2 ms·
The debunking has been debunked: Oct. 31 UPDATE The authors have introduced several revisions to their paper, available at the same URL as before. The critic
by lisper 13y ago
The debunking has been debunked:
Oct. 31 UPDATE
The authors have introduced several revisions to their paper, available at the same URL as before.
The criticism below may be outdated in part or in full.
- qwertzlcoatl 13y agoI don't know if I would necessarily call that debunked. It only means the previously debunked introduced revisions to amplify their original points and the debunkers disclaimed that their debunk may be outdated in part or in full. Or not at all. I wouldn't necessarily assume that it's a forfeit. It could just mean the debunkers didn't want to invest more time into it. It's weird that they didn't link to the revisions though.