 6. Old lady declines to cooperate. < This is the resisting arrest part Now I share your (probable) belief that the police officer brought it on himself by bullying an old lady and that she was somewhat justified in defending herself against his assault. But when you're arrested, you're supposed to go along with it and dispute the matter in court, where a judge may throw the charges out or (...various other possibilities...). Even if the original charge is dropped or never filed, failure to cooperate is considered a separate offense. (BTW in legal terms an 'assault' is is the threat of unwanted contact. Actual unwanted contact is a 'battery' and need not be particularly dangerous - it's the unwelcome aspect of it that crosses the threshold of legality, although the degree is what determines severity of sentence. I mention this to avoid a side argument about whether the old lady presented any sort of serious danger to the LEO.)