5 ms·
Besides, I don't care how "legal" they make it or how much oversight and checks they put in place. At the end of the day, they're still collecting everything.
by mtgx 13y ago
Besides, I don't care how "legal" they make it or how much oversight and checks they put in place.
At the end of the day, they're still collecting everything. And I don't want that to happen. Is that too much to ask for? Google got in so much trouble over collecting Wi-fi data, but if the governments do it, and a lot more, it's fine? Surely there have been, and will continue to be alternative solutions to stopping terrorists besides collecting everyone's information en-masse.
Also, what about the foreigners? Politicians, judges, activists, everyone is fair game for spying? I don't want to live in such a world. That's can't be the future.
Obama tries to make it seem like this is the "balance" between privacy and security. This nowhere close to a "balance". They're getting everything. How is that a "balance" for privacy? If that's the balance, I don't think I want to know what they have in mind for when they really only care about security.
- Sven7 13y agoHave you forgotten yes we can...this is the guy, a professor of constitutional law at Harvard no less, that accepted the peace prize, while running two wars and with a 'kill list' in his pocket, so don't worry Obama can balance anything. I hope they give him another Nobel for just being so awesome.
- pfortuny 13y agoThere is always the Nobel of Literature... Do not despair. They are really putting a lot of effort into it.
- B0Z 13y agoThey look like bigger fools now for giving him the Nobel than they did when he hadn't accomplished anything.
- ihsw 13y agoThe 'Nobel' as you put it encompasses multiple fields, most of which are based in sciences proven by empirical analysis. The 'Peace' prize has historically been controversial as contributions to peace are inherently political in nature. Please don't disregard the other prizes: they represent real, quantifiable achievements. Peace is a simple result from political policies, but chemistry, physics, and medicine have a rich history of research and application. Nobel Prize categories: * Physics * Chemistry * Literature * Peace * Physiology * Medicine * Economic Sciences
- rdl 13y agoThe Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel is actually distinct from the "real" Nobels. It is also even more of a joke than the Peace Prize, often.
- ihsw 13y agoI would rather not argue about 'economic sciences' at this time, that subject is usually far more politicized than 'peace.'
- rplacd 13y agoThe Prize in Literature's never free of the usual political recriminations either - there's a fine line between endorsing a message and acknowledging execution (and the fact that the ends an author sets plays an important role as well) that's never been fully articulated.
- mzs 13y agoUofC not Harvard
- munin 13y ago> And I don't want that to happen. Is that too much to ask for? civilization and government are way more nuanced than this. the answer to your question is yes, yes it is too much to ask for. you probably don't want to pay taxes, receive speeding tickets, or be subject to laws but you are...
- andy_ppp 13y agoI always find it funny that taxes are only for the poor as far as I'm aware. In reality speeding tickets aren't for reckless driving they are for funding police departments. The laws we have are and have always been designed to require whole teams of specialised people at great expense to debate whether, in fact you are or aren't in contradiction of them (insert campaign for plain terms legal messaging that is binding). In fact the law is so complex now that if you can pay for the smartest people to get you off the hook on technicalities. We didn't get onto corporate power and influence in this thread (yet) but you get the idea. Is shut up and take it an option anymore when it's looking increasingly likely that governments corrupt and subvert real public debate (infiltrating organisations like Greenpeace with trouble makers), monitor everything you do on the internet and can trace it all back to you, and should the policies change under, say a Nixon, McCarthy or worse you could find the apparatus on your doorstep for a making everyone a suspected terrorist fairly soon. Turnkey Tyranny is exactly the correct terminology. The truth is you can't trust the NSA to do the right thing and anyone with any common sense can see even in very very recent American history the powers of the state were massively abused. Freedom, democracy, these always have just been words to sugar coats a system by the rich for the rich. I the more you look at the system the more you realise that Chomsky is right about power and that you and me all need a fairer slice of the cake (both monetarily and in terms of our say in how government happens). What is good is that the means of production is coming back to the people; I can see the rich and powerful being very scared indeed by this.
- jaekwon 13y agoHow are the means of production coming back to the people? I'd like to know, because that's where the hope is.
- solnyshok 13y ago2013.06.30 Your monthly privacy balance calculated by NSA: ZERO.
- jaekwon 13y agoThe grand "balance" has been under our nose the entire time, as laid out by prof Lessig, also of Harvard. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5964883 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5964883 I think it is ignorance that is causing this. Specifically, ignorance of the nature of information, and maybe a propensity of lawyers to attempt to "balance" security with law, and thereby destroy security. Read my other comment here about Palantir's marketing material, how they advertise "immutable audit trails", and how that's supposed to provide transparency and whatever... and a link to a paper that says it doesn't work. Of course it doesn't work. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5965317 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5965317 I don't blog, so somebody else should compile this and publish it.