4 ms·
This statement indicates real progress and is a fantastic step in the right direction It read, to me, like nothing but a blowhard spouting hot-air and empty rh
by mindcrime 13y ago
This statement indicates real progress and is a fantastic step in the right direction
It read, to me, like nothing but a blowhard spouting hot-air and empty rhetoric, while desperately hoping to spike morale and discourage the next Edward Snowden from doing The Right Thing.
I mean, it's already well established that the NSA operates with almost zero effective oversight: given that the FISA courts are nothing but a rubber-stamp, Congress is lied to and accepts the lies - or engages in willful ignorance - about this whole situation (well, up until it breaks to the public thanks to Snowden), and the NSA operate under their own interpretation of the law anyway.
There's no real judicial oversight of the NSA, there's no Congressional oversight, so that leaves the Executive branch... and does anybody trust them to exercise restraint???
I think he's petrified that Snowden's heroic leadership in this area will inspire more leaks. One can only hope.
No doubt.
- pvnick 13y agoI agree with what you're saying, but the mere existence of this letter is indicative of the fear gripping those in power whom would rather their illegitimate authorities remain a secret.
- embolism 13y ago...given that the FISA courts are nothing but a rubber-stamp How is this 'given'? Do we have any evidence of this whatsoever?
- mindcrime 13y agoIt's been publicly revealed that they only deny something like .03% of all requests.[1] If that isn't a "rubber stamp" then I don't know what is. Of course they have a response to that "Well, the requests are so well done that there are very few that there is any reason to deny them" but that doesn't pass the "smell test" as far as I'm concerned. [1]: https://www.google.com/search?q=fisa+.03%25 https://www.google.com/search?q=fisa+.03%25
- embolism 13y agobut that doesn't pass the "smell test" as far as I'm concerned. So it's gone from a 'given' to 'in your opinion'. It's easy to explain the 0.03 figure if there are a large number of routine boilerplate small scale requests. It seems highly plausible that this is the case. The fact that the figure is plausible doesn't rule out the possibility that abuses might be being rubberstamped, but the truth is that we don't know, not that it's a 'given'.
- mindcrime 13y agoAnything can be argued... I take it as a given that we aren't living inside a computer generated simulation known as The Matrix. But somebody, somewhere, could make a case that we might be. But for all practical purposes, it is a given that we don't. For all practical purposes, it is a given that the FISA courts are a rubber stamp. Just because there is some amazingly-low-probability and unlikely scenario to explain that away, is no reason not to accept the utter and obvious truth.
- embolism 13y agoSo obvious to you that it would seem that you need no evidence at all, other than your preconceptions.
- ScottBurson 13y ago.03% is a disturbingly small number. I don't agree that it constitutes "no evidence at all".
- embolism 13y agoWithout knowing anything about the nature of the requests it doesn't tell us anything. Imagine there are something like 800 actual terrorist suspects - people who have been identified via human intelligence, e.g. Known to have met with terrorist cells, visited training camps, etc. Of 10,000 requests, it's easily possible that the vast majority could be simply following up on the immediate network surrounding those people - e.g. 'Suspect X called person Y, person Y is new to us, let us check whether person Y is linked to other suspects by phone or email'. Requests like that would be made using a boilerplate form, and would be correctly rubber-stamped as long as they were closely connected to suspects identified by other means. We should expect many of those kinds of requests to be being generated every day by analysts. The .03 needs to be put in the context of the number of non-routine requests that are being approved. It doesn't seem at all unreasonable that for every 10,000 boilerplate followups generated by desk clerk analysts, there are 10 more speculative ones generated as a result of more specific investigations, and of these 30% are deemed overreaching. The vast majority of requests are likely to be boring inquiries generated by bureaucrats following procedure, rather than Jack Bauer like rogues constantly overstepping their authority.