3 ms·
Right, but for those issues where the parties do form a spectrum, playing the spoiler is a smaller but more credible threat from a third party, since voting for
by dllthomas 13y ago
Right, but for those issues where the parties do form a spectrum, playing the spoiler is a smaller but more credible threat from a third party, since voting for the other guy would be worse.
On issues like this one, where party positions seem to depend only on whether it's their guy doing it, I'm not sure what the appropriate strategy is.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> On issues like this one, where party positions seem to depend only on whether it's their guy doing it, I'm not sure what the appropriate strategy is. It requires looking beyond voting. The only reason issues like you describe exist is because there isn't a sufficiently strong committed electoral constituency around the issue that will vote, run primary challengers, and provide money and boots on the ground for campaign operations around the issue, so that it just becomes a tactical issue of convenience to the major parties. Voting behavior, alone, isn't going to do anything to change that. Voting is important in a democracy, but it isn't the only -- or even the most important -- form of political participation.
- dllthomas 13y agoThis is correct; I've started putting together a group to look at coordinating such activities (and anything else we can think of): meetup.com/Hack-Government-Bay-Area It still leaves the direct question - while less important - unanswered: when we do go to vote, what is the optimal approach on this kind of issue?
- dragonwriter 13y ago> It still leaves the direct question - while less important - unanswered: when we do go to vote, what is the optimal approach on this kind of issue? Voting is a blunt instrument that's very rarely useful -- especially in one election -- at affecting change on any specific issue of this type (that is, one on which the major parties have no real distinction, though they exploit any opportunity to take PR pot-shots at the other party.) If you haven't changed the landscape by political action before the election so that the issue you are concerned about is no longer that kind of issue, then there isn't an effective voting strategy available.