4 ms·
This is extortion, and is subject to criminal penalties. It is lying: you say legal action is underway. You've done nothing but mail a letter. The moment someo
by bdcravens 13y ago
This is extortion, and is subject to criminal penalties.
It is lying: you say legal action is underway. You've done nothing but mail a letter. The moment someone says legal proceeding are underway, the other party needs to shut up, and refer all communications through attorneys. At that point, you'd probably find yourself needing to hire an attorney at considerable expense.
I suspect you could be sued for defamation: claiming legal action when none existed can harm reputation. If you're not a business entity with personal protection (such as LLC or corp, depending on your locale) they can destroy you financially: house, property, bankruptcy. No client is worth that to me.
Even if you were to sue, this website might work against you. It'd definitely come up in proceedings, and may cause the judge to grant some leniency even if your client was ordered to pay.
The warning site doesn't identify you, so if the client could care less (people launching (companyname)-sucks.com all the time), they'll just ignore you. Then you're out hosting and domain fees.
If the client goes the cybersquatting claim route, they can take the warning domain, and you can levied fine of up to $100,000 USD. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cybersquatting#Legal_resolution http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cybersquatting#Legal_resolution)
Glad it worked out for you, but I think you're correct in your warning that no one should ever do this.
- mnglkhn2 13y agoThe statement is correct and it can't be proven as incorrect: "Legal action is underway". The domain is a variation and I am pretty sure you can't claim it as cyber-squatted. Overall, it is a pressure tactic, with good chances when dealing with small businesses or individuals.
- jaynos 13y ago>It is lying: you say legal action is underway. As in, I'm starting to look for an attorney to explore my legal options. This one works in residential construction also ("I'm beginning the process of finding a lawyer to speak to about putting a lien on your house." I knew it wasn't legally possible in most situations, but I was definitely allowed to ask my lawyer again).
- ctdonath 13y agoI was definitely allowed to ask my lawyer again "Mr. Lawyer, can I ask you a couple of questions?" "Yes. What is your other question?"
- darkarmani 13y ago> This means that domain names bearing close resemblance to trademarked names are not per se impermissible. Rather, the domain name must have been registered with the bad faith intent to later sell it to the trademark holder. This "bad faith" concept is reiterated in 15 U.S.C. § 1125 and U.S.C. § 1129. Bringing up a domain to criticize a company is not cybersquatting.
- bobwaycott 13y agoThis is not extortion. This is not necessarily lying (provided you have inquired about your options with an attorney). This is not defamation. This is not cybersquatting. At best, this is stupidly prone to unpredictable backfiring that makes you look ... stupid. At worst, you look like a dick and the word spreads.