3 ms·
There are different sorts of creativity. Most mathematicians would probably not do very well in the open-ended creativity of writing a novel say. One type of
by amichail 18y ago
There are different sorts of creativity.
Most mathematicians would probably not do very well in the open-ended creativity of writing a novel say.
One type of creativity is goal driven (e.g., prove this theorem), while the other not so much (e.g., write an interesting novel).
- Retric 18y agoHow is "write an interesting novel" not a goal? I was once a fairly talented writer, but coding is less effort and on average better paying, so that's the path I chose. In the end I really don't see that big of a difference in the creative process. Granted, once you focus on a specific path for several years you change your relative strengths so it's easy to confuse innate talent with effort.
- amichail 18y agoIt's a very vague goal. Moreover, there is no such thing as a "wrong" novel.
- joecode 18y agoWell, there is: One that doesn't express your viewpoint well, for example. It depends on precisely what you are trying to accomplish in writing it, of course. Mathematical proofs require a lot of creativivty, too. There are many different ways to prove a given theorem, and it takes quite a bit of imagination to come up with one. I'd say the main difference is emotional. Being creative in the humanities requires a certain emotional madness, which can be especially debilitating. Scientists and mathematicians mostly just need to be obsessive, focused, and good at ferreting out hard to recognize patterns.
- biohacker42 18y agoI'd say the main difference is emotional. Yes, and I'd go further and say that it is specifically a much greater then average empathy intensity which leads to great and moving art. And that can hurt emotionally just as much as being an elite athlete can hurt you physically.
- amichail 18y agoThis is a subset of open-ended creativity. Another subset would be web 2.0 say and that rarely leads to "great and moving art".
- amichail 18y agoI'd say the main difference is emotional. What does that mean exactly and why does it not apply to mathematicians?
- joecode 18y agoMathematicians typically deal with abstract problems that have no direct relation to human feelings. Novelists, artists, and social scientists typically do the opposite.
- asciilifeform 18y ago> Most mathematicians would probably not do very well in the open-ended creativity of writing a novel Lewis Carroll
- silentOpen 18y agoMost mathematicians are Lewis Carroll?!