5 ms·
>If Reader was ultimately unmonetizable, I'll cry when its gone, but I don't think anyone should feel entitled to a free service. I don't think that it was not
by epistasis 13y ago
>If Reader was ultimately unmonetizable, I'll cry when its gone, but I don't think anyone should feel entitled to a free service.
I don't think that it was not monetizable, any less than GMail is. Perhaps there were high, hidden costs in maintaining such a large feed database that would mean that a comparable revenue stream from Reader would not pay for itself nearly as much as GMail does.
I think that in the end it's just that Google did not care about the Reader users. They didn't need them, there wasn't enough of a stink when they said they were going to get rid of Reader, either internally or externally.
- bryanbuckley 13y ago>I think that in the end it's just that Google did not care about the Reader users. What % of Google employees do you think are also Reader users? edit: I assume it is something like 90%. Which is why I'm pretty impressed that this change went through.
- tempestn 13y agoI highly doubt it's even close to 90%. If it were, I think you're right that it's much less likely it would have been shut down. There are many very technical people out there that just don't find RSS fits with their workflow. Personally, I have a list of blogs I like to read in a couple bookmarks folders, and when I feel like reading them, I'll go to the bookmarks and see what's up. I don't really care if I miss posts, so I have no real need for a system that will catalog them all for me. I have tried a couple times to get into it, but just found it wasn't for me. (As a means of consuming media. I do use RSS for automating various processes, as well as the occasional RSS-to-email when I really need notifications for something (like rare classifieds posts I'm searching for).) Anyway, my point is, I'm pretty technical - I run a web based company and embrace plenty of modern technologies - and I never got into RSS. I'm fairly certain the majority of Google employees don't make regular use of an RSS reader either. (Although I imagine a significant minority do as well.)
- medde 13y agoor maybe they don't want their employer knowing everything they read?
- fyrabanks 13y agoYou think low-level employees can stop a change like that? I talked to a Googler who used Reader; he's very upset about it, obviously, but said they internally communicated the reasons they were shutting down the service and they made sense.
- epsylon 13y agoGoogle shut down Reader because they think that we should be using Google+ instead.
- Pxtl 13y agoCurrents, more likely. Either way, they should've had a synced web version of currents before killing reader.
- cma 13y ago"Perhaps there were high, hidden costs in maintaining such a large feed database that would mean that a comparable revenue stream from Reader would not pay for itself nearly as much as GMail does." For search, they already scrape the entire web, including RSS feeds.
- VLM 13y agoThe large database cost is noticing that people who follow JGCs feed also tend to follow the feeds from the Chris's, furthermore they're apparently real human beings and have been reading for awhile, therefore when optimizing search engine results I'd put something linked to by JGC much higher than something linked by rgfbebgep240895i who is probably a SEO spammer rather than a human. If you'd prefer a physics example, admittedly popularity is not truth, but you Might be able to add valuable data to search engine results by a careful examination of exactly who subscribes to Shetl-Optimized vs Backreaction vs Not Even Wrong vs all of them, and how long people subscribe, and other blogs they read... Its the relationship between my set of feeds and your set of feeds that "should be" useful, not just the feeds themselves. Something no one has discussed yet is the whole topic might just be a big F you to the NSA. I'm sure they'd love a subscriber list of "from the bunker" or "zerohedge" and GOOG has to either give it or give up on the product so they have nothing to give. Can't give up on search results, too much money, but reader might have been expendable.