5 ms·
Why Antidepressants Don't Live Up to the Hype
- tokenadult 18y agoThis is an important article following up on the many studies of serotonin-specific reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs) from the 1990s. It turns out, as usual, that the drug companies were quick to publish studies favorable to their products, and slower to publish studies unfavorable to their products. See the excellent article by Peter Norvig, director of research at Google, on how to interpret scientific research, http://norvig.com/experiment-design.html http://norvig.com/experiment-design.html for more on this problem of publication bias. There is a good body of research now suggesting that most patients with depressed mood and related symptoms can be helped by cognitive therapy. http://www.aafp.org/afp/20060101/83.html http://www.aafp.org/afp/20060101/83.html http://www.apa.org/divisions/div12/rev_est/cog_depr.html http://www.apa.org/divisions/div12/rev_est/cog_depr.html For many persons suffering from depression to the degree that it interferes with work or with family relationships, the best approach will be to combine medical treatment, possibly with the new first-line drugs (SSRIs) or possibly with other drugs, and cognitive therapy to learn new patterns of thinking.
- asciilifeform 18y agoActually, it is because research on antidepressants which unambiguously make you feel better - namely, dopamine reuptake inhibitors - was outlawed. What we're left with are the ones that only work in a mild, sometimes-sort of way. And don't buy the notion that the purpose of an antidepressant is to "correct chemical imbalances." No such imbalances have ever been identified: http://www.etfrc.com/ChemicalImbalances.htm http://www.etfrc.com/ChemicalImbalances.htm "How are the chemical imbalances which are the supposed basis for the prescription of "antidepressants" diagnosed? Is exploratory neurosurgery performed, using some technique that allows the surgeon to quantify synaptic transmitter levels? No, the very idea is absurd. Is a spinal tap, then, done to at least measure, on a gross scale, the distribution of neurotransmitter metabolites? Of course not – how many people have undergone spinal taps before receiving a prescription for Effexor®? Is blood at least drawn, to test something? No. This diagnosis – the diagnosis of the most subtle of chemical disorders in the most complex organ in the body – is made on the basis of the patient's report of feeling sad and lethargic. Try to imagine a hematologist diagnosing leukemia this way to get a sense of just how ridiculous this idea is." "The principal reason for rejecting biopsychiatry (aside from the fact that intellectual honesty demands its rejection) is that it locates the cause of psychic suffering in people's "bad brains," and excludes the conditions of modern life, or anything else, from consideration as the cause of such pain." The purpose of an antidepressant is to improve mood. No more, no less. And the degree of doublespeak doctors find necessary to dance around our society's puritanical views on pleasure just to be permitted to market the current, wimpy antidepressants - is staggering.
- tokenadult 18y agoAFTER EDIT: research on antidepressants which unambiguously make you feel better - namely, dopamine reuptake inhibitors - was outlawed Do you have a citation for a law or policy statement that shows that there is indeed such an outlawing? I see Google Scholar citations that suggest that research is ongoing, and there is more planned. http://www.ajp.psychiatryonline.org/cgi/content/abstract/163/9/1594 http://www.ajp.psychiatryonline.org/cgi/content/abstract/163... /AFTER EDIT There are more than 100 countries in the world, and they would have to be united in banning a certain direction of research for there to be no research on that subject. But dopamine reuptake inhibitors, based on ongoing research in various places, are a risky approach to treating major mood disorders. "DRIs are notorious for their high abuse potential and ability to cause addiction and dependence. Pure DRIs such as cocaine and combination releasers such as amphetamine and methamphetamine are widely abused throughout the world." http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dopamine_reuptake_inhibitor http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dopamine_reuptake_inhibitor "NDRIs approved to treat depression "Here is the only NDRI that has been approved by the Food and Drug Administration specifically to treat depression, with its generic, or chemical, name followed by available brand names in parentheses: * Bupropion (Wellbutrin, Wellbutrin SR, Wellbutrin XL)" . . . . "Safety concerns with NDRIs "Bupropion can increase blood pressure in some people, so regular monitoring is important. The risk of developing high blood pressure may increase if you also use nicotine replacement therapy, such as a nicotine patch, to help you stop smoking. "There's a small chance that taking bupropion can cause a seizure if you've had previous seizures, a head injury or a nervous system tumor, or if you've had an eating disorder, such as bulimia or anorexia. Because of that, don't take this medication if you have a history of seizures or eating disorders or if you're abruptly discontinuing use of alcohol or sedatives. Be sure to tell your doctor about your past medical issues. "Also, because of potentially dangerous medication interactions, be sure your doctor knows about any current or previous use of monoamine oxidase inhibitors (MAOIs). Tell your doctor also if you have severe liver cirrhosis, because Wellbutrin can cause liver problems. In addition, don't take Zyban while you're being treated with any form of Wellbutrin." http://www.mayoclinic.com/health/antidepressants/MH00068 http://www.mayoclinic.com/health/antidepressants/MH00068
- asciilifeform 18y ago
- tlb 18y agoSummary: company funded studies claim drugs help X% of the population. More rigorous federal studies show they might only help 2/3 * X%. The main difference in the groups was including drug abusers in the federal group. So what? A drug either helps you or it doesn't. If it helps you, you don't care what fraction of other people it helps. The value of X mainly determines how many drugs you'll need to try. If they work for 50%, you'll have to try 2 drugs on average before finding one that works. So you want to start with drugs with large values of X, but whether it's 60% or 40% isn't a huge deal. Furthermore, clever doctors can often guess right and prescribe different drugs for different people. Studies that insist on giving the same drug to everyone with depression are stupid, because they're administered much more intelligently in the real world.
- apmee 18y agoWhat's interesting is that antidepressants such as Prozac have a few established, proven and well-documented side-effects, one of which is orgasm inhibition: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ssri#Sexual_side_effects http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ssri#Sexual_side_effects So I'd imagine that the men who are prescribed antidepressants for things like premature ejaculation find that they very much do live up to (a different kind of) hype.
- anigbrowl 18y agoFrom personal experience, I can say that the compulsion (to have sex) remains but the pleasure doesn't, resulting in a lot of frustration. I prefer the mood swings. I'm pretty skeptical of this as a therapeutic option for p.e..
- pchivers 18y agoI think this blog post (linked from the original article) is more interesting than the article itself: Antidepressants, Placebos and the Failure of Psychiatry http://neuroskeptic.blogspot.com/2009/03/antidepressants-placebos-and-failure-of.html http://neuroskeptic.blogspot.com/2009/03/antidepressants-pla...
- Zak 18y agoI've taken an interest in body chemistry and especially neurotransmitters over the past year or so. One thing that I've noticed is that every drug I've come across that acts as a neurotransmitter reuptake inhibitor has bizarre and highly undesirable side effects not directly related (as far as anybody knows) to increasing the levels of the neurotransmitter in question. I think very few people should take drugs in this class, and they should be used as a last resort, not the primary treatment for any condition. If it is desirable to raise the level of a given neurotransmitter, I think supplementation with precursors is a more favorable approach. For treating depression, it is likely that raising serotonin and dopamine levels simultaneously will have the desired effect. The appropriate precursors are 5-HTP and levodopa. To aid in production, it may be helpful to take vitamin B-6. To help cause production in the brain instead of the rest of the body, it is advisable to take an aromatic L-amino acid decarboxylase inhibitor that does not cross the blood-brain barrier. EGCG (green tea extract) is effective for this purpose, and may restore proper brain chemistry on its own. This is not medical advice, and while all the chemicals I've mentioned are available as dietary supplements, they have significant biological effects, including the possibility of harmful side effects. Do your research, and don't rely on advice from the health food store by itself. Wikipedia is a good starting point (though, obviously, it shouldn't be the only source you consult).
- asciilifeform 18y agoA good outline of the process: http://yarchive.net/med/5-htp.html http://yarchive.net/med/5-htp.html
- Zak 18y agoThis is the first time I've seen the claim that B6 will significantly increase serotonin production outside the brain when taken in combination with 5-HTP and an AAAD inhibitor. It certainly does without the AAAD inhibitor, and it seems possible that it would even with. This backs up my previous point though - do your research if you're considering self-medication.
- gaoshan 18y agoWhatever the effect, the withdrawal symptoms associated with addiction to big brands like Effexor make beginning to take them something one should seriously consider. I was on Effexor for 2 years and, while it did have a slight positive net effect on me, in the end weaning myself off of it was difficult and very uncomfortable. The addiction is so strong that even a doctor supervised, long term (2 months) withdrawal regimen was a bad experience.