5 ms·
How does this differ from the normal male experience in video games? "Go get butt-raped" would hardly be an uncommon thing for a male player to hear. Wouldn't
by yummyfajitas 13y ago
How does this differ from the normal male experience in video games? "Go get butt-raped" would hardly be an uncommon thing for a male player to hear.
Wouldn't it be sexist for gamers to tone down the trash talk simply because a woman is playing?
- EliRivers 13y agoThe normal male experience involves that kind of talk in reaction to what you do. It's the reaction to your actions in the game, or to your own comments. The normal female experience involves that kind of talk in reaction to what you are. Being female. Doesn't matter what you do, or what you say; you get a constant barrage of abuse, hatred, and threat of rape. For being female and daring to play a game.
- DanBC 13y ago> the first thing I hear over the headphones was: “Oh great.. a girl player? F*ck. Are you serious? Let’s kick her and hope we get someone else.” The first thing I hear when I log into games is not "Oh great... a boy player? Fuck. Are you serious? Let's kick her and hope we get someone else." > Wouldn't it be sexist for gamers to tone down the trash talk simply because a woman is playing? Did you seriously just ask if it would be sexist to not be sexist?
- yummyfajitas 13y agoThe first thing I hear when I log into games is not "Oh great... a boy player? Fuck. Are you serious? Let's kick her and hope we get someone else." I've heard various things of this nature, for various non-gendered reasons. Give a team any reason to think you are either a) a bot or b) not good and they will boot you. Did you seriously just ask if it would be sexist to not be sexist? Sexism is treating people differently based on their gender. So yes, I assert it would be sexist to say to men "jail rape u gayayay nigz" but to tell women "tally ho madam, you have soundly defeated me."
- Lewisham 13y agoI understand your point re: definitions of sexism, but I think EliRivers gets it right here in regards to performance versus person. And it's different to be on the receiving end when you're the threatened minority. It just is.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoit's different to be on the receiving end when you're the threatened minority. It just is. Only if you choose to make it so. In my last job (not in the US), I was the minority. People made jokes about Americans (e.g. "no American jokes - they sue") along with many other groups. I chose not to make it a big deal (being the oppressed minority is boring to me) so it wasn't.
- DanBC 13y ago> it's different to be on the receiving end when you're the threatened minority. It just is. > Only if you choose to make it so. The perfect demonstration of why HN is a hateful place to discuss sexism, racism, etc. "See, women, it's your fault. Just get over it already."
- PommeDeTerre 13y agoIf "sexism" is being considered as treating somebody differently because of their gender, then I think that yummyfajitas has a point. If the typical male-to-male interaction within a given community involves making sexist remarks now and then, then a male who doesn't make sexist remarks while in the presence of females would be treating them differently due to their gender. That in itself could be seen as a form of "sexism". After all, if everyone were to be treated equally in that context, then sexist remarks would be made regardless of whether the other people present were male or female. Political correctness is often contradictory or self-defeating in this sort of a way. Those who are against "intolerance" end up inherently becoming intolerant themselves, because they do not tolerate intolerance, for example. Or those who single out, target and speak out against bullies end up engaging in a form of bullying behavior themselves.
- jiggy2011 13y agoBut if it's guy -> guy remarks it's probably difficult to be "sexist" though I guess that is a semantic argument. Though if the insults are gender neutral "lol noob scrub" then I guess it might be unfair to expect preferential treatment because of gender.
- Dewie 13y agoThere is no contradiction in being sexist towards your own gender.
- 127 13y agoGirl players on average are worse than boy players. Yes, this is a stereotype. But a stereotype based on experience instead of prejudice. Don't like it? Get more girls playing computer games and being good at it.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- officemonkey 13y agoCongratulations, you've just come up with the same justification that every bigot comes up with. "Blacks are on average more criminal than whites. Yes, this is a stereotype. But a stereotype based on experience instead of prejudice. Don't like it? Get a job, negro." "Fags are more AIDS-ridden than straight people. Yes, this is a stereotype. But a stereotype based on experience instead of prejudice. Don't like it? Don't have butt-sex, faggot." Shall I go on?
- 127 13y agoIt does not help to be mad at reality. Reality does not care. Ironically I'm also a victim of the same generalization process. It is assumed that most people can't separate logic of reality and actions based on emotional morality. When I can, it is assumed that I can not, and discussions derail always in this highly predictable fashion by people calling me names.
- officemonkey 13y ago>Ironically I'm also a victim of the same generalization process. It's not ironic at all. Oftentimes people who have been oppressed become in turn oppressors.
- officemonkey 13y agoSaying "rape" is just a part of gaming culture is hardly a defense.