4 ms·
That reminded me of a famous libertarian quote: "If one rejects laissez faire on account of man's fallibility and moral weakness, one must for the same reason a
by dmix 13y ago
That reminded me of a famous libertarian quote: "If one rejects laissez faire on account of man's fallibility and moral weakness, one must for the same reason also reject every kind of government action." - Mises
If humans are full of logical fallacies and poor decision making, just making a collection of humans and giving them unlimited power does not make the logical fallacies and poor decision making go away. It can often makes it much more harmful.
But then it comes down to who has the better information (individuals/organizations or politicians) and who is more capable of acting on that information in humanities best interest.
- tokipin 13y agoi don't think it plays out like this in practice, for the reason that a government has to at least pretend it's for the people and there's at least some measure of accountability. the alternative is very, very different and I think libertarians really underestimate how evil and creative and corrupt people can be. there is a reason we have various regulations regarding child labor, for example. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Child_labor#Early_1900s http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Child_labor#Early_1900s
- burntsushi 13y ago> the alternative is very, very different and I think libertarians really underestimate how evil and creative and corrupt people can be The entire point of the parent post is that we don't underestimate the corruption that humans are capable of achieving when given power. Hence the revocation of a monopoly on the use of legitimized coercion.
- tokipin 13y ago... in exchange for a system without even the pretension of accountability
- burntsushi 13y agoYou did not respond to the central point of my comment. I will respond anyway. Firms sell goods to buyers. If buyers stop buying said goods from a particular firm, that firm is going to be in trouble unless they get the buyers to start buying again. Seems like at least a "pretension of accountability". Accountability exists in forms other than democracy.
- colanderman 13y agoYou must know that humans are very fickle creatures. People buy clothes and food from poorly-regulated industries all the time, not because none of them can be made to care about the conditions under which these goods are manufactured, but because not all of them can be made to care constantly. If only a small group of people are ever interested enough to personally fund regulation, how can such free-market "regulation" effectively ensure good working conditions and food safety? Government solves this problem by low-pass-filtering the fickleness, thus ensuring continued funding.
- burntsushi 13y agoMy initial comment was pointing out that we libertarians very explicitly don't underestimate corruption; which factors very strongly in why we view centralized power in the form of legitimized coercion as A Bad Thing. My follow-up to an off-topic but related comment was that accountability exists in freed markets; just not in the way you might be used to in democratic societies. My intention is not to defend freed markets from every possible criticism. There is plenty of literature out there that does that much better than I could already. A nice place to start is David Friedman's "The Machinery of Freedom" for pragmatic details. [1] Just as accountability can come in many different shapes and sizes, so too can regulation. The only requirement is a bit of imagination. [1] - http://daviddfriedman.com/The_Machinery_of_Freedom_.pdf http://daviddfriedman.com/The_Machinery_of_Freedom_.pdf
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- rayiner 13y agoThe alternative to a system of monopolized coercion isn't the absence of coercion, it's the diffusion of coercive violence.
- burntsushi 13y agoI've never claimed or believed otherwise. The absence of coercion would be Utopian. Also, you left out a key word: legitimized. It's important and absolutely essential to my point.
- rayiner 13y agoIn the absence of government, all violent becomes de facto legitimate, as it is in the state of nature. It is meaningless to call something "illegitimate" versus "legitimate" when you have no recourse to stop "illegitimate" actions.
- burntsushi 13y ago> The difference between legitimized coercion and de-facto coercion is a distinction without a difference. It would be appreciated if you made this fundamental disagreement clear when responding. It literally makes no sense to speak of anything else on this topic if we disagree on this point. Legitimized coercion is a concept that distinguishes organizations governing an arbitrary geographic location and its people/property and the natural coercion that arises from conflicts between individuals. The former is permitted by the law of the land (whatever it may be); the latter is not. I believe the distinction is worth making. More than that, I believe the former can be scrubbed out while the latter cannot. EDIT to address your EDIT > In the absence of government, all violent becomes de facto legitimate, as it is in the state of nature. I have never seen any libertarian philosophy use the word "legitimate" to mean "natural" in this context. I certainly am not. My hope is that the other part of this comment clarifies.
- Zigurd 13y agoYou are setting up a straw man. One level of government can lose legitimacy or the ability to operate without government at other levels losing the ability to perform.
- rektide 13y agoCivics class never taught me about "unlimited power," so I'm having a little bit of difficulty getting spun up with the premise. The conclusion though doesn't share my outlook. The actual activities are not interesting to me. What is interesting to me is insuring ongoing changing activity and new things being tried. Libertarianism fails as badly as most government fails in this regard, permitting the accrual of power by corporate bodies with, like government, interest vested chiefly in their own self propogation. The role that is unspoken, not what government is, but what I want it to be: to insure no one keeps others from trying actions to better themselves. It's not about actions, about information in acting, it's about being empowered to be able to act, to try things. I see this as a macroscopic look, whereas I see your concerns with decision making, the libertarian/government question, as microscopic, focused on only one particular thing at a time.
- jivatmanx 13y agoI don't believe that corporations are libertarian, largely because "limited liability" completely divorces them from the responsibility of the individual, which forms the basis of everything in the libertarian system. I don't see any problem with partnerships and sole proprietorships, though. As with any system, these people need to be ethical. But corporations have a sort of legally forced amorality.
- betterunix 13y ago"If humans are full of logical fallacies and poor decision making, just making a collection of humans and giving them unlimited power does not make the logical fallacies and poor decision making go away. It can often makes it much more harmful." You know, this is not some novel insight. This has been known for a long time: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magna_carta https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magna_carta
- dmix 13y agoIndeed, the real underlying problem isn't mass surveillance, the problem is the states ability to give themselves unlimited power through a seemingly legal process: "The government has granted itself power it is not entitled to." - Edward Snowden Which is quite possibly the predictable outcome of every government that hasn't had a revolution or major political upheaval for an extended periods of time. Self-interest is not just a function of markets.
- wybo 13y agoAm I the only one here who can see the fallacy in this? Government does not have unlimited power. Government is accountable, mostly democratically controlled power. It is, if there is a proper democracy (which there is in much of Western Europe, not the US so much) the exact opposite of unlimited power. Anarchy on the other hand is (slightly) diffused unlimited power. And also power only dependent on wealth. And without anyone to protect the (financially) weak, without any laws or government-backed justice, this diffused power is much worse than anything a well-functioning democracy would come up with...
- oleganza 13y agoLook into your own words and try to decipher them one by one: "Government is accountable, mostly democratically controlled power." What is "government" in practice? What does it mean to be "accountable" in practice? What is "democratically controlled"? And which "power" are we talking about? Here's my rough take on deciphering this statement: 1. Government - a group of people that can employ violence which is disallowed for some other group of people. Some number of people outside the government will look at some violent action and think it's totally justified. But if the same action is done by non-government person, they will feel bad and call somebody to prevent it. 2. Being accountable: bear the consequences of one's actions. If a dude kills a dude, he will be kicked hard and put in special house for the rest of his days. If, however, government kills a dude, there are many sorts of laws (pieces of paper) that describe to public (stupidly watching from outside) that certain killings are okay. Like, if you are in uniform and in Iraq, you can kill people left and right (under strict "protocol" of course). Does the existence of some sort of "protocol" written by some lunatics make killings "controlled" and "accountable"? How nuts is that? Here's a test for your sanity: if you like your democratic government, I have nothing against it. I will never ever intervene and disallow you to pay to your senator/city hall/party/etc. I respect your right to choose the way to live. Will you give me the same respect to have my own opinion and to act on it? I don't want to support any government action. I don't want my money to be taken via taxation or inflation. Will you allow me to act on my beliefs peacefully just like I allow you?
- wybo 13y ago