4 ms·
>People "believe in" government not because they love it or think it is perfect, they do it because they believe the alternative is something like the Hobbsian
by samstave 13y ago
>People "believe in" government not because they love it or think it is perfect, they do it because they believe the alternative is something like the Hobbsian state of nature.
Utter BS.
People "believe" in governments largely because they are indoctrinated into the belief system prepared for them based on what country they are born into. Then, based on the actions of that government, their upbringing and life experience their worldview may-or-may-not be shifted.
There are plenty of brilliant free thinking people in the world, they just unfortunately live in a world mostly populated by those who do not have the chance to have a similar perspective, due to an infinite (yet very channeled) set of life-circumstance.
The human mind is the most amazing creation we know of. Yet, the "powers that be" want you to believe that you're worthless, un-guided and incapable. Yet - just looking at the amazing world around you - created wholly by the efforts of the minds of Man - would serve to prove that you and your mind is, actually, sublime.
There has been a centuries long war on the mind...
- rayiner 13y ago> There are plenty of brilliant free thinking people in the world Ah yes, and you are one of those brilliant, free-thinking people I assume. One of the enlightened ones, who sees the folly of government and the glory of anarchy?
- pyre 13y agoAlways reminds me of this: https://xkcd.com/610/ https://xkcd.com/610/
- samstave 13y agoNice ad hominem -- so lets discuss; first though I'm posting from my phone so this first post will be brief: There are soon to be 7 billion people on this earth, comparatively, yes, I've won the genetic lottery... But that has nothing to do with the fact that there is an active war on the minds of humanity. If you want references and are completely devoid of any understanding of history I'd be happy to provide some sources, but lets hear you actually chime in on the meat of my comment as opposed to you're sophomoric attempt at discrediting what I said.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- DanBC 13y ago> There are soon to be 7 billion people on this earth A minor nit, but we're estimated to be over 7 billion already.
- justin66 13y agoYou didn't actually contradict the portion of my text that you quoted. People really do believe the alternative to having governments is the Hobbsian state of nature, or something close to it. I did not comment on how people arrive at that belief. It's not totally crazy to think that Hobbes being the foundation of western political philosophy might have something to do with it, so there's your "indoctrination," I guess.
- Volpe 13y agoWhy do you "believe" in rights? They are literally constructed by us, indoctrinated even.
- oleganza 13y agoRights are fantasy. 95% of your life is anarchy: voluntary relationships with others based on like/dislike, mutual respect and agreements. It's not based on rights, laws or other abstractions. Rights do not exist. Individual agreements do. Here is a proof: I respect any belief of rights. Your belief may be different from mine. If you peacefully respect my disagreement the same way I respect yours, then "rights" are meaningless in resolving conflicts. If we have the same idea of rights, they are irrelevant. If you force me to accept your vision of rights, you only prove that rights do not help: you abandon reason and take out the gun. There are no rights, only peace or violence. QED.
- Volpe 13y agoActually it is. Because everyone (the majority at least) believe in rights.
- oleganza 13y agoIf everyone believes in different rights, what's the point? Anyway, what's the purpose of rights? Is it to give a sanction for violence to yourself when you think you deserve it? If you are not using violence, but do a conversation, then it is only reason that you use, not particular rights.