4 ms·
The "100 mile from the border Constitution-free zone" (actually 150 miles I believe) has more of a basis in reality than you acknowledge. The Border Patrol is
by btilly 13y ago
The "100 mile from the border Constitution-free zone" (actually 150 miles I believe) has more of a basis in reality than you acknowledge.
The Border Patrol is able to operate in that zone, and they operate under somewhat different rules than other forms of law enforcement. Furthermore they sometimes interpret their ability to operate somewhat more generously than a court would agree to. So while in theory they can't do what they sometimes do, in practice they are the ones there with guns and they do it anyways.
(In particular the court has ruled that they can stop and question everyone on a public thoroughfare because the intrusion is short in duration. I've seen documented cases where agents in the field clearly believed that they could question for as long as they wanted to question. The reasoning of the court would not support that conclusion...)
So, very much not really a constitution-free zone. But certainly the border patrol walks closer to the edge of constitutional protections that we take for granted.
- tptacek 13y agoThe problem with the Internet meme is that to be valid, as I understand it based on my reading, the search has to be incident to an actual recent border crossing. Merely living in NYC does not subject you to routine searches under the border search exemption. But that's what the meme says!
- rayiner 13y agoIts even worse! They call it a "Constitution-free" zone as if it has any connection with other rights.
- reverius42 13y agoLiving in NYC might not subject you to routine searches, but that seems to be more of an issue of practicality than legality. Living in southern Arizona does in fact subject you to routine searches. I have been personally stopped near the AZ/Mexico border (maybe 15 miles away), questioned before being allowed to drive away, and I have never actually crossed that particular border.
- rdouble 13y agoThis is true. My father and brother were recently stopped near Bisbee. I guess my brother has been stopped in New Mexico 3 times.
- tptacek 13y agoHave you ever watched any of the videos of the guys refusing to answer even the simplest questions at those checkpoints?
- reverius42 13y agoNo, I haven't. What happens?
- tptacek 13y agoNothing. CBP asks questions. The drivers refuse to answer. CBP gets their supervisor. One guy asks the supervisor for proof of his citizenship. All the drivers get waved through within a couple minutes. They key appears to be not to pull to the side of the road for extended questioning, because as long as you're in the main lane, you're holding up traffic.
- wavefunction 13y agoPerhaps you should experience it for yourself as I and others have, and see whether it remains just an internet meme.
- btilly 13y agoI believe that your reading is incorrect. The border patrol can and does regularly put up blockades on major thoroughfares, stops everyone, and potentially could choose to search anyone that they reasonably suspect was recently out of the country or is illegal. This is not hypothetical. I personally have encountered this when I was stopped and questioned both on the I-5 just north of San Diego, and on secondary streets in Los Angeles. Neither time did they choose to search me, but I saw others that I believe were searched.
- tptacek 13y agoI believe you can refuse to comply with those checkpoints. As an aside, the ACLU's "Constitution free zone" campaign isn't referring to citizenship checks†; it's referring to a DHS employee's insistence that being within N miles of anything that could be considered a border subjects you to warrantless border searches. Which, again, is something you can find a SCOTUS case refuting. † Unfortunately, it's now apparently the law of the land that the police can demand identification from citizens, which is one of the great BS decisions of the last 20 years.
- wiml 13y agoWhat's the case?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]