5 ms·
She was lucky she wasn't male and black. Because if she were, they'd probably shoot him, and then say "they thought he was drawing a weapon...as he fled". Not
by mtgx 13y ago
She was lucky she wasn't male and black. Because if she were, they'd probably shoot him, and then say "they thought he was drawing a weapon...as he fled".
Not like it hasn't happen exactly like that before. There was even a video of it online. I think if more tourists knew stuff like this is happening in America, they'd stay the hell away from it.
- cones688 13y agoSometimes I think the lack of Armed Police in the UK is a benefit as they take arming an officer with a lethal weapon is a serious matter and requires specific training/psychoanalysis. What possible requirement could the " Alcohol Beverage Control Division" need to be armed?! Does every Government Official get a weapon/carry/threaten permit when they join?!
- anu_gupta 13y ago> Sometimes Not sure I've ever thought that arming British police on a routine basis would be a good thing.
- cones688 13y agoVery True - I really think untrained humans cannot handle the stress and high pressure of logically assessing a potentially lethal situation.
- rtb 13y agoMassive +1 to this. It seems to me that the UK police, since they are not armed, generally try to defuse situations. (Of course, they can call for armed backup if it is necessary.) Time and again, I read of US police unnecessarily escalating situations. If your immediate response to any tension is to pull out a gun and start shouting, then things are very likely to get a lot worse in many cases. Perhaps this is just confirmation bias though. I only get to read about the US cases where things have gone wrong.
- pestaa 13y ago> pull out a gun and start shouting I know this is a typo, but that picture in my head made me smile. Confirmation bias is only dangerous when there is significantly more evidence against the statement. You rarely hear, "we could have saved the day if we had higher damage output!"
- joe5150 13y agoI don't think it was a typo. Shouting usually comes before shooting.
- rtb 13y agoI did mean shouting; it wasn't a typo. I see that the way I phrased it was ambiguous though. :-) I meant that the police generally pull out their gun to emphasise their power and to reinforce their shouts, not always with the intention of actually shooting.
- rangibaby 13y ago> Perhaps this is just confirmation bias though. I only get to read about the US cases where things have gone wrong. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_of_Jean_Charles_de_Menezes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_of_Jean_Charles_de_Menez...
- willvarfar 13y agoWhilst that is a harrowing case, it is hardly the same as the routine pulling of guns first and asking questions later attitude that you were replying to?
- rangibaby 13y agoThanks for bringing this up! I considered the same point before posting the link, but decided that it was appropriate considering (imo) that it is a product of the same 21st century paranoia and police culture of "shoot first, ask questions later".
- tommypalm 13y agoIn Northern Ireland, all Police Officers are armed. I may be wrong in this but in recent years it hasn't led to many shots being fired mistakingly and I don't think there has been any deaths. Even still, why would a unit that polices underage drinking need firearms?
- vidarh 13y agoAs much as I agree, the US at some point passed a tipping point: Police and the population were armed, so criminals needed to be armed, so police needs to be armed etc. Rolling that back would be incredibly hard. In UK and other countries where police are generally not armed, using a dangerous weapon often also adds substantial amounts of time to potential sentences, and there's either low levels of private ownership of guns (UK) or tight controls on storage and use (e.g. Norway has tons of firearms, but the law requires it to be separate into at least two non-functional parts that must be kept locked down separately, so your hunting rifle is not something you'll go fetch on a whim when you hear a weird sound), and so criminals know that not only are they unlikely to face an armed response if they don't arm themselves, but they're also likely to get off lighter if caught without weapons, and so there's very little incentive for criminals to arm themselves in most situations. It's one of those things where de-escalation is nearly impossible because of the likely public response to news of dead cops, and how widely guns permeate the culture.
- cones688 13y agoI appreciate that, its about the polices training and response to "threats" as someone mentioned below pulling a firearm on a "suspect" just leads to aggravating the situation (innocent will panic and probably do something stupid, guilty will probably pull their own weapon to escape) neither ends well for anyone. America can't undo its weapons problem even if it introduced gun control but discouraging pulling weapons out in public without serious consequences (even for the police) might stem this trend of pulling weapons at every situation.
- scotty79 13y agoAustralia rolled that back and they are doing fine.
- Uchikoma 13y agoI don't think this necessarily has to do with weapons. There are ten thousands of armed German police officers who (number went through the press) shot 85 bullets in 2011 and usually do not draw a weapon immediately.
- Retric 13y agoThe us has approximately 80 times that many armed police officers. So, if they shot ~7,000 bullets a year they would arguably be showing similar levels of restraint. Unfortunately, it takes less training to become a police officer than a kindergarten teacher in the US so we don't see the same level of restraint. IMO we would be better served by a smaller but better trained force unfortunately the federal, state, and local governments all do law enforcement and at the local level there often seen as a way to generate revenue making them 'free'.
- Uchikoma 13y agoSorry for my typo, I've meant to write tens of thousands of police officers. Would have been funny if Germany has only ten thousands with a population of 80M people. In 2010 there were 243k police officers in Germany. Could not find 2012 numbers.
- flagnog 13y agoand to top it all off, you're disqualified from joining the force if you score TOO HIGH on the test - it happened to a good friend of mine. smh.
- Nursie 13y agoThat's a very small proportion of the overall police force that carry. It's got to be to do with the attitude around weapons. There are about 7000 armed police in England and Wales. Their weapons are kept in safes in the back of their cars, they need to have a very good reason to be carrying one, let alone actually using one. I think in the UK, despite the police closing ranks when threatened (I don't think we have this as bad as the US either) an officer that drew a weapon on a suspect that they had no reason to think was armed (and was only suspected of underage possession of alcohol) that officer would be subject to some sort of disciplinary action.
- walshemj 13y agoYes there was a case in the UK local to me where one of the armed response team put a magazine on the roof of the car and accidentally drove off - I think some one found the mag the next day He was suspended from the team immediately - the UK police do take fire arms training very seriously.
- sfall 13y agotypically they are cops on duty and conducting a normal assignment, like a DUI check point
- flexie 13y agoSurely you can't let a 20 year-old get away with what might be a beer. Law enforcement showed great mercy in dropping charges against this girl. In fact she should consider herself lucky they spared her life. But I fear other disobedient subjects may think they too can get away with no consequences for their reckless actions.
- perlpimp 13y agoReckless were the officers, that did not have properly recognizable badges. They should've called in Police to stop the car. As a team they showed tremendous lapse in judgment and should be fired for endangering a group of teens. For all it was - tour de force by people who had nothing better to do. There are safe way to do things and there are stupid ways that might make them feel empowered.
- qubitsam 13y agoflexie was being sarcastic.
- theklub 13y agoYeah, pulling a gun on an underage buyer of alcohol seems like it shouldn't even be an option. You're essentially pulling a gun on a child. Not to mention the huge waste of money to have that many agents staked out to catch some petty criminal.
- willvarfar 13y ago20yo == child?
- simonh 13y agoAccording to your legal system, apparently so. If the law says that 20 year olds are not mature enough to buy alcohol, then by definition at least at some level they are legally considered to be immature and not able to make rational decisions for themselves.
- Tichy 13y agoI have to admit that stories like that definitely factor into my travel decisions. From the outside, the US looks like a very scary place. Perhaps it is all just overblown media stuff? But for the time being there are also other nice places to visit...
- ry0ohki 13y agoWith over 300 million people, extreme things can happen to .0001% of the people any day, and that's still 300 people affected. 300 stories to choose from a day makes for lots of sensational news.
- pezh0re 13y agoOn average, it's not that bad. Yes, there are assholes everywhere (police and otherwise), but for the most part the stuff you read about is few and far between. That being said, knowing the proper way to deal with people in authority positions is incredibly important. In this case, she should have asked for ID (yelling at them through the window if necessary). If they kept insisting that she roll the window down - and for some reason her car is unlike every other car out there, requiring the engine to be on, she should have tried to explain that through the window. (Seriously, what cars require the engine to be running for the windows to roll down?)
- joe5150 13y agoI can't recall ever being in a car with power windows that would work with the car completely turned off (key out of the ignition). You can turn the key backward or partially forward in most cars just to engage the battery and operate the windows, but she may not have known about that.
- pezh0re 13y agoYep, the accessory setting (key turned on click forward) should do the trick - providing power for windows/radio etc. Upon further consideration, I wonder if she had a push-button starter. Having never driven a key-less car before, how the heck does the accessory setting work (if at all)?
- MichaelApproved 13y agoshoot him, and then say "they thought he was drawing a weapon...as he fled". Its worse than that. They wouldn't need to have worried about a gun to open fire. A vehicle is a deadly weapon. I think that if the agents thought the car was going to hit them, they'd be justified in shooting.
- joe5150 13y agoA teenager in (again) Virginia was shot and killed by an off-duty cop working as a security guard who thought he (the teen) would hit him with a car after the kid stole pancakes. http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/02/25/AR2006022501431.html http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/02...
- malandrew 13y agoI'm honestly surprised that we don't have the Russian dashcam phenomenon in the US. If I were a black male, I would most certainly have a GoPro or something similar in my car running at all times. As a bicyclist, I'm just about ready to purchase a GoPro for when drivers are reckless and endanger me. I cannot wait for the day when you can purchase a small recording device like a GoPro and have it stream continuously over wifi or cell phone signals. When that happens, citizens will be able to record the aggressions of police officers (especially during riots) without any fear that the device and it's contents will mysteriously "go missing".