7 ms·
So now they've upped the ante for Snowden-transport; probably the only feasible solution would be a warship. Maybe the other option would be a chartered jet wi
by rdl 13y ago
So now they've upped the ante for Snowden-transport; probably the only feasible solution would be a warship. Maybe the other option would be a chartered jet with in-air refueling, flying solely over international waters (or sovereign countries, like Russia and maybe China).
You can charter a military transport (capable of refueling) from a bunch of companies, like RUS Aviation. Actual refueling services are harder, probably would need to be a military, although there are a few operators of contract aerial refueling service (e.g. Omega) -- unfortunately they have big military contracts, usually with the US, and thus wouldn't be willing to participate. You could probably take a military transport, fill it with ferry tanks, and make a decent go at it, but the problem is most of the cheap-to-charter aircraft are old inefficient aircraft like the IL-76. I guess with new engines it wouldn't be horrible, but something like a 737 in ferry mode would be better. A 777-200ER or 777-200LR would probably be the best. A 747SP is the only thing I actually know how to charter which has crazy long range (7600nm), which is almost as much as the 777-200LR (which is new, and thus highly utilized). A 7600nm range aircraft is just enough to stay in Russian airspace and then come in through the Greenland-Iceland-UK gap, down the Atlantic, to Caracas. The total cost of that mission would be far less than the $23mm Ecuador was willing to give up, but well in excess of $1mm.
A warship would probably be a lot easier, although you'd probably want to go to the Russian Far East to avoid bottlenecks -- assuming a fifth rate power like Ecuador, there could easily be "this area closed due to a military exercise" or other tricks to block it otherwise.
- WildUtah 13y agoSoon US allies will be detaining ships from the Bolivian Navy just to check if Snowden is aboard.
- rdl 13y ago(Aside from the issues of Bolivia being landlocked since the War of the Pacific in 1879...) Per the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS) Article 95 of UNCLOS: Warships on the high seas have complete immunity from the jurisdiction of any State other than the flag State. Article 96 of UNCLOS: Ships owned or operated by a State and used only on government non-commercial service shall, on the high seas, have complete immunity from the jurisdiction of any State other than the flag State. 1) An interesting case came up: Argentina's frigate (well, a historical tall ship, but it was technically the flagship, like the USS Constitution) the ARA Libertad was seized in Ghana related to the $100b sovereign debt default of 2001, and a NY federal district court judgment for one of the bondholders against Argentina. 2) The whole point of a warship is that you can't detain it; if it fails to be able to prevent detention, it's not really very good as a warship, is it? 3) Ragnar Danneskjøld
- mcovey 13y agoDo you think America cares what some little treaty says? We effectively own the UN and can freely flout any agreements we've made through it. I doubt anyone would be even slightly surprised if America - either is military, a government agency, or by some other means - decided to raid foreign vessels looking for a suspect. All in a day's work when you're the world's self appointed arbiter of justice.
- rdl 13y agoThe US generally hasn't violated the physical sovereignty of embassies or of warships on the high seas. Those are from the Congress of Vienna or even before, not de novo from the UN.
- EthanHeilman 13y agoOr just get safe travel through Russia to China and take a large passenger aircraft from China to South America since they can make they flight direct.
- rdl 13y agoActually that is a longer distance, due to great cirle! http://www.aircalculator.com/flightplan.php?from=HKG&to=CCS http://www.aircalculator.com/flightplan.php?from=HKG&to=CCS 16354 km http://www.aircalculator.com/flightplan.php?from=PVG&to=CCS http://www.aircalculator.com/flightplan.php?from=PVG&to=CCS 15279 km http://www.aircalculator.com/flightplan.php?from=SVO&to=CCS http://www.aircalculator.com/flightplan.php?from=SVO&to=CCS 9908 km http://www.aircalculator.com/flightplan.php?from=VVO&to=CCS http://www.aircalculator.com/flightplan.php?from=VVO&to=CCS 13705 km http://www.aircalculator.com/flightplan.php?from=LED&to=CCS http://www.aircalculator.com/flightplan.php?from=LED&to=CCS 9391 km I estimate the deviation on SVO-CCS to avoid UK would be about 2000 km, tops. "Direct", in an airline sense, is not meaningful -- that just means it doesn't change plane enroute. Direct flights can still make technical (refueling) stops, or take on passengers (e.g. Caracas to Damascus to Tehran was in fact direct Caracas to Tehran service.) "Non-stop" means it doesn't land. "Does not overfly a US ally" is complicated, ex-China too, due to the first and second island chain problem (if Portugal will deny overflight, I'm sure Japan would too...) Direct flights from Asia to South America have historically had a stop in the US, so every passenger needed a US transit visa ($130 and hard, if not from a visa waiver country). So, they've largely been discontinued. Tokyo to Tijuana sort of happens, but still overflies US territory, so they need to report passengers to the US under APIS. And Mexico is both in North America and closely tied to the US, so it's a non-starter for Snowden. The only direct flights which don't touch the US are Shanghai-Madrid-Sao Paolo, and on Emirates, Shanghai - Dubai - Sao Paolo. The former is obviously out, and the latter I think transits enough US allies (plus, UAE itself) to not work.
- rdl 13y agoThere are flights via Australia and New Zealand as well, particularly to Chile, but those also don't help except for people with US visa issues.