3 ms·
Something about the article doesn't sit right with me. It doesn't match with the way I feel my own thought processes working. My brain is not constantly conside
by wyager 13y ago
Something about the article doesn't sit right with me. It doesn't match with the way I feel my own thought processes working. My brain is not constantly considering all possible binary options. (Is my phone ringing in my left pocket? My right pocket? In each of the bajillion possible positions it might sit within that pocket?) My brain is just receiving sensory data, not constantly making such high-level judgements on it. If it passes a certain threshold, it goes to some higher thought process and I consciously take note of it. When I feel a phantom phone vibration, it's as if I'm actually experiencing the sensation, not as if some low-level part of my brain reached out into my frontal lobe and started sounding the "phone is vibrating" alarm.
- shmageggy 13y agoYour account isn't inconsistent with the article at all. The effects they are describing are all taking place below the level of conscious awareness. They are giving a high description of how psychologists understand an information processing system. "Experiencing a sensation", as you say, is actually quite a lot like the activation mechanism you contrast it to. edit: a word.
- joeyo 13y agoThere is a considerable body of evidence that "top-down" processes affect not only how sensory evidence is processed, but how the sensations themselves are experienced. In other words, high-level (but subconscious) neural "judgments" about the statistics of the world, actually influence how you perceive it. To put it still another way: sensations aren't simply passively experienced; they are actively constructed by the brain. Phantom phone vibration is, in many ways, just as "constructed" as real phone vibration. Perceptual illusions provide one of the clearest ways to show that sensations reflect factors other than external stimuli. Here are two illusions, in different sensory modalities, that demonstrate the strong top-down influence of the brain on perception: The rubber hand illusion [1,2] and the McGurk effect [3,4]. The rubber hand illusion is particularly relevant because it is quite similar to the phantom phone vibration effect. 1. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rubber_hand_illusion http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rubber_hand_illusion 2. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TCQbygjG0RU http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TCQbygjG0RU 3. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/McGurk_effect http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/McGurk_effect 4. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G-lN8vWm3m0 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G-lN8vWm3m0 EDIT: Here's an additional example to consider. People generally can't tickle themselves. The sensations are less strong when one touches oneself than when someone else does so. The explanation for this is that the brain automatically discounts sensations which arise as a result of self-motion. This has obvious advantages, namely that you don't constantly overstimulate yourself just in the process of moving through the world and are as such better able to attend to important externally generated stimuli.
- InclinedPlane 13y agoBut that's not how your body works, is it? Do you have to think consciously to yourself about moving your legs when you are walking? Even when you are running or dodging around complicated obstacles? Do you have to think about breathing? When you read are you thinking about the form of each letter and mentally going "ok, that's a T, oh, and that's an H, and hey here's an E, and then a space, that must be the word 'THE', ok, moving on..."? No, parts of your brain seamlessly and automatically do all that work for you, even though sometimes it can be complex work requiring your higher cognitive abilities. For example, if you are reading a hand written note and there is a word that is hard to read your brain fills in a huge amount of context and filters out and in potential possibilities and you can even consciously make a choice on which word is the most likely, but it can all happen quickly and smoothly with the workings that happen automatically doing so without you even being aware of them or how they operate. That's how your brain works. It's not a matter of a simple machine with a little homunculus pulling at levers, it's a conscious part married to a whole lot of little unconscious parts. In order to learn something (like typing or reading or walking or rock climbing or driving or baseball) you need to use repetition to train up the unconscious parts. Incidentally, it's also why techniques such as meditation are so powerful, because they allow you a degree of meta-control over your mind. Because not only are actions like walking or typing mostly unconscious so are things like mood and state of mind. But you can train yourself to control those aspects just as you can train yourself to walk a different way.
- coldtea 13y ago>Something about the article doesn't sit right with me. It doesn't match with the way I feel my own thought processes working. My brain is not constantly considering all possible binary options. A lot of neuro/cognitive science results are not "intuitive". You cannot tell how your brain works only by what it's consciously doing. The conscious part is just the tip of the iceberg of the processing the brain does and when. >When I feel a phantom phone vibration, it's as if I'm actually experiencing the sensation, not as if some low-level part of my brain reached out into my frontal lobe and started sounding the "phone is vibrating" alarm. And yet you're not "actually experiencing the sensation" -- in the sense that the real world state does not correspond to it. So it very much is like your brain started sounding the "phone is vibrating" alarm. The brain can create whole experiences and illusions from nothing at all. Not only in dreams (obvious example), but also in experiments with sensory deprivation.