3 ms·
I would still disagree... I think the CS way of thinking, if you're computer-savvy, will be there with or without a CS degree. Better get something else. If yo
by swombat 18y ago
I would still disagree... I think the CS way of thinking, if you're computer-savvy, will be there with or without a CS degree. Better get something else.
If you want a more robust, equally versatile scientific field, I'd suggest Physics or Maths.
- scott_s 18y agoI'm not sure if I agree or disagree with his point, but I find the concept that the CS way of thinking will be there with or without a CS education naive. (Note I said education, not degree.) Once we've learned fundamental concepts, it's difficult to imagine when we didn't know them, and it's easy to assume learning it was inevitable.
- swombat 18y agoWell, I never got a formal CS education, but I read a lot of books on the topic. Certainly my "CS education" is far from complete in the way that it would be if I'd done a degree (I know little about, say, how to write a compiler). But the bits that I don't know are the bits that I haven't needed to use, and everything that I've needed to learn, I've been able to learn. The only thing a CS degree might give you that self-study would not is a good overview of the field. But then, if you're passionate about programming and you've been into it since you were 10, chances are you have a pretty good overview of the field already. So in that case (passionate about computers since an early age, hesitating about degree) I would strongly recommend something other than CS.
- scott_s 18y agoAnd that's why I said education, not degree. Every person graduating with a Bachelor's in CS has holes in their CS education; different departments stress different parts of CS, and even inside a department, two people can often get very different educations. Although the attitude "the bits that I don't know are the bits that I haven't needed to use" is dangerous, since you never really know if you need something until you understand it. Anyway, your point seems to be if you're going to learn CS concepts anyway, then don't choose CS as a major. You're taking "going to learn CS concepts" as a given. The author did not.
- nostrademons 18y agoI was a physics major for 6 semesters, and up until my last semester had more courses in both physics and math than in CS. I think they're both definitely worth learning, but I would not call them a "more robust, equally versatile scientific field". A bachelor's in physics is fairly specific to giving you the foundations you need to do well in grad school. You can do a lot with it because workplaces use it as a signalling device for "I can think quantitatively", and so are more likely to hire a physics major than a random liberal arts major. But other than a general respect for data (which you'll get in any scientific degree), I haven't used any skill I learned in my physics courses. I've heard many non-programmers wish that they took at least an intro CS course, though.