2 ms·
Yes, this whole line of argument that Snowden has put forward is beside the point. Whether you call it "exile" or not, it is perfectly reasonable for the US to
by eli 13y ago
Yes, this whole line of argument that Snowden has put forward is beside the point. Whether you call it "exile" or not, it is perfectly reasonable for the US to revoke his passport. It is certainly not "extralegal." It's not even unusual. It is what happens when you're charged with a felony by a US court.
- sneak 13y agoRevoking his passport is not extralegal. Nobody's arguing that. Exerting unknown influence behind closed doors with those who have the ability to grant or deny his requests for asylum is an entirely different matter, though.
- eli 13y agoI really hate arguments based on parsing words, but the Wikileaks statement says: "This kind of deception from a world leader is not justice, and neither is the extralegal penalty of exile" Doesn't "exile" refer to his being without a passport? So isn't he clearly saying that it's extralegal?