4 ms·
It occurs to me that there is a kind of deep hypocrisy for those who make the rules to claim that someone broke the rules. Rules require focus and diligence to
by javajosh 13y ago
It occurs to me that there is a kind of deep hypocrisy for those who make the rules to claim that someone broke the rules. Rules require focus and diligence to apply, and they favor those that apply them regularly, vs those to whom they are applied.
I suspect that the Obama administration broke may of their own rules rushing through the a change in status that fast - a bureaucracy the size of the US doesn't process anything quickly without breaking the rules.
The Russians are clearly using Snowden as a pawn, probably because Russia is threatened by people like Snowden just as much as the US is. Snowden threatens those who make the rules, and then apply them fully to others and not at all to themselves and their cohorts.
For the third time in my life (the first two courtesy Bush Jr.) I'm deeply ashamed of my government.
- michaelhoffman 13y agoWhich rules do you suspect the Obama administration broke? In general the reason things take a long time to do in a bureaucracy is because of the required approvals from many different officials. If the President or a cabinet secretary wants something to happen now, this is less likely to be necessary.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- lukifer 13y ago"The tree that doesn't bend, breaks." "Bend too far, and you're already broken." It's more an issue of redefining the rules than breaking them. Court oversight becomes a secret rubber stamp that's never denied. Search becomes querying the database we already have. Non-citizenship becomes 51% confidence. Spying on enemy nations during wartime becomes Hey, Everybody's Doing It, Why Can't We? ...etc
- michaelhoffman 13y agoThat's interesting but it doesn't answer the question of which rules the Obama administration broke by revoking Snowden's passport.
- bobwaycott 13y agoNot sure which, if any, were broken, but here's a quick rundown of existing rules I've found thus far: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5976018 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5976018 I'm rather out of my depth where passport laws are concerned, though.
- javajosh 13y agoI honestly don't know which ones, as I am not a lawyer or familiar with the processes that surround passport control. But I think it is very likely, verging on certainty, that some rules were broken.
- michaelhoffman 13y agoSince you disclaim any knowledge of the subject, how is it that you feel qualified to make a pronouncement that something is almost certain?
- dasil003 13y ago> The Russians are clearly using Snowden as a pawn, probably because Russia is threatened by people like Snowden just as much as the US is. Or simply because what else can a government use an individual for?
- orblivion 13y ago> It occurs to me that there is a kind of deep hypocrisy for those who make the rules to claim that someone broke the rules. Which is why I think it's silly that Snowden has (as so many before have and surely after him will) bothered to note that the US isn't allowing him to seek asylum. If you're in the position to seek asylum, and you think you deserve it, you're already claiming that the US is unfairly targeting you. Why would an organization that is unfairly targeting you be fair about asylum?
- nullc 13y agoBecause the US is not a monolith.
- mpyne 13y ago> I suspect that the Obama administration broke may of their own rules rushing through the a change in status that fast It's amazing what you can push through when a Secretary of State who can unilaterally revoke your passport once a valid warrant for arrest on Federal charges is issued, reports directly to you. The only slow part of that would be getting the charges issued in the first place; Snowden simply took too long in Hong Kong.