7 ms·
>which means that there was effectively no relationship at all. This is in large part because Nutt's research is entirely fraudulent. C.f. my previous analysis
by Alex3917 13y ago
>which means that there was effectively no relationship at all.
This is in large part because Nutt's research is entirely fraudulent. C.f. my previous analysis here:
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4044431 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4044431
- Nursie 13y agoFraud you say? Perhaps you should inform Imperial College, one of the UK's most prestigious science and engineering institutes, where he currently holds a chair in neuropsychopharmacology.
- jessriedel 13y agoIf you follow Alex3917's link, you'll see he argues that Nutt is intellectually dishonest. That's of course different than being regular dishonest (i.e. fraudulent).
- Nursie 13y agoI think if that was really the case then IC would still want to know, I wasn't kidding about them being one of the most prestigious institutions in the UK.
- jessriedel 13y agoIndeed, having been offered an academic job at Imperial, I'm partial to thinking of it as a place of high prestige. The thing about intellectual dishonesty is that it's not provable, and in fact usually isn't even noticed by people who agree with the conclusion. If you read the link, you'll see that these allegations are hardly the kind that would lead a university to remove a professor.
- flyinRyan 13y agoWe don't need to follow the link. This comment said the research was "entirely fraudulent". Amusing that his actual argument said something rather different.
- jessriedel 13y agoPoor choice of words, but I don't think that's enough to justify ignoring his criticism.
- JumpCrisscross 13y ago"The full methodology isn't actually published anywhere." I believe it is: http://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(10)61462-6/abstract http://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-67.... Is a panel of experts providing views on an objective criteria the most satisfying solution? No. But they are open about the method, the scoring system, and data used to set assumptions. Plus, it beats "experts" legislating based on subjective, opaque critera. "The rankings are creating by combining a lot of different factors that don't have anything to do with each other, e.g. by combining harm to the user with harm to society" Nutt et all advocate considering the harm done to society by drugs, versus individuals, since it is at the society-wide level that we regulate. In any case, the data are provided to allow for one to pry apart the local and global harms. Here is a chart allowing you to, visually, do just that: http://www.economist.com/blogs/dailychart/2010/11/drugs_cause_most_harm http://www.economist.com/blogs/dailychart/2010/11/drugs_caus.... "The harms for drugs are measured as they are typically used, rather than correcting for things like differences in demographic and route of administration." In his book, he spends a good deal of time addressing routes of administration, pointing out that "the health impacts of a drug can vary enormously depending on how it’s consumed". He is similarly expansive on the role of "setting" and culture in vulnerability and harm potential. "The harms of the drugs caused by prohibition are not accounted for." I thought he went quite extensively into the War on Drugs and how it wasn't "obviously the wrong thing to try in the 1970s, but today it is clearly doing more harm than good", that the "'drugs problem' needs radical rethinking as a public-health crisis rather than a moral crusade." He also uses the example of Portugal to show how legalisation can reduce indirect drug harms. "They're not accounting for the benefits of drug use, only the harms." Nutt is presently at the forefront of the British effort to de-regulate drugs. Further, harm reduction should first focus on clarifying risks.
- Alex3917 13y ago> I believe it is So do you feel like, after reading that, that you could replicate the study and get the same results? Because having read that I understand that the scores came from a committee, and are supposedly an an interval scale, but beyond that I have zero clue as to how they came up with the scores that they did. Also, as far as I can tell this is just a new analysis of his old data, and the methodology for that is still equally (or more) lacking. > the data are provided to allow for one to pry apart the local and global harms Yeah, but the local and global harms are both wrong, and combined they are even more wrong. You can break it down all you want, but it's still wrong at every single level. (E.g. do you really believe that, say, alcohol causes 2.5x as much harm to users than butane? And is it even meaningful to make that comparison in the first place?) > In his book, he spends a good deal of time addressing routes of administration, pointing out that "the health impacts of a drug can vary enormously depending on how it’s consumed". Then doesn't this only show that he knows his own study is invalid? > I thought he went quite extensively into the War on Drugs I was only talking about the validity of the study, not the book.
- bencollier49 13y agoWhoah, libel alert! Worth looking into this: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/English_defamation_law http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/English_defamation_law