3 ms·
I think the author's point is that economists are split on one of the most important issues. In that sense, it's not unlike physicists being split on the relat
by jessriedel 13y ago
I think the author's point is that economists are split on one of the most important issues. In that sense, it's not unlike physicists being split on the relative value of string theory. The only difference is that the economic issue is politically charged, so the tribal forces unsure the split endures. For physics, there are strong bandwagon incentives for everyone to do the same thing, so you swing from a huge multi-decade investment in an untested theory, to a complete vanishing of strings jobs.
In both cases, it's not the fact that something is unknown that's the problem. It's that smart people can't come to a Bayesian agreement, so it's a flag that people are being massively irrational.
- jamesaguilar 13y agoI wouldn't call string theory an issue of major importance with respect to physics compared to monetary policy in economics. I'm not a physics buff, but my understanding is string theory hasn't yet made any predictions that would result in different outcomes than the standard model. On the other hand, the variety of monetary policy viewpoints among economists would certainly make different predictions, and their magnitude would be significant. More analogous would be if physicists were split on whether gravity exists.
- jessriedel 13y agoNo, gravity is something for which there is overwhelming, unambiguous evidence. Macroeconomics is something that by its very nature is difficult to gather convincing evidence about. (No controlled experiments, very small observational data set.) Strings is much more like a macroeconomic question, because neither can be definitively tested. How to formulate a quantum theory of gravity is the most important outstanding question in fundamental physics. Strings is the best guess. Policy-wise, the effects of government spending is the most important outstanding question in economics. I think it's pretty analogous actually.
- RockyMcNuts 13y agoexcept economists aren't actually split on the effects of government spending in general, just on the relative importance of those effects in specific situations. Wikipedia's collection of unsolved problems in economics - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_unsolved_problems_in_economics http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_unsolved_problems_in_ec...